What Powershell pitfalls you have fall into? :-)
Mine are:
# -----------------------------------
function foo()
{
#("text")
}
# Expected 1, actually 4.
(foo).length
# -----------------------------------
if(#($null, $null))
{
Write-Host "Expected to be here, and I am here."
}
if(#($null))
{
Write-Host "Expected to be here, BUT NEVER EVER."
}
# -----------------------------------
function foo($a)
{
# I thought this is right.
#if($a -eq $null)
#{
# throw "You can't pass $null as argument."
#}
# But actually it should be:
if($null -eq $a)
{
throw "You can't pass $null as argument."
}
}
foo #($null, $null)
# -----------------------------------
# There is try/catch, but no callstack reported.
function foo()
{
bar
}
function bar()
{
throw "test"
}
# Expected:
# At bar() line:XX
# At foo() line:XX
#
# Actually some like this:
# At bar() line:XX
foo
Would like to know yours to walk them around :-)
My personal favorite is
function foo() {
param ( $param1, $param2 = $(throw "Need a second parameter"))
...
}
foo (1,2)
For those unfamiliar with powershell that line throws because instead of passing 2 parameters it actually creates an array and passes one parameter. You have to call it as follows
foo 1 2
Another fun one. Not handling an expression by default writes it to the pipeline. Really annoying when you don't realize a particular function returns a value.
function example() {
param ( $p1 ) {
if ( $p1 ) {
42
}
"done"
}
PS> example $true
42
"done"
$files = Get-ChildItem . -inc *.extdoesntexist
foreach ($file in $files) {
"$($file.Fullname.substring(2))"
}
Fails with:
You cannot call a method on a null-valued expression.
At line:3 char:25
+ $file.Fullname.substring <<<< (2)
Fix it like so:
$files = #(Get-ChildItem . -inc *.extdoesntexist)
foreach ($file in $files) {
"$($file.Fullname.substring(2))"
}
Bottom line is that the foreach statement will loop on a scalar value even if that scalar value is $null. When Get-ChildItem in the first example returns nothing, $files gets assinged $null. If you are expecting an array of items to be returned by a command but there is a chance it will only return 1 item or zero items, put #() around the command. Then you will always get an array - be it of 0, 1 or N items. Note: If the item is already an array putting #() has no effect - it will still be the very same array (i.e. there is no extra array wrapper).
# The pipeline doesn't enumerate hashtables.
$ht = #{"foo" = 1; "bar" = 2}
$ht | measure
# Workaround: call GetEnumerator
$ht.GetEnumerator() | measure
Here are my top 5 PowerShell gotchas
Here is something Ive stumble upon lately (PowerShell 2.0 CTP):
$items = "item0", "item1", "item2"
$part = ($items | select-string "item0")
$items = ($items | where {$part -notcontains $_})
what do you think that $items be at the end of the script?
I was expecting "item1", "item2" but instead the value of $items is: "item0", "item1", "item2".
Say you've got the following XML file:
<Root>
<Child />
<Child />
</Root>
Run this:
PS > $myDoc = [xml](Get-Content $pathToMyDoc)
PS > #($myDoc.SelectNodes("/Root/Child")).Count
2
PS > #($myDoc.Root.Child).Count
2
Now edit the XML file so it has no Child nodes, just the Root node, and run those statements again:
PS > $myDoc = [xml](Get-Content $pathToMyDoc)
PS > #($myDoc.SelectNodes("/Root/Child")).Count
0
PS > #($myDoc.Root.Child).Count
1
That 1 is annoying when you want to iterate over a collection of nodes using foreach if and only if there actually are any. This is how I learned that you cannot use the XML handler's property (dot) notation as a simple shortcut. I believe what's happening is that SelectNodes returns a collection of 0. When #'ed, it is transformed from an XPathNodeList to an Object[] (check GetType()), but the length is preserved. The dynamically generated $myDoc.Root.Child property (which essentially does not exist) returns $null. When $null is #'ed, it becomes an array of length 1.
On Functions...
The subtleties of processing pipeline input in a function with respect to using $_ or $input and with respect to the begin, process, and end blocks.
How to handle the six principal equivalence classes of input delivered to a function (no input, null, empty string, scalar, list, list with null and/or empty) -- for both direct input and pipeline input -- and get what you expect.
The correct calling syntax for sending multiple arguments to a function.
I discuss these points and more at length in my Simple-Talk.com article Down the Rabbit Hole- A Study in PowerShell Pipelines, Functions, and Parameters and also provide an accompanying wallchart--here is a glimpse showing the various calling syntax pitfalls for a function taking 3 arguments:
On Modules...
These points are expounded upon in my Simple-Talk.com article Further Down the Rabbit Hole: PowerShell Modules and Encapsulation.
Dot-sourcing a file inside a script using a relative path is relative to your current directory -- not the directory where the script resides!
To be relative to the script use this function to locate your script directory: [Update for PowerShell V3+: Just use the builtin $PSScriptRoot variable!]
function Get-ScriptDirectory
{ Split-Path $script:MyInvocation.MyCommand.Path }
Modules must be stored as ...Modules\name\name.psm1 or ...\Modules\any_subpath\name\name.psm1. That is, you cannot just use ...Modules\name.psm1 -- the name of the immediate parent of the module must match the base name of the module. This chart shows the various failure modes when this rule is violated:
2015.06.25 A Pitfall Reference Chart
Simple-Talk.com just published the last of my triumvirate of in-depth articles on PowerShell pitfalls. The first two parts are in the form of a quiz that helps you appreciate a select group of pitfalls; the last part is a wallchart (albeit it would need a rather high-ceilinged room) containing 36 of the most common pitfalls (some adapted from answers on this page), giving concrete examples and workarounds for most. Read more here.
There are some tricks to building command lines for utilities that were not built with Powershell in mind:
To run an executable who's name starts with a number, preface it with an Ampersand (&).
& 7zip.exe
To run an executable with a space anywhere in the path, preface it with an Ampersand (&) and wrap it in quotes, as you would any string. This means that strings in a variable can be executed as well.
# Executing a string with a space.
& 'c:\path with spaces\command with spaces.exe'
# Executing a string with a space, after first saving it in a variable.
$a = 'c:\path with spaces\command with spaces.exe'
& $a
Parameters and arguments are passed to legacy utilities positionally. So it is important to quote them the way the utility expects to see them. In general, one would quote when it contains spaces or does not start with a letter, number or dash (-).
C:\Path\utility.exe '/parameter1' 'Value #1' 1234567890
Variables can be used to pass string values containing spaces or special characters.
$b = 'string with spaces and special characters (-/&)'
utility.exe $b
Alternatively array expansion can be used to pass values as well.
$c = #('Value #1', $Value2)
utility.exe $c
If you want Powershell to wait for an application to complete, you have to consume the output, either by piping the output to something or using Start-Process.
# Saving output as a string to a variable.
$output = ping.exe example.com | Out-String
# Piping the output.
ping stackoverflow.com | where { $_ -match '^reply' }
# Using Start-Process affords the most control.
Start-Process -Wait SomeExecutable.com
Because of the way they display their output, some command line utilities will appear to hang when ran inside of Powershell_ISE.exe, particularly when awaiting input from the user. These utilities will usually work fine when ran within Powershell.exe console.
PowerShell Gotchas
There are a few pitfall that repeatedly reappear on StackOverflow. It is recommend to do some research if you are not familiar with these PowerShell gotchas before asking a new question. It might even be a good idea to investigate in these PowerShell gotchas before answering a PowerShell question to make sure that you teach the questioner the right thing.
TLDR: In PowerShell:
the comparison equality operator is: -eq
(Stackoverflow example: Powershell simple syntax if condition not working)
parentheses and commas are not used with arguments
(Stackoverflow example: How do I pass multiple parameters into a function in PowerShell?)
output properties are based on the first object in the pipeline
(Stackoverflow example: Not all properties displayed)
the pipeline unrolls
(Stackoverflow example: Pipe complete array-objects instead of array items one at a time?)
a. single item collections
(Stackoverflow example: Powershell ArrayList turns a single array item back into a string)
b. embedded arrays
(Stackoverflow example: Return Multidimensional Array From Function)
c. output collections
(Stackoverflow example: Why does PowerShell flatten arrays automatically?)
$Null should be on the left side of the equality comparison operator
(Stackoverflow example: Should $null be on the left side of the equality comparison)
parentheses and assignments choke the pipeline
(Stackoverflow example: Importing 16MB CSV Into Variable Creates >600MB's Memory Usage)
the increase assignment operator (+=) might become expensive
Stackoverflow example: Improve the efficiency of my PowerShell scrip
The Get-Content cmdlet returns separate lines
Stackoverflow example: Multiline regex to match config block
Examples and explanations
Some of the gotchas might really feel counter-intuitive but often can be explained by some very nice PowerShell features along with the pipeline, expression/argument mode and type casting.
1. The comparison equality operator is: -eq
Unlike the Microsoft scripting language VBScript and some other programming languages, the comparison equality operator differs from the assignment operator (=) and is: -eq.
Note: assigning a value to a variable might pass through the value if needed:
$a = $b = 3 # The value 3 is assigned to both variables $a and $b.
This implies that following statement might be unexpectedly truthy or falsy:
If ($a = $b) {
# (assigns $b to $a and) returns a truthy if $b is e.g. 3
} else {
# (assigns $b to $a and) returns a falsy if $b is e.g. 0
}
2. Parentheses and commas are not used with arguments
Unlike a lot of other programming languages and the way a primitive PowerShell function is defined, calling a function doesn't require parentheses or commas for their related arguments. Use spaces to separate the parameter arguments:
MyFunction($Param1, $Param2 $Param3) {
# ...
}
MyFunction 'one' 'two' 'three' # assigns 'one' to $Param1, 'two' to $Param2, 'three' to $Param3
Parentheses and commas are used for calling (.Net) methods.
Commas are used to define arrays. MyFunction 'one', 'two', 'three' (or MyFunction('one', 'two', 'three')) will load the array #('one', 'two', 'three') into the first parameter ($Param1).
Parentheses will intepret the containing contents as a single collection into memory (and choke the PowerShell pipeline) and should only be used as such, e.g. to call an embedded function, e.g.:
MyFunction (MyOtherFunction) # passes the results MyOtherFunction to the first positional parameter of MyFunction ($Param1)
MyFunction One $Two (getThree) # assigns 'One' to $Param1, $Two to $Param2, the results of getThree to $Param3
Note: that quoting text arguments (as the word one in the later example) is only required when it contains spaces or special characters.
3. Output properties are based on the first object in the pipeline
In a PowerShell pipeline each object is processed and passed on by a cmdlet (that is implemented for the middle of a pipeline) similar to how objects are processed and passed on by workstations in an assembly line. Meaning each cmdlet processes one item at the time while the prior cmdlet (workstation) simultaneously processes the upcoming one. This way, the objects aren't loaded into memory at once (less memory usage) and could already be processed before the next one is supplied (or even exists). The disadvantage of this feature is that there is no oversight of what (or how many) objects are expected to follow.
Therefore most PowerShell cmdlets assume that all the objects in the pipeline correspond to the first one and have the same properties which is usually the case, but not always...
$List =
[pscustomobject]#{ one = 'a1'; two = 'a2' },
[pscustomobject]#{ one = 'b1'; two = 'b2'; three = 'b3' }
$List |Select-Object *
one two
--- ---
a1 a2
b1 b2
As you see, the third column three is missing from the results as it didn't exists in the first object and the PowerShell was already outputting the results prior it was aware of the exists of the second object.
On way to workaround this behavior is to explicitly define the properties (of all the following objects) at forehand:
$List |Select-Object one, two, three
one two three
--- --- -----
a1 a2
b1 b2 b3
See also proposal: #13906 Add -UnifyProperties parameter to Select-Object
4. The pipeline unrolls
This feature might come in handy if it complies with the straightforward expectation:
$Array = 'one', 'two', 'three'
$Array.Length
3
a. single item collections
But it might get confusing:
$Selection = $Array |Select-Object -First 2
$Selection.Length
2
$Selection[0]
one
when the collection is down to a single item:
$Selection = $Array |Select-Object -First 1
$Selection.Length
3
$Selection[0]
o
Explanation
When the pipeline outputs a single item which is assigned to a variable, it is not assigned as a collection (with 1 item, like: #('one')) but as a scalar item (the item itself, like: 'one').
Which means that the property .Length (which is in fact an alias for the property .Count for an array) is no longer applied on the array but on the string: 'one'.length which equals 3. And in case of the index $Selection[0] , the first character of the string 'one'[0] (which equals the character o) is returned .
Workaround
To workaround this behavior, you might force the scalar item to an array using the Array subexpression operator #( ):
$Selection = $Array |Select-Object -First 1
#($Selection).Length
1
#($Selection)[0]
one
Knowing that in the case the $Selection is already an array, it will will not be further increased in depth (#(#('one', 'two')), see the next section 4b. Embedded collections are flattened).
b. embedded arrays
When an array (or a collection) includes embedded arrays, like:
$Array = #(#('a', 'b'), #('c', 'd'))
$Array.Count
2
All the embedded items will be processed in the pipeline and consequently returns a flat array when displayed or assigned to a new variable:
$Processed = $Array |ForEach-Object { $_ }
$Processed.Count
4
$Processed
a
b
c
d
To iterate the embedded arrays, you might use the foreach statement:
foreach ($Item in $Array) { $Item.Count }
2
2
Or a simply for loop:
for ($i = 0; $i -lt $Array.Count; $i++) { $Array[$i].Count }
2
2
c. output collections
Collections are usually unrolled when they are placed on the pipeline:
function GetList {
[Collections.Generic.List[String]]#('a', 'b')
}
(GetList).GetType().Name
Object[]
To output the collection as a single item, use the comma operator ,:
function GetList {
,[Collections.Generic.List[String]]#('a', 'b')
}
(GetList).GetType().Name
List`1
5. $Null should be on the left side of the equality comparison operator
This gotcha is related to this comparison operators feature:
When the input of an operator is a scalar value, the operator returns a Boolean value. When the input is a collection, the operator returns the elements of the collection that match the right-hand value of the expression. If there are no matches in the collection, comparison operators return an empty array.
This means for scalars:
'a' -eq 'a' # returns $True
'a' -eq 'b' # returns $False
'a' -eq $Null # returns $False
$Null -eq $Null # returns $True
and for collections, the matching elements are returned which evaluates to either a truthy or falsy condition:
'a', 'b', 'c' -eq 'a' # returns 'a' (truthy)
'a', 'b', 'c' -eq 'd' # returns an empty array (falsy)
'a', 'b', 'c' -eq $Null # returns an empty array (falsy)
'a', $Null, 'c' -eq $Null # returns $Null (falsy)
'a', $Null, $Null -eq $Null # returns #($Null, $Null) (truthy!!!)
$Null, $Null, $Null -eq $Null # returns #($Null, $Null, $Null) (truthy!!!)
In other words, to check whether a variable is $Null (and exclude a collection containing multiple $Nulls), put $Null at the LHS (left hand side) of the equality comparison operator:
if ($Null -eq $MyVariable) { ...
6. Parentheses and assignments choke the pipeline
The PowerShell Pipeline is not just a series of commands connected by pipeline operators (|) (ASCII 124). It is a concept to simultaneously stream individual objects through a sequence of cmdlets. If a cmdlet (or function) is written according to the Strongly Encouraged Development Guidelines and implemented for the middle of a pipeline, it takes each single object from the pipeline, processes it and passes the results to the next cmdlet just before it takes and processes the next object in the pipeline. Meaning that for a simple pipeline as:
Import-Csv .\Input.csv |Select-Object -Property Column1, Column2 |Export-Csv .\Output.csv
As the last cmdlet writes an object to the .\Output.csv file, the Select-Object cmdlet selects the properties of the next object and the Import-Csv reads the next object from the .\input.csv file (see also: Pipeline in Powershell). This will keep the memory usage low (especially where there are lots of object/records to process) and therefore might result in a faster throughput. To facilitate the pipeline, the PowerShell objects are quiet fat as each individual object contains all the property information (along with e.g. the property name).
Therefore it is not a good practice to choke the pipeline for no reason. There are two senarios that choke the pipeline:
Parentheses, e.g.:
(Import-Csv .\Input.csv) |Select-Object -Property Column1, Column2 |Export-Csv .\Output.csv
Where all the .\Input.csv records are loaded as an array of PowerShell objects into memory before passing it on to the Select-Object cmdlet.
Assignments, e.g.:
$Objects = Import-Csv .\Input.csv
$Objects |Select-Object -Property Column1, Column2 |Export-Csv .\Output.csv
Where all the .\Input.csv records are loaded as an array of PowerShell objects into $Objects (memory as well) before passing it on to the Select-Object cmdlet.
7. the increase assignment operator (+=) might become expensive
The increase assignment operator (+=) is syntactic sugar to increase and assign primitives as .e.g. $a += $b where $a is assigned $b + 1. The increase assignment operator can also be used for adding new items to a collection (or to String types and hash tables) but might get pretty expensive as the costs increases with each iteration (the size of the collection). The reason for this is that objects as array collections are immutable and the right variable in not just appended but *appended and reassigned to the left variable. For details see also: avoid using the increase assignment operator (+=) to create a collection
8. The Get-Content cmdlet returns separate lines
There are probably quite some more cmdlet gotchas, knowing that there exist a lot of (internal and external) cmdlets. In contrast to engine related gotchas, these gotchas are often easier to highlight (with e.g. a warning) as happend with ConvertTo-Json (see: Unexpected ConvertTo-Json results? Answer: it has a default -Depth of 2) or "fix". But there is very clasic gotcha in Get-Content which tight into the PowerShell general concept of streaming objects (in this case lines) rather than passing everything (the whole contents of the file) in once:
Get-Content .\Input.txt -Match '\r?\n.*Test.*\r?\n'
Will never work because, by default, Get-Contents returns a stream of objects where each object contains a single string (a line without any line breaks).
(Get-Content .\Input.txt).GetType().Name
Object[]
(Get-Content .\Input.txt)[0].GetType().Name
String
In fact:
Get-Content .\Input.txt -Match 'Test'
Returns all the lines with the word Test in it as Get-Contents puts every single line on the pipeline and when the input is a collection, the operator returns the elements of the collection that match the right-hand value of the expression.
Note: since PowerShell version 3, Get-Contents has a -Raw parameter that reads all the content of the concerned file at once, Meaning that this: Get-Content -Raw .\Input.txt -Match '\r?\n.*Test.*\r?\n' will work as it loads the whole file into memory.
alex2k8, I think this example of yours is good to talk about:
# -----------------------------------
function foo($a){
# I thought this is right.
#if($a -eq $null)
#{
# throw "You can't pass $null as argument."
#}
# But actually it should be:
if($null -eq $a)
{
throw "You can't pass $null as argument."
}
}
foo #($null, $null)
PowerShell can use some of the comparators against arrays like this:
$array -eq $value
## Returns all values in $array that equal $value
With that in mind, the original example returns two items (the two $null values in the array), which evalutates to $true because you end up with a collection of more than one item. Reversing the order of the arguments stops the array comparison.
This functionality is very handy in certain situations, but it is something you need to be aware of (just like array handling in PowerShell).
Functions 'foo' and 'bar' looks equivalent.
function foo() { $null }
function bar() { }
E.g.
(foo) -eq $null
# True
(bar) -eq $null
# True
But:
foo | %{ "foo" }
# Prints: foo
bar | %{ "bar" }
# PRINTS NOTHING
Returning $null and returning nothing is not equivalent dealing with pipes.
This one is inspired by Keith Hill example...
function bar() {}
$list = #(foo)
$list.length
# Prints: 0
# Now let's try the same but with a temporal variable.
$tmp = foo
$list = #($tmp)
$list.length
# Prints: 1
Another one:
$x = 2
$y = 3
$a,$b = $x,$y*5
because of operators precedence there is not 25 in $b; the command is the same as ($x,$y)*5
the correct version is
$a,$b = $x,($y*5)
The logical and bitwise operators don't follow standard precedence rules. The operator -and should have a higher priority than -or yet they're evaluated strictly left-to-right.
For example, compare logical operators between PowerShell and Python (or virtually any other modern language):
# PowerShell
PS> $true -or $false -and $false
False
# Python
>>> True or False and False
True
...and bitwise operators:
# PowerShell
PS> 1 -bor 0 -band 0
0
# Python
>>> 1 | 0 & 0
1
This works. But almost certainly not in the way you think it's working.
PS> $a = 42;
PS> [scriptblock]$b = { $a }
PS> & $b
42
This one has tripped me up before, using $o.SomeProperty where it should be $($o.SomeProperty).
# $x is not defined
[70]: $x -lt 0
True
[71]: [int]$x -eq 0
True
So, what's $x..?
Another one I ran into recently: [string] parameters that accept pipeline input are not strongly typed in practice. You can pipe anything at all and PS will coerce it via ToString().
function Foo
{
[CmdletBinding()]
param (
[parameter(Mandatory=$True, ValueFromPipeline=$True)]
[string] $param
)
process { $param }
}
get-process svchost | Foo
Unfortunately there is no way to turn this off. Best workaround I could think of:
function Bar
{
[CmdletBinding()]
param (
[parameter(Mandatory=$True, ValueFromPipeline=$True)]
[object] $param
)
process
{
if ($param -isnot [string]) {
throw "Pass a string you fool!"
}
# rest of function goes here
}
}
edit - a better workaround I've started using...
Add this to your custom type XML -
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8" ?>
<Types>
<Type>
<Name>System.String</Name>
<Members>
<ScriptProperty>
<Name>StringValue</Name>
<GetScriptBlock>
$this
</GetScriptBlock>
</ScriptProperty>
</Members>
</Type>
</Types>
Then write functions like this:
function Bar
{
[CmdletBinding()]
param (
[parameter(Mandatory=$True, ValueFromPipelineByPropertyName=$True)]
[Alias("StringValue")]
[string] $param
)
process
{
# rest of function goes here
}
}
Forgetting that $_ gets overwritten in blocks made me scratch my head in confusion a couple times, and similarly for multiple reg-ex matches and the $matches array. >.<
Remembering to explicitly type pscustom objects from imported data tables as numeric so they can be sorted correctly:
$CVAP_WA=foreach ($i in $C){[PSCustomObject]#{ `
County=$i.county; `
TotalVote=[INT]$i.TotalBallots; `
RegVoters=[INT]$i.regvoters; `
Turnout_PCT=($i.TotalBallots/$i.regvoters)*100; `
CVAP=[INT]($B | ? {$_.GeoName -match $i.county}).CVAP_EST }}
PS C:\Politics> $CVAP_WA | sort -desc TotalVote |ft -auto -wrap
County TotalVote RegVoters Turnout_PCT CVAP CVAP_TV_PCT CVAP_RV_PCT
------ --------- --------- ----------- ---- ----------- -----------
King 973088 1170638 83.189 1299290 74.893 90.099
Pierce 349377 442985 78.86 554975 62.959 79.837
Snohomish 334354 415504 80.461 478440 69.832 86.81
Spokane 227007 282442 80.346 342060 66.398 82.555
Clark 193102 243155 79.453 284190 67.911 85.52
Mine are both related to file copying...
Square Brackets in File Names
I once had to move a very large/complicated folder structure using Move-Item -Path C:\Source -Destination C:\Dest. At the end of the process there were still a number of files in source directory. I noticed that every remaining file had square brackets in the name.
The problem was that the -Path parameter treats square brackets as wildcards.
EG. If you wanted to copy Log001 to Log200, you could use square brackets as follows:
Move-Item -Path C:\Source\Log[001-200].log.
In my case, to avoid square brackets being interpreted as wildcards, I should have used the -LiteralPath parameter.
ErrorActionPreference
The $ErrorActionPreference variable is ignored when using Move-Item and Copy-Item with the -Verbose parameter.
Treating the ExitCode of a Process as a Boolean.
eg, with this code:
$p = Start-Process foo.exe -NoNewWindow -Wait -PassThru
if ($p.ExitCode) {
# handle error
}
things are good, unless say foo.exe doesn't exist or otherwise fails to launch.
in that case $p will be $null, and [bool]($null.ExitCode) is False.
a simple fix is to replace the logic with if ($p.ExitCode -ne 0) {},
however for clarity of code imo the following is better: if (($p -eq $null) -or ($p.ExitCode -ne 0)) {}
Related
I've seen the # symbol used in PowerShell to initialise arrays.
What exactly does the # symbol denote and where can I read more about it?
In PowerShell V2, # is also the Splat operator.
PS> # First use it to create a hashtable of parameters:
PS> $params = #{path = "c:\temp"; Recurse= $true}
PS> # Then use it to SPLAT the parameters - which is to say to expand a hash table
PS> # into a set of command line parameters.
PS> dir #params
PS> # That was the equivalent of:
PS> dir -Path c:\temp -Recurse:$true
PowerShell will actually treat any comma-separated list as an array:
"server1","server2"
So the # is optional in those cases. However, for associative arrays, the # is required:
#{"Key"="Value";"Key2"="Value2"}
Officially, # is the "array operator." You can read more about it in the documentation that installed along with PowerShell, or in a book like "Windows PowerShell: TFM," which I co-authored.
While the above responses provide most of the answer it is useful--even this late to the question--to provide the full answer, to wit:
Array sub-expression (see about_arrays)
Forces the value to be an array, even if a singleton or a null, e.g. $a = #(ps | where name -like 'foo')
Hash initializer (see about_hash_tables)
Initializes a hash table with key-value pairs, e.g.
$HashArguments = #{ Path = "test.txt"; Destination = "test2.txt"; WhatIf = $true }
Splatting (see about_splatting)
Let's you invoke a cmdlet with parameters from an array or a hash-table rather than the more customary individually enumerated parameters, e.g. using the hash table just above, Copy-Item #HashArguments
Here strings (see about_quoting_rules)
Let's you create strings with easily embedded quotes, typically used for multi-line strings, e.g.:
$data = #"
line one
line two
something "quoted" here
"#
Because this type of question (what does 'x' notation mean in PowerShell?) is so common here on StackOverflow as well as in many reader comments, I put together a lexicon of PowerShell punctuation, just published on Simple-Talk.com. Read all about # as well as % and # and $_ and ? and more at The Complete Guide to PowerShell Punctuation. Attached to the article is this wallchart that gives you everything on a single sheet:
You can also wrap the output of a cmdlet (or pipeline) in #() to ensure that what you get back is an array rather than a single item.
For instance, dir usually returns a list, but depending on the options, it might return a single object. If you are planning on iterating through the results with a foreach-object, you need to make sure you get a list back. Here's a contrived example:
$results = #( dir c:\autoexec.bat)
One more thing... an empty array (like to initialize a variable) is denoted #().
The Splatting Operator
To create an array, we create a variable and assign the array. Arrays are noted by the "#" symbol. Let's take the discussion above and use an array to connect to multiple remote computers:
$strComputers = #("Server1", "Server2", "Server3")<enter>
They are used for arrays and hashes.
PowerShell Tutorial 7: Accumulate, Recall, and Modify Data
Array Literals In PowerShell
I hope this helps to understand it a bit better.
You can store "values" within a key and return that value to do something.
In this case I have just provided #{a="";b="";c="";} and if not in the options i.e "keys" (a, b or c) then don't return a value
$array = #{
a = "test1";
b = "test2";
c = "test3"
}
foreach($elem in $array.GetEnumerator()){
if ($elem.key -eq "a"){
$key = $elem.key
$value = $elem.value
}
elseif ($elem.key -eq "b"){
$key = $elem.key
$value = $elem.value
}
elseif ($elem.key -eq "c"){
$key = $elem.key
$value = $elem.value
}
else{
Write-Host "No other value"
}
Write-Host "Key: " $key "Value: " $value
}
Warning: Powershell novice, terms/code may be incorrect
Say I have a Powershell array with data from Invoke-Sqlcmd, say 10,000 "rows" with a half dozen (Col1-Col6) columns each. Say I want to find every row with an empty Col5. Right now I'm doing
foreach ($row in $sqlimport.col1)
{ $col5data = $sqlimport.Where({$_.col1 -eq $row}) | Select-Object -ExpandProperty Col5
if ( '' -eq $col5data ) {$col5data+1} else {} $col5data
Returns 1, which it should in my test. Code seems wrong and slow. It takes several minutes to run through. When something like
$sqlimport.Where({$_.col5 -eq 'somedatathatisthere'})
takes milliseconds
However,
$sqlimport.Where({$_.col5 -eq ''})
Returns blank
($sqlimport.Where({$_.col5 -eq ''})).Count
Returns 0
Right now, you're asking PowerShell to create an array consisting of all the values in column col1, and then for each iteration you search the entire array again to find the corresponding col5 value. That's entirely unnecessary.
Simply loop over the array itself:
foreach($row in $sqlimport){
if($row.Col5 -like ''){
Write-Host "Col5 is empty in row with id $($row.Col1)"
}
}
This only iterates over the entire array once.
Mathias' answer explains the problem with the inefficiency of your first attempt well and offers a solution that ultimately performs best, due to use of a (single) foreach statement (as opposed to the much slower ForEach-Object cmdlet).
However, a solution using a (single) .Where() array method call (or the related .ForEach() method):
is only slightly slower[1]
while being more concise and arguably conceptually more elegant.
It is what you tried with $sqlimport.Where({ $_.col5 -eq '' }), which, based on your feedback, requires only one small tweak to make it work:
Instead of -eq '' use -like '', which is a somewhat obscure[2] shortcut to testing for an empty string ('') and also for a $null value (as also used in Mathias' answer) - it is, in essence, the equivalent of .NET's [string]::IsNullOrEmpty() method.
# -like matches both '' and $null
$sqlimport.Where({ $_.col5 -like '' })
Note:
If you wanted to test for $null values only, use the following; note how $null is placed on the LHS, which is generally advisable for robust comparisons[3]:
$sqlimport.Where({ $null -eq $_.col5 })
As an aside: GitHub issue #10656 proposes introducing a simplified test for $null with something like -is $null; unfortunately, the associated PR has been abandonded.
As an aside: [string]-type-constrained PowerShell variables never store $null values: [string] $str = $null causes $str to contain '', not $null. However, [string]-typed property values not populated in PowerShell code can contain $null values, as in your case.
For passing a true $null value to a string-typed .NET API in PowerShell code, a special singleton must be used (passing $null directly would again result in ''): [NullString]::Value`
See this answer for background information.
[1] For a performance comparison of PowerShell's various enumeration (iteration) features, see the bottom section of this answer.
[2] The real purpose of the -like operator is to perform wildcard-expression matching. The shortcut relies on -like - which operates on (non-null) strings only - auto-converting non-string operands to strings, which in the case of $null causes conversion to '' (the empty string).
[3] To reliably test for $null, place it on the LHS of an -eq / -ne operation; e.g., $null -eq $var. If you place $null on the RHS - $var -eq $null - and $var happens to be a collection (such as an array), the return value is the array of matching elements, i.e. the array of those elements in $var whose value is $null, which is a different operation - see about_Comparison_Operators.
This question addresses the following scenario:
Can custom tab-completion for a given command dynamically determine completions based on the value previously passed to another parameter on the same command line, using either a parameter-level [ArgumentCompleter()] attribute or the Register-ArgumentCompleter cmdlet?
If so, what are the limitations of this approach?
Example scenario:
A hypothetical Get-Property command has an -Object parameter that accepts an object of any type, and a -Property parameter that accepts the name of a property whose value to extract from the object.
Now, in the course of typing a Get-Property call, if a value is already specified for -Object, tab-completing -Property should cycle through the names of the specified object's (public) properties.
$obj = [pscustomobject] #{ foo = 1; bar = 2; baz = 3 }
Get-Property -Object $obj -Property # <- pressing <tab> here should cycle
# through 'foo', 'bar', 'baz'
#mklement0, regarding first limitation stated in your answer
The custom-completion script block ({ ... }) invoked by PowerShell fundamentally only sees values specified via parameters, not via the pipeline.
I struggled with this, and after some stubbornness I got a working solution.
At least good enough for my tooling, and I hope it can make life easier for many others out there.
This solution has been verified to work with PowerShell versions 5.1 and 7.1.2.
Here I made use of $cmdAst (called $commandAst in the docs), which contains information about the pipeline. With this we can get to know the previous pipeline element and even differentiate between it containing only a variable or a command. Yes, A COMMAND, which with help of Get-Command and the command's OutputType() member method, we can get (suggested) property names for such as well!
Example usage
PS> $obj = [pscustomobject] #{ foo = 1; bar = 2; baz = 3 }
PS> $obj | Get-Property -Property # <tab>: bar, baz, foo
PS> "la", "na", "le" | Select-String "a" | Get-Property -Property # <tab>: Chars, Context, Filename, ...
PS> 2,5,2,2,6,3 | group | Get-Property -Property # <tab>: Count, Values, Group, ...
Function code
Note that apart from now using $cmdAst, I also added [Parameter(ValueFromPipeline=$true)] so we actually pick the object, and PROCESS {$Object.$Property} so that one can test and see the code actually working.
param(
[Parameter(ValueFromPipeline=$true)]
[object] $Object,
[ArgumentCompleter({
param($cmdName, $paramName, $wordToComplete, $cmdAst, $preBoundParameters)
# Find out if we have pipeline input.
$pipelineElements = $cmdAst.Parent.PipelineElements
$thisPipelineElementAsString = $cmdAst.Extent.Text
$thisPipelinePosition = [array]::IndexOf($pipelineElements.Extent.Text, $thisPipelineElementAsString)
$hasPipelineInput = $thisPipelinePosition -ne 0
$possibleArguments = #()
if ($hasPipelineInput) {
# If we are in a pipeline, find out if the previous pipeline element is a variable or a command.
$previousPipelineElement = $pipelineElements[$thisPipelinePosition - 1]
$pipelineInputVariable = $previousPipelineElement.Expression.VariablePath.UserPath
if (-not [string]::IsNullOrEmpty($pipelineInputVariable)) {
# If previous pipeline element is a variable, get the object.
# Note that it can be a non-existent variable. In such case we simply get nothing.
$detectedInputObject = Get-Variable |
Where-Object {$_.Name -eq $pipelineInputVariable} |
ForEach-Object Value
} else {
$pipelineInputCommand = $previousPipelineElement.CommandElements[0].Value
if (-not [string]::IsNullOrEmpty($pipelineInputCommand)) {
# If previous pipeline element is a command, check if it exists as a command.
$possibleArguments += Get-Command -CommandType All |
Where-Object Name -Match "^$pipelineInputCommand$" |
# Collect properties for each documented output type.
ForEach-Object {$_.OutputType.Type} | ForEach-Object GetProperties |
# Group properties by Name to get unique ones, and sort them by
# the most frequent Name first. The sorting is a perk.
# A command can have multiple output types. If so, we might now
# have multiple properties with identical Name.
Group-Object Name -NoElement | Sort-Object Count -Descending |
ForEach-Object Name
}
}
} elseif ($preBoundParameters.ContainsKey("Object")) {
# If not in pipeline, but object has been given, get the object.
$detectedInputObject = $preBoundParameters["Object"]
}
if ($null -ne $detectedInputObject) {
# The input object might be an array of objects, if so, select the first one.
# We (at least I) are not interested in array properties, but the object element's properties.
if ($detectedInputObject -is [array]) {
$sampleInputObject = $detectedInputObject[0]
} else {
$sampleInputObject = $detectedInputObject
}
# Collect property names.
$possibleArguments += $sampleInputObject | Get-Member -MemberType Properties | ForEach-Object Name
}
# Refering to about_Functions_Argument_Completion documentation.
# The ArgumentCompleter script block must unroll the values using the pipeline,
# such as ForEach-Object, Where-Object, or another suitable method.
# Returning an array of values causes PowerShell to treat the entire array as one tab completion value.
$possibleArguments | Where-Object {$_ -like "$wordToComplete*"}
})]
[string] $Property
)
PROCESS {$Object.$Property}
Update: See betoz's helpful answer for a more complete solution that also supports pipeline input.
The part of the answer below that clarifies the limitations of pre-execution detection of the input objects' data type still applies.
The following solution uses a parameter-specific [ArgumentCompleter()] attribute as part of the definition of the Get-Property function itself, but the solution analogously applies to separately defining custom-completion logic via the Register-CommandCompleter cmdlet.
Limitations:
[See betoz's answer for how to overcome this limitation] The custom-completion script block ({ ... }) invoked by PowerShell fundamentally only sees values specified via parameters, not via the pipeline.
That is, if you type Get-Property -Object $obj -Property <tab>, the script block can determine that the value of $obj is to be bound to the -Object parameter, but that wouldn't work with
$obj | Get-Property -Property <tab> (even if -Object is declared as pipeline-binding).
Fundamentally, only values that can be evaluated without side effects are actually accessible in the script block; in concrete terms, this means:
Literal values (e.g., -Object ([pscustomobject] #{ foo = 1; bar = 2; baz = 3 })
Simple variable references (e.g., -Object $obj) or property-access or index-access expressions (e.g., -Object $obj.Foo or -Object $obj[0])
Notably, the following values are not accessible:
Method-call results (e.g., -Object $object.Foo())
Command output (via (...), $(...), or #(...), e.g.
-Object (Invoke-RestMethod http://example.org))
The reason for this limitation is that evaluating such values before actually submitting the command could have undesirable side effects and / or could take a long time to complete.
function Get-Property {
param(
[object] $Object,
[ArgumentCompleter({
# A fixed list of parameters is passed to an argument-completer script block.
# Here, only two are of interest:
# * $wordToComplete:
# The part of the value that the user has typed so far, if any.
# * $preBoundParameters (called $fakeBoundParameters
# in the docs):
# A hashtable of those (future) parameter values specified so
# far that are side effect-free (see above).
param($cmdName, $paramName, $wordToComplete, $cmdAst, $preBoundParameters)
# Was a side effect-free value specified for -Object?
if ($obj = $preBoundParameters['Object']) {
# Get all property names of the objects and filter them
# by the partial value already typed, if any,
# interpreted as a name prefix.
#($obj.psobject.Properties.Name) -like "$wordToComplete*"
}
})]
[string] $Property
)
# ...
}
I've checked and tried a few of the suggestions on StackOverflow but none of them seem to work. I put together an example of what I am trying to accomplish.
[System.Random] $rand = New-Object System.Random
$randomNumbers = New-Object int[] 10;
[int[]] $randomNumbers;
for($i = 0; $i -lt $randomNumbers.Length; $i++)
{
($randomNumbers[$i] = $rand.Next(256)) 2>&1 | Out-Null;
}
I've tried the
> $Null
|Out-Null
2>&1
But none of them seem to suppress the output. It's showing 10 zero's in a row. One for each assignment. How can I suppress that output?
Remove int[]] $randomNumbers;. It is not the assignment that is printed, but the empty array.
other solution for replace your code ;)
[int[]] $randomNumbers=1..10 | %{ Get-Random -maximum 256 }
To complement Andrey Marchuk's effective answer:
[int[]] $randomNumbers looks like a type-bound PowerShell variable declaration, but, since no value is assigned, it is merely a cast: the preexisting value of $randomNumbers - a 10-element array of 0 values - is simply cast to [int[]] (a no-op in this case), and then output - yielding 10 lines with a 0 on each in this case.
A true type-bound assignment that is the (inefficient) equivalent of your New-Object int[] 10 statement is [int[]] $randomNumbers = #( 0 ) * 10.
Note that it is the presence of = <value> that makes this statement an assignment that implicitly creates the variable.
PowerShell has no variable declarations in the conventional sense, it creates variables on demand when you assign to them.
You can, however, use the New-Variable cmdlet to explicitly create variables, which allows you to control additional aspects, such as the variable's scope.
Variable assignments in PowerShell do NOT output anything by default, so there's no need to suppress any output (with | Out-Null, >$null, ...).
That said, you can force a variable assignment to output the assigned value by enclosing the assignment in (...).
$v = 'foo' # no output
($v = 'foo') # enclosed in () -> 'foo' is output
As you've discovered, actively suppressing the output in ($randomNumbers[$i] = $rand.Next(256)) 2>&1 | Out-Null; is unnecessary, because simply omitting the parentheses makes the statement quiet: $randomNumbers[$i] = $rand.Next(256)
Finally, you could simplify your code using the Get-Random cmdlet:
[int[]] $randomNumbers = 1..10 | % { Get-Random -Maximum 256 }
This single pipeline does everything your code does (not sure about performance, but it may not matter).
There are powershell cmdlets in our project for finding data in a database. If no data is found, the cmdlets write out a $null to the output stream as follows:
Write-Output $null
Or, more accurately since the cmdlets are implemented in C#:
WriteOutput(null)
I have found that this causes some behavior that is very counter to the conventions employed elsewhere, including in the built-in cmdlets.
Are there any guidelines/rules, especially from Microsoft, that talk about this? I need help better explaining why this is a bad idea, or to be convinced that writing $null to the output stream is an okay practice. Here is some detail about the resulting behaviors that I see:
If the results are piped into another cmdlet, that cmdlet executes despite no results being found and the pipeline variable ($_) is $null. This means that I have to add checks for $null.
Find-DbRecord -Id 3 | For-Each { if ($_ -ne $null) { <do something with $_> }}
Similarly, If I want to get the array of records found, ensuring that it is an array, I might do the following:
$recsFound = #(Find-DbRecord -Category XYZ)
foreach ($record in $recsFound)
{
$record.Name = "Something New"
$record.Update()
}
The convention I have seen, this should work without issue. If no records are found, the foreach loop wouldn't execute. Since the Find cmdlet is writing null to the output, the $recsFound variable is set to an array with one item that is $null. Now I would need to check each item in the array for $null which clutters my code.
$null is not void. If you don't want null values in your pipeline, either don't write null values to the pipeline in the first place, or remove them from the pipeline with a filter like this:
... | Where-Object { $_ -ne $null } | ...
Depending on what you want to allow through the filter you could simplify it to this:
... | Where-Object { $_ } | ...
or (using the ? alias for Where-Object) to this:
... | ? { $_ } | ...
which would remove all values that PowerShell interprets as $false ($null, 0, empty string, empty array, etc.).