Why is my SwiftUI List row not always updating internally - reactive-programming

Question

I have a list of reminders grouped into sections by completion and date. With data coming from an ObservedObject DataStore called global. I pass a realmBinding to the cell. The cell can update this binding and it will trigger the data store to update.
List {
// Past Due
if self.global.pastDueReminders.count > 0 {
Section(header: SectionHeader {}){
ForEach(self.global.pastDueReminders) { reminder in
NavigationLink(destination: ReminderDetail( reminder: reminder.realmBinding())) {
GeneralReminderCell(reminder: reminder.realmBinding())
}
}
}
}
// Completed
if self.global.completeReminders.count > 0 {
// Same as PastDue but for Completed
}
}
The cell looks something like:
struct GeneralReminderCell: View {
#Binding var reminder:Reminder
var body: some View {
HStack(alignment:.top, spacing: 10) {
Image(systemName: reminder.completed ? "checkmark.circle.fill" : "circle")
.onTapGesture(perform:{ self.reminder.completed = !self.reminder.completed })
VStack(alignment: .leading, spacing: 2) {
Text("Follow up with \(reminder.client.fullName)").fontWeight(.semibold)
if reminder.title.count > 0 {
Text(reminder.title)
}
Text(reminder.date.formatted()).foregroundColor(.gray)
}
}.padding(.vertical, 10)
}
}
When tapping on an image it toggles the reminder completion state and its position changes in the List view. The image that was tapped should changed to a filled in check when completed.
This behaviour almost always happens as expected, but sometimes the checked image will get out of sync with the completed state of reminder. I've look at this for quite some time and have not made much headway. Why is the checked image not always matching the state of the data?

Answer 1

Even though this is a very old question, I may have been working on what appears to be this same problem. In my case, my App is running on macOS. At first, the problem also seemed to be very intermittent and had been difficult to reproduce consistently.
I also have a View with a ForEach supplying rows to a List. My row's View contains an #State for an Optional Image that gets updated several different ways via actions performed by that same row View (e.g. Continuity Camera, file picker or drag & drop). The issue is that sometimes the new Image is shown and sometimes it is not shown. Using Self._printChanges() I am able to see that the #State is changing and the row's body it is being redrawn, however, the rendered View does not change. The only pattern that I am able to observe is that this issue only seems to occur with the last row in the List. Based on the success of my workaround below, it seems to confirm that there is an issue with the way SwiftUI's List reuses table cells.
My solution/workaround is to replace:
List {
ForEach {
}
}
With:
ScrollView {
LazyVStack {
ForEach {
}
}
}