Scheduling a IEnumerable periodically with .NET reactive extensions - system.reactive

Question

Say for example I have an enumerable
dim e = Enumerable.Range(0, 1024)
I'd like to be able to do
dim o = e.ToObservable(Timespan.FromSeconds(1))
So that the observable would generate values every second
until the enumerable is exhausted. I can't figure a simple way to
do this.

Answer 1

You can use Interval together with Zip to get the desired functionality:
var sequence = Observable.Interval(TimeSpan.FromSeconds(1))
.Zip(e.ToObservable(), (tick, index) => index)

Answer 2

I have also looked for the solution and after reading the intro to rx made my self one:
There is an Observable.Generate() overload which I have used to make my own ToObservable() extension method, taking TimeSpan as period:
public static class MyEx {
public static IObservable<T> ToObservable<T>(this IEnumerable<T> enumerable, TimeSpan period)
{
return Observable.Generate(
enumerable.GetEnumerator(),
x => x.MoveNext(),
x => x,
x => x.Current,
x => period);
}
public static IObservable<T> ToObservable<T>(this IEnumerable<T> enumerable, Func<T,TimeSpan> getPeriod)
{
return Observable.Generate(
enumerable.GetEnumerator(),
x => x.MoveNext(),
x => x,
x => x.Current,
x => getPeriod(x.Current));
}
}
Already tested in LINQPad. Only concerning about what happens with the enumerator instance after the resulting observable is e.g. disposed. Any corrections appreciated.

Answer 3

You'd need something to schedule notifying observers with each value taken from the Enumerable.
You can use the recursive Schedule overload on an Rx scheduler.
Public Shared Function Schedule ( _
scheduler As IScheduler, _
dueTime As TimeSpan, _
action As Action(Of Action(Of TimeSpan)) _
) As IDisposable
On each scheduled invocation, simply call enumerator.MoveNext(), and call OnNext(enumerator.Current), and finally OnCompleted when MoveNext() returns false. This is pretty much the bare-bones way of doing it.
An alternative was to express your requirement is to restate it as "for a sequence, have a minimum interval between each value".
See this answer. The test case resembles your original question.

Answer 4

You could always do this very simple approach:
dim e = Enumerable.Range(0, 1024)
dim o = e.ToObservable().Do(Sub (x) Thread.Sleep(1000))
When you subscribe to o the values take a second to be produced.

Answer 5

I can only assume that you are using Range to dumb down your question.
Do you want every value that the Enumerable pushes to be delayed by a second?
var e = Enumerable.Range(0, 10);
var o = Observable.Interval(TimeSpan.FromSeconds(1))
.Zip(e, (_,i)=>i);
Or do you want only the last value of the Enumerable at each second to be pushed. i.e. reading from Enumerable that is evaluating as you enumerate it (perhaps some IO). In which case CombineLatest is more useful than Zip.
Or perhaps you just want to get a value every second, in which case just use the Observable.Interval method
var o = Observable.Interval(TimeSpan.FromSeconds(1));
If you explain your problem space then the community will be able to better help you.
Lee
*Excuse the C# answer, but I dont know what the equivalent VB.NET code would be.