I am working on an assignment that requires me to use the trapz function in MATLAB in order to evaluate an integral. I believe I have written the code correctly, but the program returns answers that are wildly incorrect. I am attempting to find the integral of e^(-x^2) from 0 to 1.
x = linspace(0,1,2000);
y = zeros(1,2000);
for iCnt = 1:2000
y(iCnt) = e.^(-(x(iCnt)^2));
end
a = trapz(y);
disp(a);
This code currently returns
1.4929e+03
What am I doing incorrectly?
You need to just specify also the x values:
x = linspace(0,1,2000);
y = exp(-x.^2);
a = trapz(x,y)
a =
0.7468
More details:
First of all, in MATLAB you can use vectors to avoid for-loops for performing operation on arrays (vectors). So the whole four lines of code
y = zeros(1,2000);
for iCnt = 1:2000
y(iCnt) = exp(-(x(iCnt)^2));
end
will be translated to one line:
y = exp(-x.^2)
You defined x = linspace(0,1,2000) it means that you need to calculate the integral of the given function in range [0 1]. So there is a mistake in the way you calculate y which returns it to be in range [1 2000] and that is why you got the big number as the result.
In addition, in MATLAB you should use exp there is not function as e in MATLAB.
Also, if you plot the function in the range, you will see that the result makes sense because the whole page has an area of 1x1.
Related
I'm trying to implement my own fft in MATLAB the following way:
function z=FastFourierTransform(x)
N=length(x);
if N <= 1
z = x;
else
range = (0:N/2-1);
e = exp(-2i*pi/N).^range;
odd = FastFourierTransform(x(1:2:N-1));
even = e.*FastFourierTransform(x(2:2:N));
z = [even + odd, even - odd];
end
return
Turns out, there seems to be somthing wrong with it since it does not give the same result as the built in function provided by MATLAB.
I'm calling the function the following way:
N = 128;
x = 32*pi*(1:N)'/N;
u = cos(x/16).*(1+sin(x/16));
actualSolution = fft(u);
actualSolution
mySolution = FastFourierTransform(u)';
mySolution
actualSolution
mySolution
The numbers are always the same but they sometimes differ in their sign.
You have swapped odd and even.
Using this line to compute z will produce the correct FFT:
z = [odd + even, odd - even];
My guess is that the source of confusion is that Matlab uses 1-based indices, and the pseudocode you used to implement the function uses 0-based indices.
I have this task to create a script that acts similarly to normcdf on matlab.
x=linspace(-5,5,1000); %values for x
p= 1/sqrt(2*pi) * exp((-x.^2)/2); % THE PDF for the standard normal
t=cumtrapz(x,p); % the CDF for the standard normal distribution
plot(x,t); %shows the graph of the CDF
The problem is when the t values are assigned to 1:1000 instead of -5:5 in increments. I want to know how to assign the correct x values, that is -5:5,1000 to the t values output? such as when I do t(n) I get the same result as normcdf(n).
Just to clarify: the problem is I cannot simply say t(-5) and get result =1 as I would in normcdf(1) because the cumtrapz calculated values are assigned to x=1:1000 instead of -5 to 5.
Updated answer
Ok, having read your comment; here is how to do what you want:
x = linspace(-5,5,1000);
p = 1/sqrt(2*pi) * exp((-x.^2)/2);
cdf = cumtrapz(x,p);
q = 3; % Query point
disp(normcdf(q)) % For reference
[~,I] = min(abs(x-q)); % Find closest index
disp(cdf(I)) % Show the value
Sadly, there is no matlab syntax which will do this nicely in one line, but if you abstract finding the closest index into a different function, you can do this:
cdf(findClosest(x,q))
function I = findClosest(x,q)
if q>max(x) || q<min(x)
warning('q outside the range of x');
end
[~,I] = min(abs(x-q));
end
Also; if you are certain that the exact value of the query point q exists in x, you can just do
cdf(x==q);
But beware of floating point errors though. You may think that a certain range outght to contain a certain value, but little did you know it was different by a tiny roundoff erorr. You can see that in action for example here:
x1 = linspace(0,1,1000); % Range
x2 = asin(sin(x1)); % Ought to be the same thing
plot((x1-x2)/eps); grid on; % But they differ by rougly 1 unit of machine precision
Old answer
As far as I can tell, running your code does reproduce the result of normcdf(x) well... If you want to do exactly what normcdf does them use erfc.
close all; clear; clc;
x = linspace(-5,5,1000);
cdf = normcdf(x); % Result of normcdf for comparison
%% 1 Trapezoidal integration of normal pd
p = 1/sqrt(2*pi) * exp((-x.^2)/2);
cdf1 = cumtrapz(x,p);
%% 2 But error function IS the integral of the normal pd
cdf2 = (1+erf(x/sqrt(2)))/2;
%% 3 Or, even better, use the error function complement (works better for large negative x)
cdf3 = erfc(-x/sqrt(2))/2;
fprintf('1: Mean error = %.2d\n',mean(abs(cdf1-cdf)));
fprintf('2: Mean error = %.2d\n',mean(abs(cdf2-cdf)));
fprintf('3: Mean error = %.2d\n',mean(abs(cdf3-cdf)));
plot(x,cdf1,x,cdf2,x,cdf3,x,cdf,'k--');
This gives me
1: Mean error = 7.83e-07
2: Mean error = 1.41e-17
3: Mean error = 00 <- Because that is literally what normcdf is doing
If your goal is not not to use predefined matlab funcitons, but instead to calculate the result numerically (i.e. calculate the error function) then it's an interesting challange which you can read about for example here or in this stats stackexchange post. Just as an example, the following piece of code calculates the error function by implementing eq. 2 form the first link:
nerf = #(x,n) (-1)^n*2/sqrt(pi)*x.^(2*n+1)./factorial(n)/(2*n+1);
figure(1); hold on;
temp = zeros(size(x)); p =[];
for n = 0:20
temp = temp + nerf(x/sqrt(2),n);
if~mod(n,3)
p(end+1) = plot(x,(1+temp)/2);
end
end
ylim([-1,2]);
title('\Sigma_{n=0}^{inf} ( 2/sqrt(pi) ) \times ( (-1)^n x^{2*n+1} ) \div ( n! (2*n+1) )');
p(end+1) = plot(x,cdf,'k--');
legend(p,'n = 0','\Sigma_{n} 0->3','\Sigma_{n} 0->6','\Sigma_{n} 0->9',...
'\Sigma_{n} 0->12','\Sigma_{n} 0->15','\Sigma_{n} 0->18','normcdf(x)',...
'location','southeast');
grid on; box on;
xlabel('x'); ylabel('norm. cdf approximations');
Marcin's answer suggests a way to find the nearest sample point. It is easier, IMO, to interpolate. Given x and t as defined in the question,
interp1(x,t,n)
returns the estimated value of the CDF at x==n, for whatever value of n. But note that, for values outside the computed range, it will extrapolate and produce unreliable values.
You can define an anonymous function that works like normcdf:
my_normcdf = #(n)interp1(x,t,n);
my_normcdf(-5)
Try replacing x with 0.01 when you call cumtrapz. You can either use a vector or a scalar spacing for cumtrapz (https://www.mathworks.com/help/matlab/ref/cumtrapz.html), and this might solve your problem. Also, have you checked the original x-values? Is the problem with linspace (i.e. you are not getting the correct x vector), or with cumtrapz?
So I'm just trying to plot 4 different subplots with variations of the increments. So first would be dx=5, then dx=1, dx=0.1 and dx=0.01 from 0<=x<=20.
I tried to this:
%for dx = 5
x = 0:5:20;
fx = 2*pi*x *sin(x^2)
plot(x,fx)
however I get the error inner matrix elements must agree. Then I tried to do this,
x = 0:5:20
fx = (2*pi).*x.*sin(x.^2)
plot(x,fx)
I get a figure, but I'm not entirely sure if this would be the same as what I am trying to do initially. Is this correct?
The initial error arose since two vectors with the same shape cannot be squared (x^2) nor multiplied (x * sin(x^2)). The addition of the . before the * and ^ operators is correct here since that will perform the operation on the individual elements of the vectors. So yes, this is correct.
Also, bit of a more advanced feature, you can use an anonymous function to aid in the expressions:
fx = #(x) 2*pi.*x.*sin(x.^2); % function of x
x = 0:5:20;
plot(x,fx(x));
hold('on');
x = 0:1:20;
plot(x,fx(x));
hold('off');
Im new to MATLAB. Want to use integral2 as follows
function num = numer(x)
fun=#(p,w) prod((p+1-p).*(1-w).*exp(w.*x.*x/2))
num= integral2(fun ,0,1,0,1)
end
I get several errors starting with
Error using .*
Matrix dimensions must agree.
Error in numer>#(p,w)prod(p+(1-w).*exp(w.*x.*x/2)) (line 5)
fun=#(p,w) prod(p+(1-w).*exp(w.*x.*x/2))
Can you please tell me what I do wrong.
Thanks
From the help for integral2:
All input functions must accept arrays as input and operate
elementwise. The function Z = FUN(X,Y) must accept arrays X and Y of
the same size and return an array of corresponding values.
When x was non-scalar, your function fun did not do this. By wrapping everything in prod, the function always returned a scalar. Assuming that your prod is in the right place to begin with and taking advantage of the properties of the exponential, I believe this version will do what you need for vector x:
x = [0 1];
lx = length(x);
fun = #(p,w)(p+1-p).^lx.*(1-w).^lx.*exp(w).^sum(x.*x/2);
num = integral2(fun,0,1,0,1)
Alternatively, fun = #(p,w)(p+1-p).^lx.*(1-w).^lx.*exp(sum(x.*x/2)).^w; could be used.
I have one file with the following code:
function fx=ff(x)
fx=x;
I have another file with the following code:
function g = LaplaceTransform(s,N)
g = ff(x)*exp(-s*x);
a=0;
b=1;
If=0;
h=(b-a)/N;
If=If+g(a)*h/2+g(b)*h/2;
for i=1:(N-1)
If=If+g(a+h*i)*h;
end;
If
Whenever I run the second file, I get the following error:
Undefined function or variable 'x'.
What I am trying to do is integrate the function g between 0 and 1 using trapezoidal approximations. However, I am unsure how to deal with x and that is clearly causing problems as can be seen with the error.
Any help would be great. Thanks.
Looks like what you're trying to do is create a function in the variable g. That is, you want the first line to mean,
"Let g(x) be a function that is calculated like this: ff(x)*exp(-s*x)",
rather than
"calculate the value of ff(x)*exp(-s*x) and put the result in g".
Solution
You can create a subfunction for this
function result = g(x)
result = ff(x) * exp(-s * x);
end
Or you can create an anonymous function
g = #(x) ff(x) * exp(-s * x);
Then you can use g(a), g(b), etc to calculate what you want.
You can also use the TRAPZ function to perform trapezoidal numerical integration. Here is an example:
%# parameters
a = 0; b = 1;
N = 100; s = 1;
f = #(x) x;
%# integration
X = linspace(a,b,N);
Y = f(X).*exp(-s*X);
If = trapz(X,Y) %# value returned: 0.26423
%# plot
area(X,Y, 'FaceColor',[.5 .8 .9], 'EdgeColor','b', 'LineWidth',2)
grid on, set(gca, 'Layer','top', 'XLim',[a-0.5 b+0.5])
title('$\int_0^1 f(x) e^{-sx} \,dx$', 'Interpreter','latex', 'FontSize',14)
The error message here is about as self-explanatory as it gets. You aren't defining a variable called x, so when you reference it on the first line of your function, MATLAB doesn't know what to use. You need to either define it in the function before referencing it, pass it into the function, or define it somewhere further up the stack so that it will be accessible when you call LaplaceTransform.
Since you're trying to numerically integrate with respect to x, I'm guessing you want x to take on values evenly spaced on your domain [0,1]. You could accomplish this using e.g.
x = linspace(a,b,N);
EDIT: There are a couple of other problems here: first, when you define g, you need to use .* instead of * to multiply the elements in the arrays (by default MATLAB interprets multiplication as matrix multiplication). Second, your calls g(a) and g(b) are treating g as a function instead of as an array of function values. This is something that takes some getting used to in MATLAB; instead of g(a), you really want the first element of the vector g, which is given by g(1). Similarly, instead of g(b), you want the last element of g, which is given by g(length(g)) or g(end). If this doesn't make sense, I'd suggest looking at a basic MATLAB tutorial to get a handle on how vectors and functions are used.