In a Combine Publisher chain, how to keep inner objects alive until cancel or complete? - swift

Question

I've created a Combine publisher chain that looks something like this:
let pub = getSomeAsyncData()
.mapError { ... }
.map { ... }
...
.flatMap { data in
let wsi = WebSocketInteraction(data, ...)
return wsi.subject
}
.share().eraseToAnyPublisher()
It's a flow of different possible network requests and data transformations. The calling code wants to subscribe to pub to find out when the whole asynchronous process has succeeded or failed.
I'm confused about the design of the flatMap step with the WebSocketInteraction. That's a helper class that I wrote. I don't think its internal details are important, but its purpose is to provide its subject property (a PassthroughSubject) as the next Publisher in the chain. Internally the WebSocketInteraction uses URLSessionWebSocketTask, talks to a server, and publishes to the subject. I like flatMap, but how do you keep this piece alive for the lifetime of the Publisher chain?
If I store it in the outer object (no problem), then I need to clean it up. I could do that when the subject completes, but if the caller cancels the entire publisher chain then I won't receive a completion event. Do I need to use Publisher.handleEvents and listen for cancellation as well? This seems a bit ugly. But maybe there is no other way...
.flatMap { data in
let wsi = WebSocketInteraction(data, ...)
self.currentWsi = wsi // store in containing object to keep it alive.
wsi.subject.sink(receiveCompletion: { self.currentWsi = nil })
wsi.subject.handleEvents(receiveCancel: {
wsi.closeWebSocket()
self.currentWsi = nil
})
Anyone have any good "design patterns" here?
One design I've considered is making my own Publisher. For example, instead of having WebSocketInteraction vend a PassthroughSubject, it could conform to Publisher. I may end up going this way, but making a custom Combine Publisher is more work, and the documentation steers people toward using a subject instead. To make a custom Publisher you have to implement some of things that the PassthroughSubject does for you, like respond to demand and cancellation, and keep state to ensure you complete at most once and don't send events after that.
[Edit: to clarify that WebSocketInteraction is my own class.]

Answer 1

It's not exactly clear what problems you are facing with keeping an inner object alive. The object should be alive so long as something has a strong reference to it.
It's either an external object that will start some async process, or an internal closure that keeps a strong reference to self via self.subject.send(...).
class WebSocketInteraction {
private let subject = PassthroughSubject<String, Error>()
private var isCancelled: Bool = false
init() {
// start some async work
DispatchQueue.main.asyncAfter(deadline: .now() + 1) {
if !isCancelled { self.subject.send("Done") } // <-- ref
}
}
// return a publisher that can cancel the operation when
var pub: AnyPublisher<String, Error> {
subject
.handleEvents(receiveCancel: {
print("cancel handler")
self.isCancelled = true // <-- ref
})
.eraseToAnyPublisher()
}
}
You should be able to use it as you wanted with flatMap, since the pub property returned publisher, and the inner closure hold a reference to self
let pub = getSomeAsyncData()
...
.flatMap { data in
let wsi = WebSocketInteraction(data, ...)
return wsi.pub
}