I have an init method that takes values from a NSDictionary. This is within my Friend object.
My question is when do I release this particular instantiation of Friend?
- (id)initWithValue:(NSString *)value {
Friend *friend = [[Friend alloc] init];
friend.friendId = [value valueForKeyPath:#"id"];
friend.friendName = [value valueForKeyPath:#"name"];
return friend;
}
I call the init method below to add the Friend objects to a friends array
for (id value in dataDict) {
Friend *friend = [[Friend alloc] initWithValue:value];
[friends addObject:friend];
[friend release];
}
I then do the following in code:
Friend *friend = (Friend *)[friends objectAtIndex:indexPath.row];
If I autorelease the Friend object in the init method then I get a message was sent to deallocated instance when I use the above code to get the particular objects value based on the indexPath.row.
A couple of things:
an init method should not be calling alloc (see diwup's example for the right way to do an init)
it looks like what you're trying to do is make a convenience method that creates, initializes, and returns an (autoreleased) object (similar to +NSString stringWithFormat: etc.). You've almost got it, but you need to (a) not name it "init*", and (b) make it a class method, not an instance method.
Something like:
+ (Friend)friendWithValue:(NSString *)value {
Friend *friend = [[[Friend alloc] init] autorelease];
friend.friendId = [value valueForKeyPath:#"id"];
friend.friendName = [value valueForKeyPath:#"name"];
return friend;
}
You would use that like:
[friends addObject:[Friend friendWithValue:value]];
Not directly answering your question, but these lines of code are definitely dangerous:
- (id)initWithValue:(NSString *)value {
Friend *friend = [[Friend alloc] init];
Instead, you should write like this:
- (id)initWithValue:(NSString *)value {
[super init];
self.friendId = ...;
self.friendName = ...;
return self;
}
And directly answering it: Release your allocated objects ONLY when you are done with them. Create a method and call [object release]; for all your allocated objects. Doing so, you avoid having memory allocation inconsistencies, and this approach is better then calling autorelease.
Related
I get leaks if I dont put it in dealloc. I get a crash EXC_BAD_ACCESS If I do. I cannot see anything wrong with this code. The bad access is pointed at [events release]. Have I made a mistake in the code below or is Instruments just having a laugh at my expense?
events is an NSArray
#interface EventsViewController : UITableViewController
{
#private
NSArray *events;
}
- (void)viewDidLoad
{
events = [[self getEvents] retain];
}
- (void)dealloc
{
[events release];
[super dealloc];
}
- (NSArray*)getEvents
{
NSMutableArray *response = [[[NSMutableArray alloc] init] autorelease];
//Some sql
while(sqlite3_step(statement) == SQLITE_ROW)
{
Event *event = [[[Event alloc] init] autorelease];
event.subject = [NSString stringWithUTF8String:(char *)sqlite3_column_text(statement, 0)];
[response addObject:event];
}
return response;
}
Update
A lot of you are saying the code is fine which is a plus. I dont manipulate events elsewhere - I have removed any code that does to try and single out the crash. Perhaps its in the parent view?
This is the click event that pushes the EventsViewController:
- (void)eventsClick:(id)sender
{
EventsViewController *eventsViewController = [[EventsViewController alloc] initWithNibName:#"EventsViewController" bundle:nil];
eventsViewController.anywhereConnection = anywhereConnection;
eventsViewController.contact = contact;
[[self navigationController] pushViewController:eventsViewController animated:YES];
[eventsViewController release];
}
The crash is actually happening when I return to the parent view. (I think it is considered a parent in this scenario). But perhaps the [eventsViewController release] just triggers dealloc in the EventViewController.
Have you considered just refactoring your code to use ARC? It works with iOS 4 and up and will make your life a lot easier. There are plenty of tutorials out there that will guide you how to do it, and will remove the need to manually figure out the nuances of memory management.
If your Events object has property 'subject' set as assign, then the results of stringWithUTF8String: will not be retained. (Same thing if Events is a C++ object.)
The stringWithUTF8String: method returns an auto-released object that will be released at the next turn of the event loop.
There is a huge difference when you reference a variable via "self", and when you don't.
When you use
events = [[self getEvents] retain];
the memory allocated in getEvents never gets stored in the class property and is basically a leak.
You need to use
self.events = [self getEvents]; // no need to use retain if property is correctly defined.
Then
[events release];
should work fine.
try putting
events = nil;
in dealloc.
In my iOS app, I am using a NSMutableArray, named imageMArray. I have set its getter and setter properties and instantiated it.
In viewDidLoad:
imageMArray=[[NSMutableArray alloc] initWithArray:CategoryImages];
imageMArray=[self shuffleOnlyArray:imageMArray];
In ShuffleOnlyArray Method:
NSMutableArray *destArray1 = [[NSMutableArray alloc] initWithCapacity: [sourceArray count]] ;
return destArray1;
In shuffle Method:
imageMArray=[[self shuffleOnlyArray:imageMArray] retain];
There appears to be a memory leak in the Shuffle method.
Should I release imageMArray or set it to nil? If it should be released, should it be autoreleased?
imageMArray=[[NSMutableArray alloc] initWithArray:CategoryImages];
In the above statement, you have a memoryleak.
Instead you can have like as follows.
imageMArray = [NSMutableArray arrayWithArray:CategoryImages];
In ShuffleOnlyArray Method, return the autoreleased object.
NSMutableArray *destArray1 = [[NSMutableArray alloc] initWithCapacity: [sourceArray count]] ;
return [destArray1 autorelease];
But after you get it, retain (take the ownership) the array object.
imageMArray=[[self shuffleOnlyArray:imageMArray] retain];
Edit
In shuffle method, do as follows:
NSMutableArray *imageMArray1 = [imageMArray mutableCopy];
if( imageMArray )
{
[imageMArray release];
}
imageMArray=[[self shuffleOnlyArray:imageMArray1] retain];
[imageMArray1 release];
Edit 2:
One more solution:
Use the category to shuffle as mentioned in the SO link
No need of creating new and releasing the arrays.
1 You already have a memory leak in the following lines.
imageMArray = [[NSMutableArray alloc] initWithArray:CategoryImages];
imageMArray = [self shuffleOnlyArray:imageMArray];
In the first line you create an object with retain count 1.
Then you say that your imageMArray pointer points to other object. You should release the first object, because you louse the reference to the fist object and you can not release it after you change the reference!
2 You should not use retain because your ShuffleOnlyArray method returns a retained object.
Your factory method should return an autorelease object and the caller of the factory should decide if if will retain it or not.
Hope I was clear enough
I have numerous classes that use the various NSDictionary/NSArray collection classes as ivars but often I run into the problem of my collection class getting released before the containing class is released.
This seems to happen mostly with the collections classes and not with another model class (ie classes that I either created separately or other NS* non-collection classes).
Here are the two variations I've done and seen other people do:
#implementation ClassX
// myDictionary declared as a property in the .h file as this:
// #property (nonatomic, retain) NSMutableDictionary *myDictionary;
#synthesize myDictionary;
- (id)int
{
if (self = [super init])
{
// Option 1:
// If I don't instantiate and assign with 'self',
// myDictionary ivar will not be available
// at times in doSomething.
myDictionary = [NSMutableDictionary dictionary];
// Option 2:
// Doing this, however will keep the dictionary around.
// because I have invoked an extra retain on the dictionary
self.myDictionary = [NSMutableDictionary dictionary];
// Which one is more correct?
}
return self;
}
- (void)doSomething
{
// this will give the error about trying to invoke
// a method on an already released instance
[myDictionary objectForKey:#"myKey"];
}
- (void)dealloc
{
// If I did self.myDictionary in 'init', I then
// need to do this:
[myDictionary release];
[super dealloc];
}
#end
So which approach is the more correct way to hold an instance of NSDictionary within a class?
Option 2 is correct; Option 1 is wrong.
But you left out the best option: myDictionary = [[NSMutableDictionary alloc] init].
I recommend using
myDictionary = [[NSMutableDictionary alloc] init];
The memory is only within the scope of the method you're in if you call [NSMutableDictionary dictionary]. Once you leave the method, that memory goes with it which is why you need to alloc/init if you want to retain the values.
That's why you don't have to release if you don't encounter an alloc.
So for instance:
- (void) doSomething {
// Do not need to release this string
NSString *someText = #"Hello world!";
// You need to release this string:
NSString *otherText = [[NSString alloc] initWithString:#"Hello world!"];
[otherText release];
}
Edited: Removed self after #mipadi #st3fan and caught my mistake. Forgot to post the change. Thanks for keeping me accountable.
I am using a singleton class to share data between views in my iphone app. My singleton class contains a dictionary which I allocate in my -init method:
- (id)init
{
if ( self = [super init] )
{
self.dataList = [[NSMutableDictionary alloc]init];
}
return self;
}
I release it in my dealloc method:
- (void)dealloc
{
[dataList release];
[super dealloc];
}
This dataList is downloaded from a server, and I do this multiple times in my app,so I have a custom setter method to release the old one, and retain the new one:
-(void) setDataList:(NSMutableDictionary*)d
{
if( dataList !=nil){
[dataList release];
dataList = [d retain];
else
dataList = [d retain];
}
ON using the leaks tool, I am getting a memory leak of the dictionary. I think I am doing the alloc and release of the dictionary properly..does the leak occur because the dealloc method of the singleton is not getting called?
Thanks for your help,
Srikanth
Add an autorelease:
self.dataList = [[[NSMutableDictionary alloc] init] autorelease];
When you assign a an object to a property it retains it and whenever you call and init method it retains, bringing the retain count to 2.
It also releases when you reassign it so you can just
self.dataList = newValue;
#syntehsize'd properties take care of all the retain release stuff for you.
I'm using the following method in my code:
- (NSMutableArray *) newOrderedArray:(NSMutableArray *)array ByKey:(NSString *)key ascending:(BOOL)ascending {
NSSortDescriptor *idDescriptor = [[NSSortDescriptor alloc] initWithKey:key ascending:ascending];
NSArray *sortDescriptors = [NSArray arrayWithObject:idDescriptor];
NSArray *orderArray = [array sortedArrayUsingDescriptors:sortDescriptors];
[idDescriptor release];
NSMutableArray *result = [NSMutableArray arrayWithArray:orderArray];
return result;
}
Is this a well-coded convenience method? As I think, it returns an autoreleased NSMutableArray.
This method is called by another one:
- (id) otherMethod {
NSMutableArray *otherResult = [[[NSMutableArray alloc] initWithCapacity:[otherArray count]] autorelease];
// I add some stuff to otherResult and then...
NSMutableArray *result = [dbUtils newOrderedArray:otherResult ByKey:#"objectId" ascending:NO];
return result;
}
This method (otherMethod) is called in some view controller where I want to store returned array and release it when deallocating the view controller. However, when [result retain] is called in this view controller (because I need it to be available and I can't allow it to be deallocated) I receive the following error:
[CFArray release]: message sent to deallocated instance
I've tried to log [result retainCount] just before calling retain and it print "1". I don't understand why an error is thrown when calling retain.
Thank you,
A
I don't see anything technically wrong with the code above--otherMethod should return an autoreleased NSMutableArray. Are you sure you're getting the error when calling retain? It looks more like you might be accidentally be sending release at some point instead of retain.
Stylistically, there's one thing--methods with "new" in the title should always return non-autoreleased objects, so you should either name your method something else (such as orderedArray...) or use [[NSMutableArray alloc] initWithArray:] instead of arrayWithArray. Also, method signatures shouldn't start with a capital (so ByKey should be byKey.
try this:
NSMutableArray *otherResult = [[NSMutableArray initWithCapacity:[otherArray count]];
Because initWithCapacity will return an autoreleased Array. Right now you tell the Autoreleasepool to release the Array twice.
initWithCapacity:does not return an autoreleased object. – Wevah
AFAIK initWithCapacity is a convenience initializier, which by convention return autoreleased objects. So if the object is only used within a local method, the autoreleasepool should deallocate it. Care to elaborate?