Contextual serialization from WebApi endpoint based on permissions - rest

Question

I am using the Asp.Net Web Api. I would like to be able to filter out certain fields on the response objects based on the connected clients access rights.
Example:
class Foo
{
[AccessFilter("Uberlord")]
string Wibble { get; set; }
string Wobble { get; set; }
}
When returning data the filed Wibble should only be returned if the current users context can satisfy the value of "Uberlord".
There are three avenues that I am exploring but I have not got a working solution:
A custom WebApi MediaTypeFormatter.
A custom json.net IContractResolver.
Some sort of AOP wrapper for controllers that manipulates the response object
My issue with these are:
The custom formatter does not feel like the right place to do it but might be the only option.
The custom json serializer would not have access to the current context so I would have to work that out.
With the first two options you would require specific implementations for each response format, json, xml, some custom format, etc. This would mean that if another response type is supported then a custom formatter / serializer is required to prevent sensitive data leaking.
The AOP controller wrapper would require a lot of reflection.
An additional bonus would be to strip out values from the fields on an inbound request object using the same mechanism.
Have I missed an obvious hook? Has this been solved by another way?

Answer 1

It was actually a lot simpler than I first thought. What I did not realise is that the DelegatingHandler can be used to manipulate the response as well as the request in the Web Api Pipeline.
Lifecycle of an ASP.NET Web API Message
Delegating Handler
Delegating handlers are an extensibility point in the message pipeline allowing you to massage the Request before passing it on to the rest of the pipeline. The response message on its way back has to pass through the Delegating Handler as well, so any response can also be monitored/filtered/updated at this extensibility point.
Delegating Handlers if required, can bypass the rest of the pipeline too and send back and Http Response themselves.
Example
Here is an example implementation of a DelegatingHandler that can either manipulate the response object or replace it altogether.
public class ResponseDataFilterHandler : DelegatingHandler
{
protected override System.Threading.Tasks.Task<HttpResponseMessage> SendAsync(HttpRequestMessage request, CancellationToken cancellationToken)
{
return base.SendAsync(request, cancellationToken)
.ContinueWith(task =>
{
var response = task.Result;
//Manipulate content here
var content = response.Content as ObjectContent;
if (content != null && content.Value != null)
{
((SomeObject)content.Value).SomeProperty = null;
}
//Or replace the content
response.Content = new ObjectContent(typeof(object), new object(), new JsonMediaTypeFormatter());
return response;
});
}
}
Microsoft article on how to implement a delegating handler and add it to the pipeline.HTTP Message Handlers in ASP.NET Web API

Answer 2

I have a similar question in the works over here: ASP.NET WebAPI Conditional Serialization based on User Role
A proposed solution that I came up with is to have my ApiController inherit from a BaseApiController which overrides the Initalize function to set the appropriate formatter based on the user's role. I haven't decided if I will go this way yet, but perhaps it will work for you.
protected override void Initialize(System.Web.Http.Controllers.HttpControllerContext controllerContext)
{
base.Initialize(controllerContext);
// If the user is in a sensitive-data access role
controllerContext.Configuration.Formatters.Add(/*My Formatter*/);
// Otherwise use the default ones added in global app_start that defaults to remove sensitive data
}