I have a bit gantt chart that i want to be visible on an iphone.
It is 7200 x 1800px large, and consists of ~600 bars, each of which is a UILabel.
It is to look like this:
Now i've gotten it to work. And at ~100 bars, i can make it run quite smoothly by simply adding them all to the scroll view. However, with the full 600 (or more eventually) it simply crashes when i instantiate all those uilabels and add them all to the scroll view as subviews.
So what i've done is made it create only the uilabels for the currently visible rows, and as the user scrolls up and down it removes the invisible uilabels and adds the newly visible ones.
However, this jerks quite noticeably as you scroll vertically as it crosses each row boundary, and has to render another row and remove the old row.
Does anyone have any suggestions to solve this? Any ideas what is the slow part? Instantiating the uilabels, or adding them as subviews, or anything?
All help will be greatly appreciated.
Apple has some really good demo code that shows how to do this. Check out TiledScrollView.m especially the layoutSubviews method.
Other things you might consider:
If you labels are quite long horizontally you may need to break them into smaller chunks. Quite long in this context is wider than the screen.
Make sure your UILabels are opaque. Scrolling things that require compositing adds extra overhead which may account for some of your issues.
Looking at your screen shot the row and column headers are not opaque and are using alphas. Whereas this is a nice effect it may be worth temporarily making them opaque too just to see if this is contributing to your problems. I don't think this is contributing too much to your problems; the area being composited is quite small.
Just a thought, but could the issue be that even though you are caching and reusing the labels, is the scroll view still retaining them, so even though you may only have a few labels, each is being retained hundreds of times. If this is so then I would think that the scroll view is still effectively trying to manage those hundreds of rows.
So as #Nathon S asked - are you moving them? i.e. building a finite set of labels and just moving them around on the scroll view to match the viewing area. If you are hiding and re-adding to the scroll view then I would suspect a massive set of retains being the slow down. I would think that with a moving label design, you would not need to do any hides and adds after the the initial display. Which should make it very fast and lightweight.
Related
I have an infinite scrollview in which I add images as the user scrolls. Those images have varying heights and I've been trying to come up with the best way of finding a clear space inside the current bounds of the view that would allow me to add the image view.
Is there anything built-in that would make my search more efficient?
The problem is I want the images to be sort of glued to one another with no blank space between them. Making the search through 320x480 pixels tends to be quite a CPU hog. Does anyone know an efficient method to do it?
Thanks!
It seems that you're scrolling this thing vertically (you mentioned varying image heights).
There's nothing built in to UIScrollView that will do this for you. You'll have to track your UIImageView subviews manually. You could simply maintain the max y coordinate occupied by you images as you add them.
You might consider using UITableView instead, and implementing a very customized tableView:heightForRowAtIndexPath: in your delegate. You would probably need to do something special with the actual cells as well, but it would seem to make your job a little easier.
Also, for what it's worth, you might find a way to avoid making your solution infinite. Be careful about your memory footprint! iOS will shut your app off if things get out of hand.
UPDATE
Ok, now I understand what you're going for. I had imagined that you were presenting photographs or something rectangular like that. If I were trying to cover a scroll view with UILeafs (wah wah) I would take a statistical approach. I would 'paint' leaves randomly along horizontal/vertical strips as the user scrolls. Perhaps that's what you're doing already? Whatever you're doing I think it looks good.
Now I guess that the reason you're asking is to prevent the little random white spots that show through - is that right? If I may suggest a different solution: try to color the background of your scroll view to something earthy that looks good if it shows through here and there.
Also, it occurred to me that you could use a larger template image -- something that already has a nice distribution of leaves -- with transparency all along the outside outline of the leaves but nowhere else. Then you could tile these, but with overlap, so that the alpha just shows through to the leaves below. You could have a number of these images so that it doesn't look obvious. This would take away all of the uncertainty and make your retiling very efficient.
Also, consider learning about CoreAnimation (CALayer in particular) and CoreGraphics/Quartz 2D ). Proper use of these libraries will probably yield great improvements in rendering speed.
UPDATE 2:
If your images are all 150px wide, then split your scrollview into columns and add/remove based on those (as discussed in chat).
Good luck!
This is somewhat of a hypothetical question, but I can imagine this situation coming up at some point in the future: Let's assume for a moment that I have a freakishly complicated hierarchy of UIViews that I'd need to render only once. Let's also assume that, once drawn, I have no further use for the information (UIImages, labels, custom views, coords, etc.) beneath the parent view. Rather than retaining them, the idea is to free all the extra memory they use while avoiding a redraw. The result would be the same as drawing to an offscreen buffer and then pushing it onscreen. Is it possible to achieve this using UIView/CGLayer right out of the box, or is the only option to convert the content of the parent CGLayer into a UIImage?
Just curious. I'd imagine in most situations the overhead of keeping a few extra views around is negligible, but memory is memory, and I haven't been able to find anything on it in the official docs beyond allocating bitmaps.
Thanks!
This strikes me as something very risky. Things beyond your control may happened that require the view to be redrawn, such as a notification appearing or the view being effected by the phone call active green bar thingy at the top of the screen.
I suggest that if you have that many views in your hierarchy there will be so many other performance problems that come into play that saving a few bytes after redraw will be the least of your problems.
I can think about overriding -(void)drawRect:(CGRect)rect; method, drawing only once to offscreen before moving that image to the screen according to some boolean flag, but it may lead to a monstrous bugs and should be desined properly. Another thing is that it may lead to overriding also the -(void)layoutSubviews;, thought it may be overhead if you've overriden the firs one...
I'm making an iPhone game and using UIView objects to draw sprites. Most of the time, I have no performance problems. However, once I have around 15 to 20 objects on the screen (and maybe 5 of them moving around), the game becomes considerably slower, especially on the iPhone 3G. The frame rate can drop to as low as a single frame per second.
Is this simply a limitation of using UIView objects, or should iOS be able to handle this many UIView objects on screen at the same time?
In order to isolate the problem, I've made drawing my views very simple — drawing a red rectangle. drawRect is only getting called once per view. The view hierarchy is very simple and shallow. I'm using CADisplayLink to update the UIView locations every frame.
There's very little else going on, so I'd like to hear if anyone else has had success using this number of UIView objects.
The key to my problems ended up being that I had labels on top of my game content. The labels are not opaque, which likely was a large part of the problem, as phix23 suggested.
The first thing that made a big difference was removing a frames per second label that was on top of the content. Having a label that changed content on every frame caused a lot of slowdown.
I also had a large label that displayed on top of much of the game and changed shape when you level up. It turned out that drawing this label on top of everything caused a lot of slowdown as well.
In answer to my original question, I've found that on an iPhone 3G I can support about 30-40 opaque UIViews onscreen at the same time, with 2 or 3 non-opaque views as well. Non-opaque UIViews that change size, shape, or location are by far the worst, and even one of these that covers a significant amount of the screen can quickly cause problems.
If you're setting the opaque property of each view to NO, keep in mind that this seriously affects the speed of drawing the views. If your views aren't transparent, you should leave this set to YES, which is default.
for such type of application you should use CoreGraphics / Quartz / OpenGL but anyway I don't think there is a limitation on such low count. For example if I have a table view with 9 rows and each row has 5 subviews its still displayed acceptable fast. Have you tried using UIView animation to change the position in view?
good luck in learning OpenGL ;)
I'm trying to implement a view that shows a grid of information without using a UITableView, however, since I'm displaying about 36 different statistics, with its label I will have to initialize and use 72 UILabels. Does having so many UILabels mean that my iPhone app's performance will be significantly negatively affected? Is there a way to reuse some of the UILabels to decrease the number of UILabels that must be loaded at one time, or should I just resort to drawing everything on a surface instead?
First of all you should test the interface your thinking of and see if it takes a performance hit. Having a lot of labels all loaded at once will increase your memory footprint but depending on what else is going on in the app, it might not matter.
Secondly, you can't easily reuse the labels but it is possible. However, you would have to constantly monitor the displayed area of the scrollview and move the labels frames around as the view scrolled. I doubt you could do that efficiently. It would take a lot of coding in any case.
Thirdly, any grid like layout can be easily displayed in a table without making it look like a table. For example, the photopicker layout is a table but it looks like a bunch of icons on a white background. Another app I saw used a table to display paragraphs of text but it looked like an ordinary scrolling textview. Every row in a table can be customized to display exactly what you want. In principle, you could use a different cell for every row and they could all be unique in their height and contents.
The advantage of the table is the the table manages what is and is not on screen for you. It does reuse cells and their contents which makes them more efficient. The table also makes it easier to manage a lot of data.
I'm trying to make a level-of-detail line chart, where the user can zoom in/out horizontally by using two fingers, and grow the contentSize attribute of the the UIScrollView field. They can also scroll horizontally to shift left or right and see more of the chart (check any stock on Google Finance charts to get an idea of what I'm talking about). Potentially, the scroll view could grow to up to 100x its original size, as the user is zooming in.
My questions are:
- Has anyone had any experience with UIScrollViews that have such large contentSize restrictions? Will it work?
- The view for the scroll view could potentially be really huge, since the user is zooming in. How is this handled in memory?
- Just a thought, but would it be possible to use UITableViewCells, oriented to scroll horizontally, to page in/out the data?
This is kind of an open ended question right now - I'm still brainstorming myself. If anyone has any ideas or has implemented such a thing before, please respond with your experience. Thanks!
This is quite an old topic, but still I want to share some my experiences.
Using such a large UIView (100x than its origin size) in UIScrollView could cause Memory Warning. You should avoid render the entire UIView at once.
A better way to implement this is to render the only area which you can see and the area just around it. So, UIViewScroll can scroll within this area smoothly. But what if user scrolled out of the area that has been rendered? Use delegate to get notified when user scroll out of the pre-rendered area and try to render the new area which is going to be showed.
The basic idea under this implementation is to use 9 UIViews (or more) to tile a bigger area, when user scrolled (or moved) from old position to new position. Just move some UIViews to new place to make sure that one of UIView is the main view which you can see mostly, and other 8 UIViews are just around it.
Hope it is useful.
I have something similar, although probably not to the size your talking about. The UIScrollView isn't a problem. The problem is that if you're drawing UIViews on it (rather than drawing lines yourself) UIViews that are well, well off the screen continue to exist in memory. If you're actually drawing the lines by creating your own UIView and responding to drawRect, it's fine.
Assuming that you're a reasonably experienced programmer, getting a big scroll view working that draws pars of the chart is only a days work, so my recommendation would be to create a prototype for it, and run the prototype under the object allocations tool and see if that indicates any problems.
Sorry for the vagueness of my answer; it's a brainstorming question
But still, this approach (in the example above) is not good enough in some cases. Cause we only rendered a limited area in the UIScrollView.
User can use different gestures in UIScrollView: drag or fling. With drag, the pre-rendered 8 small UIViews is enough for covering the scrolling area in most of the case. But with flinging, UIScrollView could scroll over a very large area when user made a quick movement, and this area is totally blank (cause we didn't render it) while scrolling. Even we can display the right content after the UIScrollView stops scrolling, the blank during scrolling isn't very UI friendly to user.
For some apps, this is Ok, for example Google map. Since the data couldn't be downloaded immediately. Waiting before downloading is reasonable.
But if the data is local, we should eliminate this blank area as possible as we can. So, pre-render the area that is going to be scrolled is crucial. Unlike UITableView, UIScrollView doesn't have the ability to tell us which cell is going to be displayed and which cell is going to be recycled. So, we have to do it ourselves. Method [UIScrollViewDelegate scrollViewWillEndDragging:withVelocity:targetContentOffset:] will be called when UIScrollView starts to decelerating (actually, scrollViewWillBeginDecelerating is the method been called before decelerating, but in this method we don't know the information about what content will be displayed or scrolled). So based on the UIScrollView.contentOffset.x and parameter targetContentOffset, we can know exactly where the UIScrollView starts and where the UIScrollView will stop, then pre-render this area to makes the scrolling more smoothly.