I'm using Aran Mulhollan' RemoteIOPlayer, using audioqueues in the SDK iphone.
I can without problems:
- adding two signals to mix sounds
- increasing sound volume by multiplying the UInt32 I get from the wav files
BUT every other operation gives me warped and distorted sound, and in particular I can't divide the signal. I can't seem to figure out what I'm doing wrong, the actual result of the division seems fine; some aspect of sound / signal processing must obviously be eluding me :)
Any help appreciated !
Have you tried something like this?
- (void)setQueue:(AudioQueueRef)ref toVolume:(float)newValue {
OSStatus rc = AudioQueueSetParameter(ref, kAudioQueueParam_Volume, newValue);
if (rc) {
NSLog(#"AudioQueueSetParameter returned %d when setting the volume.\n", rc);
}
}
First of all the code you mention does not use AudioQueues, it uses AudioUnits. The best way to mix audio in the iphone is using the mixer units that are inbuilt, there is some code on the site you downloaded your original example from here. Other than that what i would check in your code os that you have the correct data type. Are you trying your operations on Unsigned ints when you should be using signed ones? often that produces warped results (understandably)
The iPhone handles audio as 16-bit integer. Most audio files are already normalized so that the peak sample values are the maximum that fit in a 16-bit signed integer. That means if you add two such samples together, you get overflow, or in this case, audio clipping. If you want to mix two audio sources together and ensure there's no clipping, you must average the samples: add them together and divide by two. Or you set the volume to half. If you're using decibels, that would be about a -6 dB change.
Related
I'm not sure if it's possible to achieve what I want, but basically I have a NSDictionary which represents a recording. It's a timeline of what sound id was played at what point in time.
I have it so that you can play back this timeline/recording, and it works perfectly.
I'm wondering if there is anyway to take this timeline, and export it as a single sound that could be saved to a computer if the device was synced with iTunes.
So basically I'm asking if I can take a timeline of sounds, play it back and have these sounds stitched together as a single sound, that can then be exported.
I'm using OpenAL as my sound framework and the sound files are all CAFs.
Any help or guidance is appreciated.
Thanks!
You will need:
A good understanding of linear PCM audio format (See Wikipedia's Linear PCM page).
A good understanding of audio sample-rates and some basic maths to convert your timings into sample-offsets.
An awareness of how two's-complement binary numbers (signed/unsigned, 16-bit, 32-bit, etc.) are stored in computers, and how the endian-ness of a processor affects this.
Patience, interest in learning, and a strong desire to get this working.
Here's what to do:
Enable file sharing in your app (UIFileSharingEnabled=YES in info.plist and write files to /Documents directory).
Render the used sounds into memory buffers containing linear PCM audio data (if they are not already, i.e. if they are compressed). You can do this using the offline rendering functionality of Audio Queues (see Apple audio queue docs). It will make things a lot easier if you render them all to the same PCM format and sample rate (For example 16-bit signed samples #44,100Hz, I'll use this format for all examples), and use the same format for your output. I recommend starting off with a Mono format then adding stereo once you get it working.
Choose an uncompressed output format and mix your sounds into a single stream:
3.1. Allocate a buffer large enough, or open a file stream to write to.
3.2. Write out any headers (for example if using WAV format output instead of raw PCM) and write zeros (or the mid-point of your sample range if not using a signed sample format) for any initial silence before your first sound starts. For example if you want 0.1 seconds silence before your first sound, write 4410 (0.1 * 44100) zero-samples i.e. write 4410 shorts (16-bit) all with zero.
3.3. Now keep track of all 'currently playing' sounds and mix them together. Start with an empty list of 'currently playing sounds and keep track of the 'current time' of the sample you are mixing, for each sample you write out increment the 'current time' by 1.0/sample_rate. When it gets time for another sound to start, add it to the 'currently playing' list with a sample offset of 0. Now to do the mixing, you iterate through all of the 'currently playing' sounds and add together their current sample, then increment the sample offset for each of them. Write the summed value into the output buffer. For example if soundA starts at 0.1 seconds (after the silence) and soundB starts at 0.2 seconds, you will be doing the equivalent of output[8820] = soundA[4410] + soundB[0]; for sample 8820 and then output[8821] = soundA[4411] + soundB[1]; for sample 8821, etc. As a sound ends (you get to the end of its samples) simply remove it from the 'currently playing' list and keep going until the end of your audio data.
3.4. The simple mixing (sum of samples) described above does have some problems. For example if two samples have values that add up to a number larger than 32767, this cannot be stored in a signed-16-bit number, this is called clipping. For now, just clamp the value to 32767, and get it working... later on come back and implement a simple limiter (see description at end).
Now that you have a mixed version of your track in an uncompressed linear PCM format, that might be enough, so write it to /Documents. If you want to write it in a compressed format, you will need to get the source for an audio encoder and run your linear PCM output through that.
Simple limiter:
Let's choose to limit the top 10% of the sample range, so if the absolute value is greater than 29490 (int limitBegin = (int)(32767 * 0.9f);) we will scale down the value. The maximum possible peak would be int maxSampleValue = 32767 * numPlayingSounds; and we want to scale values above limitBegin to peak at 32767. So do the summation into sampleValue as per the very simple mixer described above, then:
if(sampleValue > limitBegin)
{
float overLimit = (sampleValue - limitBegin) / (float)(maxSampleValue - limitBegin);
sampleValue = limitBegin + (int)(overLimit * (32767 - limitBegin));
}
If you're paying attention, you will have noticed that when numPlayingSounds changes (for example when a new sound starts), the limiter becomes more (or less) harsh and this may result in abrupt volume changes (within the limited range) to accommodate the extra sound. You can use the maximum number of playing sounds instead, or devise some clever way to ramp up the limiter over a few milliseconds.
Remember that this is operating on the absolute value of sampleValue (which may be negative in signed formats), so the code here is just to demonstrate the idea. You'll need to write it properly to handle limiting at both ends (peak and trough) of your sample range. Also, there are some tricks you can do to optimize all of the above during the mixing - you will probably spot these while you're writing the mixer, be careful and get it working first, then go back and refactor/optimize if needed.
Also remember to consider the endian-ness of the platform you are using and the file-format you are writing to, as you may need to do some byte-swapping.
One approach which isn't too hard if your files are stored in a simple format is just to combine them together manually. That is, create a new file with the caf format and manually put together the pieces you want.
This will be really easy if the sounds are uncompressed (linear PCM). But, read the documents on the caf file format here:
http://developer.apple.com/library/mac/#documentation/MusicAudio/Reference/CAFSpec/CAF_spec/CAF_spec.html#//apple_ref/doc/uid/TP40001862-CH210-SW1
I want to mix audio files of different size into a one single .wav file without clipping any file.,i.e. The resulting file size should be equal to the largest sized file of all.
There is a sample through which we can mix files of same size
[(http://www.modejong.com/iOS/#ex4 )(Example 4)].
I modified the code to get the mixed file as a .wav file.
But I am not able to understand that how to modify this code for unequal sized files.
If someone can help me out with some code snippet,i'll be really thankful.
It should be as easy as sending all the files to the mixer simultaneously. When any single file gets to the end, just treat it as if the remainder is filled with zeroes. When all files get to the end, you are done.
Note that the example code says it returns an error if there would be clipping (the sum of the waves is greater than the max representable value.). This condition is more likely if you are mixing multiple inputs. The best way around it is to create some "headroom" in the input waves. You can do either do this in preprocessing, by ensuring that each wave's volume is no more than X% of maximum. (~80-90%, depending on number of inputs.). The other way is to do it dynamically in the mixer code by multiplying each sample by some value <1.0 as you add it to the mix.
If you are selecting the waves to mix at runtime and failure due to clipping is unacceptable, you will need to modify the sample code to pin the values at max/min instead of returning an error. Don't just let them overflow or you will get noisy artifacts.
(Clipping creates artifacts as well, but when you haven't created enough headroom before mixing, it is definitely preferrable to overflow. It is a more familiar-sounding type of distortion, similar to what you get when you overdrive your speakers. See this wikipedia article on clipping:
Clipping is preferable to the alternative in digital systems—wrapping—which occurs if the digital hardware is allowed to "overflow", ignoring the most significant bits of the magnitude, and sometimes even the sign of the sample value, resulting in gross distortion of the signal.
How I'd do it:
Much like the mix_buffers function that you linked to, but pass in 2 parameters for mixbufferNumSamples. Iterate over the whole of the longer of the two buffers. When the index has gone beyond the end of the shorter buffer, simply set the sample from that buffer to 0 for the rest of the function.
If you must avoid clipping and do it in real-time and you know nothing else about the two sounds, you must provide enough headroom. The simplest method is by halving each of the samples before mixing:
mixed = s1/2 + s2/2;
This ensures that the resultant mixed sample won't overflow an int16_t. It will have the side effect of making everything quieter though.
If you can run it offline, you can calculate a scale factor to apply to both waveforms which will keep the peaks when summed below the maximum allowed value.
Or you could mix them all at full volume to an int32_t buffer, keeping track of the largest (magnitude) mixed sample and then go back through the buffer multiplying each sample by a scale factor which will make that extreme sample just reach the +32767/-32768 limits.
I want to add a few bytes of data to a sound file (for example a song). The sound file will be transmitted via radio to a received who uses for example the iPhone microphone to pick up the sound, and an application will show the original bytes of data. Preferably it should not be hearable for humans.
What is such technology called? Are there any applications that can do this?
Libraries/apps that can be used on iPhone?
It's audio steganography. There are algorithms to do it. Refer to here.
I've done some research, and it seems the way to go is:
Use low audio frequencies.
Spread the "bits" around randomly - do not use a pattern as it will be picked up by the listener. "White noise" is a good clue. The random pattern is known by the sender and receiver.
Use Fourier transform to pick up frequency and amplitude
Clean up input data.
Use checksum/redundancy-algorithms to compensate for loss.
I'm writing a prototype and am having a bit difficulty in picking up the right frequency as if has a ~4 Hz offset (100 Hz becomes 96.x Hz when played and picked up by the microphone).
This is not the answer, but I hope it helps.
Is it possible to compare two sounds ?
for example app have already a sound file mp3 or any format, is it possible to compare any static sound file and recorded sound inside of app ?
Any comments are welcomed.
Regards
This forum thread has a good answer (about three down) - http://www.dsprelated.com/showmessage/103820/1.php.
The trick is to get the decoded audio from the mp3 - if they're just short 'hello' sounds, I'd store them inside the app as a wav instead of decoding them (though I've never used CoreAudio or any of the other frameworks before so mp3 decoding into memory might be easy).
When you've got your reference wav and your recorded wav, follow the steps in the post above :
1 Do whatever is necessary to convert .wav files to their discrete- time
signals:
http://www.sonicspot.com/guide/wavefiles.html
2 time-warping might or might not be necessary depending on difference
between two sample rates:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dynamic_time_warping
3 After time warping, truncate both signals so that their durations are
equivalent.
4 Compute normalized energy spectral density (ESD) from DFT's two signals:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power_spectrum.
6 Compute mean-square-error (MSE) between normalized ESD's of two
signals:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mean_squared_error
The MSE between the normalized ESD's
of two signals is good metric of
closeness. If you have say, 10 .wav
files, and 2 of them are nearly the
same, but the others are not, the two
that are close should have a
relatively low MSE. Two perfectly
identical signals will obviously have
MSE of zero. Ideally, two "equivalent"
signals with different time scales,
(20-second human talking versus
5-second chipmunk), different energies
(soft-spoken human verus yelling
chipmunk), and different phases
(sampling began at slightly different
instant against continuous time
input); should still have MSE of zero,
but quantization errors inherent in
DSP will yield MSE slightly greater
than zero.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minimum_mean-square_error
You should get two different MSE values, one between your male->recorded track and one between your female->recorded track. The comparison with the lowest difference is probably the correct gender.
I confess that I've never tried to do this and it looks very hard - good luck!
Here is a question for all you iPhone experts:
If you guys remember the sounds that modems used to make, or when one was trying to load a program from a cassette tape – I am trying to replicate this in an iPhone for a ham radio application. I have a stream of data (ASCII) and I need to encode it as AFSK at 1200 baud. So basically everything in the stream is converted to a series of 1200 and 2200 Hz tones. It needs to sound something like this: http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/27/AFSK_1200_baud.ogg
I successfully built a bit array out of the string, but when I try to assign tones to each bit I get gaps in the sound, therefore it doesn’t demodulate correctly.
Any thought of how one should tackle this problem? Thank you.
The mobilesynth project is open-source. You might be able to scan that for code that generates the tones you need.
How are you assigning tones to the bits? Remember, a digital audio signal is just a stream of samples with values between -1 and 1. Perhaps there is a clipping issue between tone assignments. This can happen if the signal dives below -1 or above 1. If it stays above or below this range at a constant value, there will be no sound. Maybe you could output your stream of samples to check if this is the case. Or plug the output into an oscilloscope...
Also note that clicking can occur between "uneven" transitions of signals. For example if i output a sample with value 1 followed immediately by a sample with value -1, a click or pop will be produced.