User defined functions with params - codesys

Question

In codesys some functions support what in other languages is usually called 'params', i.e. a function that can take a varied amount of similarly typed variables. For example the ADD Operator (function in ladder).
My question is, if there's any way to do the same in user defined functions?
The only idea that I have so far is to take an ARRAY [*] OF SOMETHING and use LOWER_BOUND and UPPER_BOUND to do the computations. This does work, but requires the user to create an additional array variable every time they want to call my function. For example, we have the CONCAT function that concatenates 2 strings. Suppose I want a CONCAT_ALL function that takes n strings and concatenates them all:
STRS: ARRAY [0..9] OF STRING := [STR1, STR2, STR3, STR4, STR5, STR6, STR7, STR8, STR9, STR10];
// This works, but I want to avoid creating an array variable!
CONALL1: STRING := CONCAT_ALL(STRINGS := STRS);
// This doesn't work!
CONALL2: STRING := CONCAT_ALL(STRINGS := [STR1, STR2, STR3, STR4, STR5, STR6, STR7, STR8, STR9, STR10]);
(EDIT: As I was asked, I am using Schneider Electric Machine Expert 1.2, or CODESYS compiler 3.5.12.80)

Answer 1

There is hope in the future!
In Codesys V3.5 SP16 it seems to be finally possible to use FUNCTIONs and METHODs with optional arguments. Of course this will be in non-codesys products, like TwinCAT and Schneider, in later versions.
This means you can finally create a CONCAT with 100 arguments and call it with just for example 3! Awesome.
https://www.codesys.com/fileadmin/data/Images/Download/features-and-improvements-V35SP16-en.pdf

Answer 2

Here is an object oriented example of a string concatenator Function Block:
First we define an Interface with 2 methods:
INTERFACE I_MultipleConcat
METHOD concatString : I_MultipleConcat
VAR_INPUT
sTarget : STRING;
END_VAR
METHOD getResult
VAR_IN_OUT
sRetrieveResult : STRING(1000);
END_VAR
Then the Function Block which implements the Interface:
FUNCTION_BLOCK FB_MultipleConcat IMPLEMENTS I_MultipleConcat
VAR_OUTPUT
uiLen : UINT;
END_VAR
VAR
sResult : STRING(1000);
END_VAR
//-------------------------------------------------------------------
METHOD concatString : I_MultipleConcat
VAR_INPUT
sTarget : STRING;
END_VAR
//make sure that the length of sResult is not exceeded
IF uiLen + INT_TO_UINT(LEN(sTarget)) <= (SIZEOF(sResult)-1)
THEN
//add uiLen as offset to sResult memory access
memcpy(ADR(sResult) + uiLen,ADR(sTarget),LEN(sTarget));
uiLen := uiLen + INT_TO_UINT(LEN(sTarget));
END_IF
//return the instance of this FuncBlock in order to concat new strings
//with concatString() or pass the result to another STRING with getResult()
concatString := THIS^;
//-------------------------------------------------------------------
METHOD getResult
VAR_IN_OUT
sRetrieveResult : STRING(1000);
END_VAR
sRetrieveResult := sResult;
sResult := '';
uiLen := 0;
You can call it like this:
IF NOT bInit
THEN
bInit := TRUE;
//s1 must be a STRING(1000) otherwise compile error
fbMultipleConcat
.concatString('Test1 ')
.concatString('Test2 ')
.concatString('Test3 ')
.getResult(s1);
END_IF

Answer 3

Short answer: There is no way to pass n arguments to a function.
Structured text is a strongly and statically typed language designed for hard real time requirements and it is not a scripting language like Python.
If you have a lot of string manipulations in your code that you don't want to do in python but in your real time loop (and you should assess if it's really necessary depending on your requirements) and still want to make it in a comfortable way, then you have to put some effort in it and build a string manipulation library yourself.
After that you could have a very comfortable function call like this:
sResult := F_Concat6(str1,str2,str3,str4,str5,str6);
I understand that it is tempting to adopt thought and programming patterns learned from other programming languages, but structured text and real time industrial control programming is really another kind of beast compared to common user land programming.
With that I mean, that there are specific reasons why the language is designed as it is and when those principles are correctly understood and applied, rock solid architectures derive from them.
To sum it up, my two cents of advice on this:
Think and write software as expected by your domain and do not port incompatible working methods from other domains.

Answer 4

No you cannot pass n arguments to function.
But you can pass an array, with none fixed number of elements. Syntaxyx for Codesys 2.3.
FUNCTION CONCAT_ALL : STRING(250)
VAR_INPUT
asParts: POINTER TO ARRAY[0..10000] OF STRING(20); (* Array of strings *)
iNum: INT; (* Number of elements *)
END_VAR
VAR
iCount: INT; (* For cycle *)
END_VAR
FOR iCount := 0 TO 10000 DO
IF iCount > iNum THEN
EXIT;
END_IF;
CONCAT_ALL := CONCAT(CONCAT_ALL, asParts^[iCount]);
END_FOR;
END_FUNCTION
PROGRAM PLC_PRG
VAR
(* Array 1 to test *)
asTest1: ARRAY[1..2] OF STRING(20) := 'String 1', 'String 2';
(* Array 2 to test *)
asTest2: ARRAY[1..3] OF STRING(20) := 'String 1', 'String 2', 'String 3';
s1: STRING(250);
s2: STRING(250);
END_VAR
s1 := CONCAT_ALL(ADR(asTest1), 2);
s1 := CONCAT_ALL(ADR(asTest2), 3);
END_PROGRAM