noob here.
So Im coding a basic To-Do App and I need the user to be able to edit a task he previously entered. To do this, I wish to reuse my AddTaskView in the following way: once I tap "Edit" on the Task, the AddTaskView form gets presented and populated with all the Tasks data and pressing "Save" actually updates the data, instead of adding a new Task.
Currently, my AddTaskView stores all the forms variables in #State variables which have a value by default, such as:
#State private var taskTitle : String = ""
How can I send the data to AddTaskView that is already available since the task already exists to be able to populate the appropiate fields? My understanding is I cant just set #State variables values from outside the view.
Current AddTaskView.swift
struct AddTaskView: View {
//CoreDatas managedObjectEnvironment
#StateObject var vm : viewModel
#Environment(\.managedObjectContext) var moc
#Environment(\.presentationMode) var presentationMode
var categories : FetchedResults<Category>
#State private var taskTitle : String = ""
#State private var taskPriority : String = "Low"
#State private var chosenCategory : String? = ""
#State private var taskDate : Date = Date()
let priorities = ["Low", "High"]
var body: some View {
NavigationView {
Form {
Section(header: Text("Task info")) {
TextField("Task title", text: $taskTitle)
}
Section {
DatePicker("Date", selection: $taskDate)
}
Section {
Picker(
selection: $taskPriority,
label: Text("Priority")
) {
ForEach(self.priorities, id: \.self) {
Text($0).tag($0)
}
}
}
Section {
Picker(
selection: $chosenCategory,
label: Text("Category")
) {
ForEach(self.categories, id: \.categoryName) { cat in
Text(cat.categoryName ?? "Unknown").tag(cat.id)
}
}
}
Section {
Button("Save") {
self.vm.addTask(moc: self.moc, title: self.taskTitle, date: self.taskDate, priority: self.taskPriority, chosenCategory: chosenCategory!)
self.presentationMode.wrappedValue.dismiss()
}
}
}
.navigationTitle("Add Task")
}
}
I want to call and present this AddTaskView from another view where I have all the task info. As far as I understand, I cant just present the view such as:
AddTaskView(taskTitle: aTitle, taskPriority: aPriority, etc)
Any pointers are welcomed. thanks!
You did not ask a small question. I am going to recommend you go through Apple's Introducing SwiftUI. It will give you the foundation to understand what is going on, however the TLDR is every time you change an #State var in a struct, you are getting an entirely new struct. The values in a struct are immutable, regardless of what var might imply, and you literally make a new struct and put it in the old one's place.
And to answer your question as to presenting the view struct, yes, that would work. So would AddTaskView() the way you have your struct set up, though it wouldn't show much. Go hit the tutorial. It is well worth the time.
Related
Update:
This question is already solved (see responses below). The correct way to do this is to get your Binding by projecting the
ObservableObject For example, $options.refreshRate.
TLDR version:
How do I get a SwiftUI Picker (or other API that relies on a local Binding) to immediately update my ObservedObject/EnvironmentObject. Here is more context...
The scenario:
Here is something I consistently need to do in every SwiftUI app I create...
I always make some class that stores any user preference (let's call this class Options and I make it an ObservableObject.
Any setting that needs to be consumed is marked with #Published
Any view that consumes this brings it in as a #ObservedObject or #EnvironmentObject and subscribes to changes.
This all works quite nicely. The trouble I always face is how to set this from the UI. From the UI, here is usually what I'm doing (and this should all sound quite normal):
I have some SwiftUI view like OptionsPanel that drives the Options class above and allows the user to choose their options.
Let's say we have some option defined by an enum:
enum RefreshRate {
case low, medium, high
}
Naturally, I'd choose a Picker in SwiftUI to set this... and the Picker API requires that my selection param be a Binding. This is where I find the issue...
The issue:
To make the Picker work, I usually have some local Binding that is used for this purpose. But, ultimately, I don't care about that local value. What I care about is immediately and instantaneously broadcasting that new value to the rest of the app. The moment I select a new refresh rate, I'd like immediately know that instant about the change. The ObservableObject (the Options class) object does this quite nicely. But, I'm just updating a local Binding. What I need to figure out is how to immediately translate the Picker's state to the ObservableObject every time it's changed.
I have a solution that works... but I don't like it. Here is my non-ideal solution:
The non-ideal solution:
The first part of the solution is quite actually fine, but runs into a snag...
Within my SwiftUI view, rather than do the simplest way to set a Binding with #State I can use an alternate initializer...
// Rather than this...
#ObservedObject var options: Options
#State var refreshRate: RefreshRate = .medium
// Do this...
#ObservedObject var options: Options
var refreshRate: Binding<RefreshRate>(
get: { self.options.refreshRate },
set: { self.options.refreshRate = $0 }
)
So far, this is great (in theory)! Now, my local Binding is directly linked to the ObservableObject. All changes to the Picker are immediately broadcast to the entire app.
But this doesn't actually work. And this is where I have to do something very messy and non-ideal to get it to work.
The code above produces the following error:
Cannot use instance member 'options' within property initializer; property initializers run before 'self' is available
Here my my (bad) workaround. It works, but it's awful...
The Options class provides a shared instance as a static property. So, in my options panel view, I do this:
#ObservedObject var options: Options = .shared // <-- This is still needed to tell SwiftUI to listen for updates
var refreshRate: Binding<RefreshRate>(
get: { Options.shared.refreshRate },
set: { Options.shared.refreshRate = $0 }
)
In practice, this actually kinda works in this case. I don't really need to have multiple instances... just that one. So, as long as I always reference that shared instance, everything works. But it doesn't feel well architected.
So... does anyone have a better solution? This seems like a scenario EVERY app on the face of the planet has to tackle, so it seems like someone must have a better way.
(I am aware some use an .onDisapear to sync local state to the ObservedObject but this isn't ideal either. This is non-ideal because I value having immediate updates for the rest of the app.)
The good news is you're trying way, way, way too hard.
The ObservedObject property wrapper can create this Binding for you. All you need to say is $options.refreshRate.
Here's a test playground for you to try out:
import SwiftUI
enum RefreshRate {
case low, medium, high
}
class Options: ObservableObject {
#Published var refreshRate = RefreshRate.medium
}
struct RefreshRateEditor: View {
#ObservedObject var options: Options
var body: some View {
// vvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvv
Picker("Refresh Rate", selection: $options.refreshRate) {
// ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Text("Low").tag(RefreshRate.low)
Text("Medium").tag(RefreshRate.medium)
Text("High").tag(RefreshRate.high)
}
.pickerStyle(.segmented)
}
}
struct ContentView: View {
#StateObject var options = Options()
var body: some View {
VStack {
RefreshRateEditor(options: options)
Text("Refresh rate: \(options.refreshRate)" as String)
}
.padding()
}
}
import PlaygroundSupport
PlaygroundPage.current.setLiveView(ContentView())
It's also worth noting that if you want to create a custom Binding, the code you wrote almost works. Just change it to be a computed property instead of a stored property:
var refreshRate: Binding<RefreshRate> {
.init(
get: { self.options.refreshRate },
set: { self.options.refreshRate = $0 }
)
}
If I understand your question correctly, you want
to Set a Published value in an ObservableObject from the UI (Picker, etc.) in SwiftUI.
There are many ways to do that, I suggest you use a ObservableObject class, and use it directly wherever you need a binding in a view, such as in a Picker.
The following example code shows one way of setting up your code to do that:
import Foundation
import SwiftUI
// declare your ObservableObject class
class Options: ObservableObject {
#Published var name = "Mickey"
}
struct ContentView: View {
#StateObject var optionModel = Options() // <-- initialise the model
let selectionSet = ["Mickey", "Mouse", "Goofy", "Donald"]
#State var showSheet = false
var body: some View {
VStack {
Text(optionModel.name).foregroundColor(.red)
Picker("names", selection: $optionModel.name) { // <-- use the model directly as a $binding
ForEach (selectionSet, id: \.self) { value in
Text(value).tag(value)
}
}
Button("Show other view") { showSheet = true }
}
.sheet(isPresented: $showSheet) {
SheetView(optionModel: optionModel) // <-- pass the model to other view, see also #EnvironmentObject
}
}
}
struct SheetView: View {
#ObservedObject var optionModel: Options // <-- receive the model
var body: some View {
VStack {
Text(optionModel.name).foregroundColor(.green) // <-- show updated value
}
}
}
If you really want to have a "useless" intermediate local variable, then use this approach:
struct ContentView: View {
#StateObject var optionModel = Options() // <-- initialise the model
let selectionSet = ["Mickey", "Mouse", "Goofy", "Donald"]
#State var showSheet = false
#State var localVar = "" // <-- the local var
var body: some View {
VStack {
Text(optionModel.name).foregroundColor(.red)
Picker("names", selection: $localVar) { // <-- using the localVar
ForEach (selectionSet, id: \.self) { value in
Text(value).tag(value)
}
}
.onChange(of: localVar) { newValue in
optionModel.name = newValue // <-- update the model
}
Button("Show other view") { showSheet = true }
}
.sheet(isPresented: $showSheet) {
SheetView(optionModel: optionModel) // <-- pass the model to other view, see also #EnvironmentObject
}
}
}
Sorry to make this post so long, but in hindsight I should have shown you the simpler instance of the issue so you could better understand what the problem is. I am assuming the same issue with ForEach is at the root cause of both of these bugs, but I could be wrong. The second instance is still included to give you context, but the first intance should be all you need to fully understand the issue.
First Instance:
Here is a video of the issue: https://imgur.com/a/EIg9TSm. As you can see, there are 4 Time Codes, 2 of which are favorite and 2 are not favorites (shown by the yellow star). Additionally, there is text at the top that represents the array of Time Codes being displayed just as a list of favorite (F) or not favorite (N). I click on the last Time Code (Changing to favorite) and press the toggle to unfavorite it. When I hit save, the array of Time Codes is updated, yet as you see, this is not represented in the List. However, you see that the Text of the reduced array immediately updates to FNFF, showing that it is properly updated as a favorite by the ObservedObject.
When I click back on the navigation and back to the page, the UI is properly updated and there are 3 yellow stars. This makes me assume that the problem is with ForEach, as the Text() shows the array is updated but the ForEach does not. Presumably, clicking out of the page reloads the ForEach, which is why it updates after exiting the page. EditCodeView() handles the saving of the TimeCodeVieModel in CoreData, and I am 99% certain that it works properly through my own testing and the fact that the ObservedObject updates as expected. I am pretty sure I am using the dynamic version of ForEach (since TimeCodeViewModel is Identifiable), so I don't know how to make the behavior update immediately after saving. Any help would be appreciated.
Here is the code for the view:
struct ListTimeCodeView: View {
#ObservedObject var timeCodeListVM: TimeCodeListViewModel
#State var presentEditTimeCode: Bool = false
#State var timeCodeEdit: TimeCodeViewModel?
init() {
self.timeCodeListVM = TimeCodeListViewModel()
}
var body: some View {
VStack {
HStack {
Text("TimeCodes Reduced by Favorite:")
Text("\(self.timeCodeListVM.timeCodes.reduce(into: "") {$0 += $1.isFavorite ? "F" : "N"})")
}
List {
ForEach(self.timeCodeListVM.timeCodes) { timeCode in
TimeCodeDetailsCell(fullName: timeCode.fullName, abbreviation: timeCode.abbreviation, color: timeCode.color, isFavorite: timeCode.isFavorite, presentEditTimeCode: $presentEditTimeCode)
.contentShape(Rectangle())
.onTapGesture {
timeCodeEdit = timeCode
}
.sheet(item: $timeCodeEdit, onDismiss: didDismiss) { detail in
EditCodeView(timeCodeEdit: detail)
}
}
}
}
}
}
Here is the code for the View Models (shouldn't be relevant to the problem, but included for understanding):
class TimeCodeListViewModel: ObservableObject {
#Published var timeCodes = [TimeCodeViewModel]()
init() {
fetchAllTimeCodes()
}
func fetchAllTimeCodes() {
self.timeCodes = CoreDataManager.shared.getAllTimeCodes().map(TimeCodeViewModel.init)
}
}
class TimeCodeViewModel: Identifiable {
var id: String = ""
var fullName = ""
var abbreviation = ""
var color = ""
var isFavorite = false
var tags = ""
init(timeCode: TimeCode) {
self.id = timeCode.id!.uuidString
self.fullName = timeCode.fullName!
self.abbreviation = timeCode.abbreviation!
self.color = timeCode.color!
self.isFavorite = timeCode.isFavorite
self.tags = timeCode.tags!
}
}
Second Instance:
EDIT: I realize it may be difficult to understand what the code is doing, so I have included a gif demoing the problem (unfortunately I am not high enough reputation for it to be shown automatically). As you can see, I select the cells I want to change, then press the button to assign that TimeCode to it. The array of TimeCodeCellViewModels changes in the background, but you don't actually see that change until I press the home button and then reopen the app, which triggers a refresh of ForEach. Gif of issue. There is also this video if the GIF is too fast: https://imgur.com/a/Y5xtLJ3
I am trying to display a grid view using a VStack of HStacks, and am running into an issue where the ForEach I am using to display the content is not refreshing when the array being passed in changes. I know the array itself is changing because if I reduce it to a string and display the contents with Text(), it properly updates as soon as a change is made. But, the ForEach loop only updates if I close and reopen the app, forcing the ForEach to reload. I know that there is a special version of ForEach that is specifically designed for dynamic content, but I am pretty sure I am using this version since I pass in '''id: .self'''. Here is the main code snippet:
var hoursTimeCode: [[TimeCodeCellViewModel]] = []
// initialize hoursTimeCode
VStack(spacing: 3) {
ForEach(self.hoursTimeCode, id: \.self) {row in
HStack(spacing: 3){
HourTimeCodeCell(date: row[0].date) // cell view for hour
.frame(minWidth: 50)
ForEach(row.indices, id: \.self) {cell in
// TimeCodeBlockCell displays minutes normally. If it is selected, and a button is pressed, it is assigned a TimeCode which it will then display
TimeCodeBlockCell(timeCodeCellVM: row[cell], selectedArray: $selectedTimeCodeCells)
.frame(maxWidth: .infinity)
.aspectRatio(1.0, contentMode: .fill)
}
}
}
}
I'm pretty sure it doesn't change anything, but I did have to define a custom hash function for the TimeCodeCellViewModel, which might change the behavior of the ForEach (the attributes being changed are included in the hash function). However, I have noticed the same ForEach behavior in another part of my project that uses a different view model, so I highly doubt this is the issue.
class TimeCodeCellViewModel:Identifiable, Hashable {
static func == (lhs: TimeCodeCellViewModel, rhs: TimeCodeCellViewModel) -> Bool {
if lhs.id == rhs.id {
return true
}
else {
return false
}
}
func hash(into hasher: inout Hasher) {
hasher.combine(id)
hasher.combine(isSet)
hasher.combine(timeCode)
hasher.combine(date)
}
var id: String = ""
var date = Date()
var isSet = false
var timeCode: TimeCode
var frame: CGRect = .zero
init(timeCodeCell: TimeCodeCell) {
self.id = timeCodeCell.id!.uuidString
self.date = timeCodeCell.date!
self.isSet = timeCodeCell.isSet
self.timeCode = timeCodeCell.toTimeCode!
}
}
Here is a snippet of what you need to make the code work.
See the comments for some basics of why
struct EditCodeView:View{
#EnvironmentObject var timeCodeListVM: TimeCodeListViewModel
//This will observe changes to the view model
#ObservedObject var timeCodeViewModel: TimeCodeViewModel
var body: some View{
EditTimeCodeView(timeCode: timeCodeViewModel.timeCode)
.onDisappear(perform: {
//*********TO SEE CHANGES WHEN YOU EDIT
//uncomment this line***********
//_ = timeCodeListVM.update(timeCodeVM: timeCodeViewModel)
})
}
}
struct EditTimeCodeView: View{
//This will observe changes to the core data entity
#ObservedObject var timeCode: TimeCode
var body: some View{
Form{
TextField("name", text: $timeCode.fullName.bound)
TextField("appreviation", text: $timeCode.abbreviation.bound)
Toggle("favorite", isOn: $timeCode.isFavorite)
}
}
}
class TimeCodeListViewModel: ObservableObject {
//Replacing this whole thing with a #FetchRequest would be way more efficient than these extra view models
//IF you dont want to use #FetchRequest the only other way to observe the persistent store for changes is with NSFetchedResultsController
//https://stackoverflow.com/questions/67526427/swift-fetchrequest-custom-sorting-function/67527134#67527134
//This array will not see changes to the variables of the ObservableObjects
#Published var timeCodeVMs = [TimeCodeViewModel]()
private var persistenceManager = TimeCodePersistenceManager()
init() {
fetchAllTimeCodes()
}
func fetchAllTimeCodes() {
//This method does not observe for new and or deleted timecodes. It is a one time thing
self.timeCodeVMs = persistenceManager.retrieveObjects(sortDescriptors: nil, predicate: nil).map({
//Pass the whole object there isnt a point to just passing the variables
//But the way you had it broke the connection
TimeCodeViewModel(timeCode: $0)
})
}
func addNew() -> TimeCodeViewModel{
let item = TimeCodeViewModel(timeCode: persistenceManager.addSample())
timeCodeVMs.append(item)
//will refresh view because there is a change in count
return item
}
///Call this to save changes
func update(timeCodeVM: TimeCodeViewModel) -> Bool{
let result = persistenceManager.updateObject(object: timeCodeVM.timeCode)
//You have to call this to see changes at the list level
objectWillChange.send()
return result
}
}
//DO you have special code that you aren't including? If not what is the point of this view model?
class TimeCodeViewModel: Identifiable, ObservableObject {
//Simplify this
//This is a CoreData object therefore an ObservableObject it needs an #ObservedObject in a View so changes can be seem
#Published var timeCode: TimeCode
init(timeCode: TimeCode) {
self.timeCode = timeCode
}
}
Your first ForEach probably cannot check if the identity of Array<TimeCodeCellViewModel> has changed.
Perhaps you want to use a separate struct which holds internally an array of TimeCodeCellViewModel and conforms to Identifiable, effectively implementing such protocol.
stuct TCCViewModels: Identifiable {
let models: Array<TimeCodeCellViewModel>
var id: Int {
models.hashValue
}
}
You might as well make this generic too, so it can be reused for different view models in your app:
struct ViewModelsContainer<V: Identifiable> where V.ID: Hashable {
let viewModels: Array<V>
let id: Int
init(viewModels: Array<V>) {
self.viewModels = viewModels
var hasher = Hasher()
hasher.combine(viewModels.count)
viewModels.forEach { hasher.combine($0.id) }
self.id = hasher.finalize
}
}
StepsEntity is a core data entity
Receiving the following error when attempting to display a string value in a TextField: "Cannot convert value of type 'Published<[StepsEntity]>.Publisher' to expected argument type 'Binding'"
I know this is because StepsEntity in my core data model is #Published. #Published works great here as it allows all the data to be updated neatly. How can I display an #Published in a TextField?
Below is the piece where I am receiving the error:
List {
VStack(alignment: .center) {
if let recipeSteps = (vm.recipes[vm.getRecordsCount() - 1].steps?.allObjects as? [StepsEntity])?.sorted { $0.stepNumber < $1.stepNumber } {
if (textFieldCount == 1) {
//do nothing
} else if (textFieldCount > 1) {
ForEach(recipeSteps, id: \.stepNumber) { index in
HStack {
Text(String(index.stepNumber) + ".").bold()
TextField("", text: vm.$recipeSteps) //This is where the error is seen
}
}.onDelete(perform: { index in
self.vm.deleteRecipeSteps(at: index, from: vm.recipes[vm.getRecordsCount() - 1])
})
}
}
}
vm.recipeSteps refers to my CoreDataRelationshipViewModel, which is where all core data functions are handled. this is declared in the view struct as:
#StateObject var vm = CoreDataRelationshipViewModel()
Here is a snippet from the CoreDataRelationshipViewModel class:
class CoreDataRelationshipViewModel: ObservableObject {
let manager = CoreDataManager.instance
#Published var recipes: [RecipeEntity] = []
#Published var recipeSteps: [StepsEntity] = []
init() {
getRecipes()
}
func getRecipes() { ////more functions for retrieving, deleting, etc. in this section
I have tried converting the Published var to a binding but no luck:
TextField("", text: Binding(vm.$recipeSteps)!)
I have also tried referencing the recipeSteps declared in the if let statement within the list, but that does not work either.
I have been at it for a few days, and I think I have exhausted all options. Open to all ideas here. Maybe I need to rebuild my model?
Thoughts?
--Edits--
Upper portion of struct, where variables are created:
struct AddItemView: View {
#StateObject var viewModel = ViewModel()
#State var frameDimensions: CGFloat = 0
#State var imageButtonText: String = "Click To Add Image"
#State var imageToUpload: Data
#StateObject var vm = CoreDataRelationshipViewModel()
#Environment(\.presentationMode) var presentationMode
#State var stepInfo: String = ""
#State var textFieldCount: Int = 1
#State var stepNumber: [Int]
#State var recordsCount = 1
#State var errorText = ""
#State var stepErrorColor = Color.white.opacity(0)
#State var nameErrorColor = Color.white.opacity(0)
var body: some View {
ZStack {
HStack {
Your problem is that
TextField("", text: vm.$recipeSteps)
should actually be
TextField("", text: $vm.recipeSteps)
as you need to pass the view model with Binding rather than recipeSteps (which, when using $ to pass it beyond vm's dot accessor, passes a generic Publisher).
Also, this would only work if the #Published property in your view model conforms to StringProtocol (is a string). Are you sure recipeSteps is a string that can be edited via TextField?
I ended up restructuring the way my core data save works. Instead of saving item by item, I am now looping through a for in loop to save data all at the end. This allows me to display the data locally via some state variables, but then save the full array to my core data entity.
I'm starting with SwiftUI and following WWDC videos I'm starting with #State and #Binding between two views. I got a display right, but don't get how to make back-forth read-write what was not include in WWDC videos.
I have model classes:
class Manufacturer {
let name: String
var models: [Model] = []
init(name: String, models: [Model]) {
self.name = name
self.models = models
}
}
class Model: Identifiable {
var name: String = ""
init(name: String) {
self.name = name
}
}
Then I have a drawing code to display that work as expected:
var body: some View {
VStack {
ForEach(manufacturer.models) { model in
Text(model.name).padding()
}
}.padding()
}
and I see this:
Canvas preview picture
But now I want to modify my code to allows editing this models displayed and save it to my model #Binding so I've change view to:
var body: some View {
VStack {
ForEach(self.$manufacturer.models) { item in
Text(item.name)
}
}.padding()
}
But getting and error in ForEach line:
Generic parameter 'ID' could not be inferred
What ID parameter? I'm clueless here... I thought Identifiable acting as identifier here.
My question is then:
I have one view (ContentView) that "holds" my datasource as #State variable. Then I'm passing this as #Binding to my ManufacturerView want to edit this in List with ForEach fill but cannot get for each binding working - how can I do that?
First, I'm assuming you have something like:
#ObservedObject var manufacturer: Manufacturer
otherwise you wouldn't have self.$manufacturer to begin with (which also requires Manufacturer to conform to ObservableObject).
self.$manufacturer.models is a type of Binding<[Model]>, and as such it's not a RandomAccessCollection, like self.manufacturer.models, which is one of the overloads that ForEach.init accepts.
And if you use ForEach(self.manufacturer.models) { item in ... }, then item isn't going to be a binding, which is what you'd need for, say, a TextField.
A way around that is to iterate over indices, and then bind to $manufacturer.models[index].name:
ForEach(manufacturer.indices) { index in
TextField("model name", self.$manufacturer.models[index].name)
}
In addition to that, I'd suggest you make Model (and possibly even Manufacturer) a value-type, since it appears to be just a storage of data:
struct Model: Identifiable {
var id: UUID = .init()
var name: String = ""
}
This isn't going to help with this problem, but it will eliminate possible issues with values not updating, since SwiftUI wouldn't detect a change.
I'm using an ObservableObject 'DataStore', which contains an array ('exampleList') of objects ('exampleObject').
#Published exampleList = [exampleObject]()
I'm calling the DataStore via #EnvironmentObject ('dataStore').
#EnvironmentObject var dataStore = DataStore()
Then I iterate the list with
ForEach(0..<dataStore.exampleList.count) { index in ....
To bind element of item to a detail view, I'm doing like this:
DetailView(itemBinding: $dataStore.exampleList[index])
Until Xcode11 beta 4, it worked perfectly. Since XCode11 beta 5, it still works but Xcode gives me this alert:
'subscript(_:)' is deprecated: See Release Notes for a migration path
I tried with simpler stuff, with a simple #State var containing an array of strings, and it's the same issue: when calling an element of this array, and trying to use the value into a TextField:
TextField("test", text: $test[0])
I get the same alert.
I don't understand how to fix it. Does that mean that we no longer can bind values inside an array?
Then, how can we iterate an array and bind a specific item?
This is my first question on Stack Overflow, I apologize if my question is clumsy...
Thanks a lot for your answers, I'm using Stack Overflow for years, it's amazing, I always find existing and helpful answers, but it is the first time I can't find any, that's why I'm asking.
Xcode 11, beta 6 UPDATE:
Good news! Just as I suspected, in beta 6, the Binding conformance to MutableCollection has been been replaced with something else. Instead of conforming to MutableCollection, it now let your access the elements via #dynamicMemberLookup. The result is you now can keep doing $text[3] and no longer get a warning! It seems this question can be closed now.
Xcode 11, beta 5. Old answer:
I finally got some time to investigate this a little. As I mentioned in the comments, I think it would be wise to wait until the Collection conformance is completely removed (or replaced with something else). But just to satisfy our curiosity, I have created an extension on Binding, that I think does what the current Collection conformance does. The only difference is that, instead of accessing through a subscript, I implemented a function called element(_ idx: Int) to get a Binding<T> to the element.
If one day the conformance is completely removed, I may change the implementation, and conform to Collection myself. I cannot do it now, because it would conflict with the existent (and deprecated) implementation. For the time being, I think this demonstrate how to handle the warnings if you absolutely want to get rid of them.
Just to be clear. I am not using this code. As long as I can still access the elements through the subscript, I will still do it and ignore the warnings. This is just for academic purposes.
The extension is:
extension Binding where Value: MutableCollection, Value.Index == Int {
func element(_ idx: Int) -> Binding<Value.Element> {
return Binding<Value.Element>(
get: {
return self.wrappedValue[idx]
}, set: { (value: Value.Element) -> () in
self.wrappedValue[idx] = value
})
}
}
And it can be used like this:
struct MainView: View {
#Binding var text: [String]
var body: some View {
TextField("", text: $text.element(0))
TextField("", text: $text.element(1))
TextField("", text: $text.element(2))
}
}
I had to bind the array of an observable object recently, didn't get any warnings on stable XCode11. I did it like this
struct ScheduleTimer: Identifiable {
var id: Int
var name: String
var start: Date
var end: Date
var isActive: Bool
}
struct ScheduleView: View {
#ObservedObject var scheduleController = ScheduleController()
var body: some View {
NavigationView {
Form {
ForEach(scheduleController.timers) { timer in
ScheduleForm(scheduleController: self.scheduleController, timer: timer)
}
}
}
}
}
struct ScheduleForm: View {
#ObservedObject var scheduleController: ScheduleController
var timer: ScheduleTimer
var scheduleIndex: Int {
scheduleController.timers.firstIndex(where: { $0.id == timer.id })!
}
#State var start = Date()
var body: some View {
Section(header: Text(self.scheduleController.timers[scheduleIndex].name)){
DatePicker("From", selection: self.$scheduleController.timers[scheduleIndex].start, displayedComponents: .hourAndMinute)
DatePicker("To", selection: self.$scheduleController.timers[scheduleIndex].end, displayedComponents: .hourAndMinute)
Toggle(isOn: self.$scheduleController.timers[scheduleIndex].isActive) {
Text("")
}.toggleStyle(DefaultToggleStyle())
}
}
}
class ScheduleController: ObservableObject {
#Published var timers = [ScheduleTimer]()
...