Assume we have an array of optionals defined:
var arrayOfOptionals: [String?] = ["Seems", "like", "an", nil, "of", "optionals"]
I can force unwrap it in a short way: var arrayForCrash = arrayOfOptionals.map { $0! }
But that will make app to crash, is there any other short way(without explicitly unwrapping) how I can unwrap an array of optional?
This solution will get you a new array with all values unwrapped and all nil's filtered away.
Swift 4.1:
let arrayOfOptionals: [String?] = ["Seems", "like", "an", nil, "of", "optionals"]
let arrayWithNoOptionals = arrayOfOptionals.compactMap { $0 }
Swift 2.0:
let arrayOfOptionals: [String?] = ["Seems", "like", "an", nil, "of", "optionals"]
let arrayWithNoOptionals = arrayOfOptionals.flatMap { $0 }
Swift 1.0:
let arrayOfOptionals: [String?] = ["Seems", "like", "an", nil, "of", "optionals"]
let arrayWithNoOptionals = arrayOfOptionals.filter { $0 != nil }.map { $0! }
Since it is an array of optionals, it is possible some of the entries are nil. Instead of force unwrapping with !, use the nil coalescing operator to turns nils into empty strings.
let arrayOfOptionals: [String?] = ["This", "array", nil, "has", "some", "nils", nil]
let array:[String] = arrayOfOptionals.map{ $0 ?? "" }
// array is now ["This", "array", "", "has", "some", "nils", ""]
Although you can use flatMap { $0 } to remove nils, flatMap is actually a much more powerful function, and has an overloaded version which does something completely different (e.g. flatten [[Int]] to [Int]). If you're not careful, you may accidentally invoke the wrong function.
I would recommend using an extension on SequenceType to remove nils. If you use removeNils(), you'll be able to essentially do the following:
[1, nil, 2].removeNils() == [1, 2]
It works by making Optional conform to an OptionalType protocol which allows extending SequenceTypes that contain Optional values.
For more information see the original answer I posted.
I took #Cenny's answer and decided to make an operator out of it:
prefix operator <!> {}
prefix func <!> <T>(array: [T?]) -> [T] {
return array.filter{ $0 != nil }.map{ $0! }
}
I'm using it to parse an array of JSON objects and filter the ones that failed:
static func parse(j: JSONArray) -> [Agency]? {
return <!>j.map { self.parse($0) }
}
Update for Swift 2+:
Use flatMap operator and it'll only return non-nil objects
Swift 4
Easy to read and safe approach to filter nils of any sequence
protocol OptionalProtocol {
associatedtype Wrapped
var optional: Wrapped? { get }
}
extension Optional: OptionalProtocol {
var optional: Wrapped? {
return self
}
}
extension Sequence where Element: OptionalProtocol {
var removingOptionals: [Element.Wrapped] {
return self.compactMap { $0.optional }
}
}
Usage
let array: [Int?] = [1, 2, nil, 3, 4, nil]
print(array.removingOptionals) // prints [1, 2, 3, 4], has type [Int]
The more interesting, how to unwrap an optional array of optional values. It is important to deal when we are working with JSON, because JSON can potentially contain null value for an array of something.
Example:
{ "list": null }
// or
{ "list": [null, "hello"] }
To fill a Swift struct we may have a model:
struct MyStruct: Codable {
var list: [String?]?
}
And to avoid working with String?? as a first item we could:
var myStruct = try! JSONDecoder.init().decode(MyStruct.self, from: json.data(using: .utf8)!)
let firstItem: String? = s1.list?.compactMap { $0 }.first
With compactMap { $0 } we can avoid
let i2: String?? = s1.list?.first
compactMap { $0 } is an equivalent of filter { $0 != nil }. map { $0! }
How about:
import Foundation
var test: [String!] = ["this","is","a",nil,"test"]
for string in test {
if string != nil {
print(string)
}
}
Output is thisisatest.
In your case use [String!], if I understood you correctly.
Related
I have this simple code, what I am trying to do is removing nil values from [Any?] and make an [Any]. But compactMap does not work!
let optionalString: String? = nil
let optionalInt: Int? = nil
let customTuple = (optionalString, "a", "b", "c", optionalInt)
let arrayOfChildren: [Mirror.Child] = Array(Mirror(reflecting: customTuple).children)
let arrayOfChildrenValues: Array<Any?> = arrayOfChildren.map({ element in element.value })
let compactArrayOfChildrenValues: Array<Any> = arrayOfChildrenValues.compactMap({ element in element })
print(compactArrayOfChildrenValues)
The printed result:
[nil, "a", "b", "c", nil]
Test:
For example, the following simple test would work! But my code in top does not! What I am missing here?
let optionalString: String? = nil
let optionalInt: Int? = nil
let array: [Any?] = [optionalString, "Hello, world!", optionalInt, 1000]
print(array.compactMap({ element in element }))
result:
["Hello, world!", 1000]
Another Test:
let optionalString: String? = nil
let optionalInt: Int? = nil
let arrayOfChildrenValues: Array<Any?> = [optionalString, "a", "b", "c", optionalInt]
let compactArrayOfChildrenValues: Array<Any> = arrayOfChildrenValues.compactMap({ element in element })
print(compactArrayOfChildrenValues)
result:
["a", "b", "c"]
Firstly, change the type of arrayOfChildrenValues to [Any], so it is no longer optional, since \.value doesn't return an optional.
Now - you want to see if the element of type Any is an optional. To do this, you can try match it to Optional<Any>.none.
Change the following parts:
let arrayOfChildrenValues: [Any] = arrayOfChildren.map(\.value)
let compactArrayOfChildrenValues: [Any] = arrayOfChildrenValues.filter { element in
switch element {
case Optional<Any>.none: return false
default: return true
}
}
Other ways
Here is another way:
let arrayOfChildrenValues: [Any] = arrayOfChildren.map(\.value)
let compactArrayOfChildrenValues: [Any] = (arrayOfChildrenValues as [Any?]).compactMap { $0 }
However, there is another method with some strange behaviour happening, I'm not sure I can fully understand.
Here's the code:
let arrayOfChildrenValues: [Any?] = arrayOfChildren.map(\.value)
let compactArrayOfChildrenValues: [Any] = arrayOfChildrenValues.compactMap { $0 }
The reason why this is strange is because all the other methods work with arrayOfChildrenValues being expressed like { element in element.value }, however this only works when using key-paths. Perhaps it's because the return type is inferred as [Any?], so it does a cast similar to the example above?
Why does your other example work?
The reason why compactMap doesn't work on [Any] is because a value of type Any cannot be not nil, since it is not an optional.
You can test this, by trying compactMap on [Any] instead of [Any?]. Modify your other example, as so:
let anyArray: [Any] = array.map { $0 as Any }
print(anyArray.compactMap({ element in element }))
Notice this prints [nil, Optional("Hello, world!"), nil] - and has also wrapped all our values in an optional because in reality this is still of type [Any?], 'disguised' as [Any].
Let's say we have an Array, assigned to a variable with the type Any
let something: Any = ["one", "two", "three"]
Let's also assume we don't know if it's an array or something entirely else. And we also don't know what kind of Array.Element we are dealing with exactly.
Now we want to find out if it's an array.
let isArray = something is Array // compiler error
let isArray = (something as? [Any?] != nil) // does not work (array is [String] and not [Any?])
Is there any elegant solution to tickle the following information out of the swift type system:
Is the given object an Array
What's the count of the array
Give me the elements of the array
(bridging to NSArray is not a solution for me, because my array could also be of type [Any?] and contain nil-values)
I love #stefreak's question and his solution. Bearing in mind #dfri's excellent answer about Swift's runtime introspection, however, we can simplify and generalise #stefreak's "type tagging" approach to some extent:
protocol AnySequenceType {
var anyElements: [Any?] { get }
}
extension AnySequenceType where Self : SequenceType {
var anyElements: [Any?] {
return map{
$0 is NilLiteralConvertible ? Mirror(reflecting: $0).children.first?.value : $0
}
}
}
extension Array : AnySequenceType {}
extension Set : AnySequenceType {}
// ... Dictionary, etc.
Use:
let things: Any = [1, 2]
let maybies: Any = [1, nil] as [Int?]
(things as? AnySequenceType)?.anyElements // [{Some 1}, {Some 2}]
(maybies as? AnySequenceType)?.anyElements // [{Some 1}, nil]
See Swift Evolution mailing list discussion on the possibility of allowing protocol extensions along the lines of:
extension<T> Sequence where Element == T?
In current practice, however, the more common and somewhat anticlimactic solution would be to:
things as? AnyObject as? [AnyObject] // [1, 2]
// ... which at present (Swift 2.2) passes through `NSArray`, i.e. as if we:
import Foundation
things as? NSArray // [1, 2]
// ... which is also why this fails for `mabyies`
maybies as? NSArray // nil
At any rate, what all this drives home for me is that once you loose type information there is no going back. Even if you reflect on the Mirror you still end up with a dynamicType which you must switch through to an expected type so you can cast the value and use it as such... all at runtime, all forever outside the compile time checks and sanity.
As an alternative to #milos and OP:s protocol conformance check, I'll add a method using runtime introspection of something (foo and bar in examples below).
/* returns an array if argument is an array, otherwise, nil */
func getAsCleanArray(something: Any) -> [Any]? {
let mirr = Mirror(reflecting: something)
var somethingAsArray : [Any] = []
guard let disp = mirr.displayStyle where disp == .Collection else {
return nil // not array
}
/* OK, is array: add element into a mutable that
the compiler actually treats as an array */
for (_, val) in Mirror(reflecting: something).children {
somethingAsArray.append(val)
}
return somethingAsArray
}
Example usage:
/* example usage */
let foo: Any = ["one", 2, "three"]
let bar: [Any?] = ["one", 2, "three", nil, "five"]
if let foobar = getAsCleanArray(foo) {
print("Count: \(foobar.count)\n--------")
foobar.forEach { print($0) }
} /* Count: 3
--------
one
2
three */
if let foobar = getAsCleanArray(bar) {
print("Count: \(foobar.count)\n-------------")
foobar.forEach { print($0) }
} /* Count: 5
-------------
Optional("one")
Optional(2)
Optional("three")
nil
Optional("five") */
The only solution I came up with is the following, but I don't know if it's the most elegant one :)
protocol AnyOptional {
var anyOptionalValue: Optional<Any> { get }
}
extension Optional: AnyOptional {
var anyOptionalValue: Optional<Any> {
return self
}
}
protocol AnyArray {
var count: Int { get }
var allElementsAsOptional: [Any?] { get }
}
extension Array: AnyArray {
var allElementsAsOptional: [Any?] {
return self.map {
if let optional = $0 as? AnyOptional {
return optional.anyOptionalValue
}
return $0 as Any?
}
}
}
Now you can just say
if let array = something as? AnyArray {
print(array.count)
print(array.allElementsAsOptional)
}
This works for me on a playground:
// Generate fake data of random stuff
let array: [Any?] = ["one", "two", "three", nil, 1]
// Cast to Any to simulate unknown object received
let something: Any = array as Any
// Use if let to see if we can cast that object into an array
if let newArray = something as? [Any?] {
// You now know that newArray is your received object cast as an
// array and can get the count or the elements
} else {
// Your object is not an array, handle however you need.
}
I found that casting to AnyObject works for an array of objects. Still working on a solution for value types.
let something: Any = ["one", "two", "three"]
if let aThing = something as? [Any] {
print(aThing.dynamicType) // doesn't enter
}
if let aThing = something as? AnyObject {
if let theThing = aThing as? [AnyObject] {
print(theThing.dynamicType) // Array<AnyObject>
}
}
If you look at this function:
typealias JSONDictionary = [String: AnyObject]
private func allIdentifiersInJson(json: [JSONDictionary], key: String?) -> [AnyObject] {
if let identifier = key {
let identifiers = json.map{ $0[identifier] } //this returns [AnyObject?]
return identifiers as? [AnyObject] ?? [] // this crashes the compiler in Release with Optimizations
}
return []
}
How would you cast an [AnyObject?] to an [AnyObject]
In Release config with optimizations enabled, I get this error during compilation:
Bitcast requires both operands to be pointer or neither
%548 = bitcast i64 %547 to %objc_object*, !dbg !10033
LLVM ERROR: Broken function found, compilation aborted!
One way would be to use flatMap:
let l: [AnyObject?] = [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, nil, 7]
let m = l.flatMap { $0 } // Returns [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7] as [AnyObject]
(tested only in Swift 2)
Expanding on what is in my comment above, if you use the following, your app will crash if identifier is not a key in the dictionary:
let identifiers = json.map { $0[ identifier ]! }
So, what you might want to do is filter that first, then perform the mapping knowing that you can force unwrap because you've already checked for that key:
let identifiers = json.filter({ $0[ identifier ] != nil }).map { $0[ identifier ]! }
But if it were me, I'd want to get rid of the force unwrap altogether for total safety, even when someone else or even yourself comes back to this code a week later and monkeys with it by taking out the filter:
let identifiers = json.map({ $0[ identifier ] ?? NSNull() }).filter { !($0 is NSNull) }
Now you are safely unwrapping with the nil coalescing operator (??) and providing a default object (NSNull), then filtering out those default objects.
You probably want to be using something like this instead:
private func allIdentifiersInJson(json: [JSONDictionary], key: String?) -> [AnyObject] {
if let key = key {
return json.map { $0[key] }.filter { $0 != nil } as! [AnyObject]
}
return []
}
Because we are using filter to remove all instances of nil, we can use the forced cast to [AnyObject] without fear of a crash.
Or, as pointed out by #MirekE in their answer, flatMap is even more succinct:
return json.flatMap { $0[key] }
Which only returns non-nil results, and removes the need for any casting.
This function will not crash the compiler:
private func allIdentifiersInJson(json: [JSONDictionary], key: String?) -> [AnyObject] {
if let key = key {
let identifiers = json.map{ $0[key]! } //this returns [AnyObject]
return identifiers ?? []
}
return []
}
Say I had the below api :
func paths() -> [String?] {
return ["test", nil, "Two"]
}
And I was using this in a method where I needed [String], hence I had to unwrap it using the simple map function. I'm currently doing :
func cleanPaths() -> [String] {
return paths.map({$0 as! String})
}
Here, the force-cast will cause an error. So technically I need to unwrap the Strings in the paths array. I'm having some trouble doing this and seem to be getting silly errors. Can someone help me out here?
compactMap() can do this for you in one step:
let paths:[String?] = ["test", nil, "Two"]
let nonOptionals = paths.compactMap{$0}
nonOptionals will now be a String array containing ["test", "Two"].
Previously flatMap() was the proper solution, but has been deprecated for this purpose in Swift 4.1
You should filter first, and map next:
return paths.filter { $0 != .None }.map { $0 as! String }
but using flatMap as suggested by #BradLarson is a just better
Perhaps what you want to is a filter followed by a map:
func cleanPaths() -> [String] {
return paths()
.filter {$0 != nil}
.map {$0 as String!}
}
let x = cleanPaths()
println(x) // ["test", "two"]
let name = obj.value
name.map { name in print(name)}
I'm a little confused around flatMap (added to Swift 1.2)
Say I have an array of some optional type e.g.
let possibles:[Int?] = [nil, 1, 2, 3, nil, nil, 4, 5]
In Swift 1.1 I'd do a filter followed by a map like this:
let filtermap = possibles.filter({ return $0 != nil }).map({ return $0! })
// filtermap = [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]
I've been trying to do this using flatMap a couple ways:
var flatmap1 = possibles.flatMap({
return $0 == nil ? [] : [$0!]
})
and
var flatmap2:[Int] = possibles.flatMap({
if let exercise = $0 { return [exercise] }
return []
})
I prefer the last approach (because I don't have to do a forced unwrap $0!... I'm terrified for these and avoid them at all costs) except that I need to specify the Array type.
Is there an alternative away that figures out the type by context, but doesn't have the forced unwrap?
Since Swift 4.1 you can use compactMap:
let possibles:[Int?] = [nil, 1, 2, 3, nil, nil, 4, 5]
let actuals = possibles.compactMap { $0 }
(Swift 4.1 replaced some overloads of flatMap with compactmap.
If you are interested in more detail on this then see for example:
https://useyourloaf.com/blog/replacing-flatmap-with-compactmap/
)
With Swift 2 b1, you can simply do
let possibles:[Int?] = [nil, 1, 2, 3, nil, nil, 4, 5]
let actuals = possibles.flatMap { $0 }
For earlier versions, you can shim this with the following extension:
extension Array {
func flatMap<U>(transform: Element -> U?) -> [U] {
var result = [U]()
result.reserveCapacity(self.count)
for item in map(transform) {
if let item = item {
result.append(item)
}
}
return result
}
}
One caveat (which is also true for Swift 2) is that you might need to explicitly type the return value of the transform:
let actuals = ["a", "1"].flatMap { str -> Int? in
if let int = str.toInt() {
return int
} else {
return nil
}
}
assert(actuals == [1])
For more info, see http://airspeedvelocity.net/2015/07/23/changes-to-the-swift-standard-library-in-2-0-betas-2-5/
I still like the first solution, which creates only one intermediate
array. It can slightly more compact be written as
let filtermap = possibles.filter({ $0 != nil }).map({ $0! })
But flatMap() without type annotation and without forced
unwrapping is possible:
var flatmap3 = possibles.flatMap {
flatMap($0, { [$0] }) ?? []
}
The outer flatMap is the array method
func flatMap<U>(transform: #noescape (T) -> [U]) -> [U]
and the inner flatMap is the function
func flatMap<T, U>(x: T?, f: #noescape (T) -> U?) -> U?
Here is a simple performance comparison (compiled in Release mode).
It shows that the first method is faster, approximately by a factor
of 10:
let count = 1000000
let possibles : [Int?] = map(0 ..< count) { $0 % 2 == 0 ? $0 : nil }
let s1 = NSDate()
let result1 = possibles.filter({ $0 != nil }).map({ $0! })
let e1 = NSDate()
println(e1.timeIntervalSinceDate(s1))
// 0.0169369578361511
let s2 = NSDate()
var result2 = possibles.flatMap {
flatMap($0, { [$0] }) ?? []
}
let e2 = NSDate()
println(e2.timeIntervalSinceDate(s2))
// 0.117663979530334
Related to the question. If you are applying flatMap to an optional array, do not forget to optionally or force unwrap your array otherwise it will call flatMap on Optional and not objects conforming to Sequence protocol. I made that mistake once, E.g. when you want to remove empty strings:
var texts: [String]? = ["one", "two", "", "three"] // has unwanted empty string
let notFlatMapped = texts.flatMap({ $0.count > 0 ? $0 : nil })
// ["one", "two", "", "three"], not what we want - calls flatMap on Optional
let flatMapped = texts?.flatMap({ $0.count > 0 ? $0 : nil })
// ["one", "two", "three"], that's what we want, calls flatMap on Array
You could use reduce:
let flattened = possibles.reduce([Int]()) {
if let x = $1 { return $0 + [x] } else { return $0 }
}
You are still kind of declaring the type, but it's slightly less obtrusive.
Since this is something I seem to end up doing quite a lot I'm exploring a generic function to do this.
I tried to add an extension to Array so I could do something like possibles.unwraped but couldn't figure out how to make an extension on an Array. Instead used a custom operator -- hardest part here was trying to figure out which operator to choose. In the end I chose >! to show that the array is being filtered > and then unwrapped !.
let possibles:[Int?] = [nil, 1, 2, 3, nil, nil, 4, 5]
postfix operator >! {}
postfix func >! <T>(array: Array<T?>) -> Array<T> {
return array.filter({ $0 != nil }).map({ $0! })
}
possibles>!
// [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]