Is startup.el really used? - emacs

I'm on windows, and according to this startup.el is used at the startup of emacs. But when I set code in this file (C:\Users\frountch\Progs\emacs24\share\emacs\24.3.50\lisp\startup.el in my case, after deleting the .elc file), it is not executed.
For instance I change the defun normal-top-level from:
(defun normal-top-level ()
"Emacs calls this function when it first starts up.
It sets `command-line-processed', processes the command-line,
reads the initialization files, etc.
It is the default value of the variable `top-level'."
(if command-line-processed
(message "Back to top level.")
to
(devar myload (load-path))
(devar myload2 nil)
(defun normal-top-level ()
"fuuuuuuu"
(setq myload2 (load-path))
(if command-line-processed
(message "Back to top level.")
After that, myload and myload2 are not defined.
Worse, if I delete startup.el and startup.elc, emacs can still be launched!
Is startup.el really used? How can I check that?
If I define
(defun normal-top-level ()
"fuuuuu"
(message "fuuu"
)
)
in startup.el (startup.elc still deleted), when I C-h f, the help windows still shows
normal-top-level is a compiled Lisp function in `startup.el'.
(normal-top-level)
Emacs calls this function when it first starts up. It sets
command-line-processed', processes the command-line, reads the
initialization files, etc. It is the default value of the variable
top-level'.
But when I click on 'startup.el'. it opens my defun (with fuuu)!?
Is this a Win$ specific problem? is the startup really inside the binary?
version is 24.3.50.1

startup.el isn't used in a standard Emacs binary. Note that Startup Summary doesn't suggest this. It doesn't say that the source library startup.el is actually loaded during startup. It merely states that a function defined in startup.el is called at startup.
startup.el is one of the essential core libraries that are “dumped” into the Emacs binary during compilation, to decrease startup time and increase performance. Hence, the compiled Emacs binary does not load the source library startup.el, but instead reads its compiled byte code from the data section of the Emacs binary.
Yet, the code in startup.el is part of an Emacs binary, and evaluated at startup. While you can't check this directly by modifying startup.el in a precompiled Emacs distribution, you can easily verify this by reading the source code of Emacs, or by building Emacs from source with a patched startup.el.
This is not specific to Windows. In this regard, Emacs behaves the same on all supported operating systems.
Please note that startup.el is not intended to be modified by the user. Use ~/.emacs.d/init.el to configure and customize your Emacs.

Related

How does the "pdf-tools" package overrides "dired-find-file" method?

After installing pdf-tools the dired mode opens the pdf file with PDFView mode as major mode.
(use-package pdf-tools
:ensure t
:config
(pdf-tools-install t))
How does the pdf-tools package be able to accomplish this?
The Help for RET key in dried buffer says it is bound to dired-find-file
RET (translated from ) runs the command dired-find-file (found
in dired-mode-map), which is an interactive compiled Lisp function.
I searched for dired-find-file in pdf-tools installed elisp files and could not find any advice-add's?
Also please explain how can one go about finding arbitrary key bindings like this one?
What it modified is not directly related to dired, but to how Emacs decides to open files in general. The part of the code that is responsible for that is in pdf-tools-install-noverify, itself called by pdf-tools-install. The first two lines of the function are:
(add-to-list 'auto-mode-alist pdf-tools-auto-mode-alist-entry)
(add-to-list 'magic-mode-alist pdf-tools-magic-mode-alist-entry)
the relevant variables pdf-tools-<auto/magic>-mode-alist-entry being constants defined earlier in the file pdf-tools.el.
You can check the relevant documentation for auto-mode-alist and magic-mode-alist, but to sum up, the former is a mapping from "filenames" (or more precisely, file patterns -- typically, regexps matching file extensions) to major modes, and the latter is a mapping from "beginning of a buffer" to a major mode (see also this wikipedia page on magic numbers/file signatures).
As to how one can determine that: because it is not directly related to key bindings/advices/redefinition of functions, the only "general" option is to explore the "call stack" ! The package tells you to put (pdf-tools-install) somewhere in your init file to activate the package, so you can try to see what this function actually does -- and going a bit further, you see that it is essentially a wrapper around pdf-tools-install-noverify, which does the real job of setting everything up.

Execution order of eval-after-load vs hooks for a given major mode in emacs

Let's assume the particular mode I'm working with is python-mode.
The Emacs manual specifies following for hooks:
Every major mode command is supposed to run a normal hook called the mode hook as one of the last steps of initialization.
From Major mode conventions:
Each major mode should have a normal mode hook named modename-mode-hook. The very last thing the major mode command should do is to call run-mode-hooks.
And with-eval-after-load executes code after code is loaded (e.g. required), and runs immediately if already required.
I have following in my init file:
(add-hook 'python-mode-hook 'my-post-python)
Also I have added
(with-eval-after-load 'python-mode
(setq-default python-basic-offset 7) ; setting some option
(add-to-list 'python-globals-list "console"))
Now assuming I open Emacs, followed by opening a Python file buffer, what are the loading/execution orders with respect to hooks and with-eval-after-load? From the docs specified at start, it seems mode hooks will run before with-eval-after-load code?
More specifically, are mode hooks are run every time a buffer is entered/ made the current buffer? (P.S. this is hard to find from the docs/manual, any links clarifying any of the above in the docs/manual are welcome).
Now assuming I open emacs, followed by opening a python file buffer, what are the loading/execution order with respect to hooks and with-eval-after-load?
Assuming python.el has not already been loaded, then:
You visit foo.py.
set-auto-mode is called and determines that python-mode is appropriate, and calls that.
The python-mode function is (at this point) an autoload definition for the python-mode library1, which is consequently loaded.
At the end of loading, your with-eval-after-load for the python-mode library is evaluated.
The real python-mode function (newly defined by loading the library) is called, at the end of which:
python-mode-hook runs.
Are mode hooks are run every time a buffer is entered/ made the current buffer?
No, they run every time the mode function is called.
1 The default library is python.el which uses (provide 'python), but from your with-eval-after-load you're evidentially using the python-mode.el library instead.

Emacs: auto-complete-mode on but no auto-suggestions showing (Emacs lisp mode)

I'm puzzled as to why nothing pops up (in Emacs lisp mode) when I begin typing a function name. For example, after typing (def on a new line, I would assume that auto-complete should be showing me a alist of options which includes defun. Am not sure how long the default delay is, but I waited for a few seconds and nothing happened. Any suggestions?
Details regarding my installation process:
Installed using package-install via Melpa
Added the following two lines to my init.el file:
(require 'auto-complete-config)
(ac-config-default)
Confirmed that load-path includes the folder containing the .el files associated with auto-complete. (I have it set-up to recursively add all folders under path/to/my/.emacs.d/.)
Confirmed (via describe-variable) that ac-dictionary-directories includes the correct directories when Emacs starts up. As reference, it includes the following two directories:
ac-dictionary-directories is a variable defined in 'auto-complete.el'.
Its value is ("/home/dchaudh/Dropbox/dchaudhUbuntu/emacs/.emacs.d/elpa/auto-complete-20140824.1658/dict")
Confirmed that auto-complete-mode is on when I open my init.el file, which obviously triggers emacs-lisp-mode (I can see Emacs Lisp in my mode line). The following is included in the summary of active modes (i.e., via describe-mode):
Global-Auto-Complete minor mode (no indicator)
Toggle Auto-Complete mode in all buffers.
With prefix ARG, enable Global-Auto-Complete mode if ARG is positive;
otherwise, disable it. If called from Lisp, enable the mode if
ARG is omitted or nil.
Not a direct answer, but company works fine out of the box in emacs-lisp-mode, so you might want to try that one.
In my experience, other modes (e.g. flyspell) can interfere with auto-complete operation. (There is a workaround for slyspell built into auto-complete but you have to activate it in your. emacs file.)
I'd suggest trying it with an empty. emacs and then gradually adding parts of your configuration back in. You should be able to find the problem that way.

eval-when-compile not being honored?

I'm attempting to install ace-jump-mode for emacs 24.1.50.1.
I've installed it with M-x package-install, and calling M-x ace-jump-mode activates it and prompts for a letter, but upon entering a letter, I get the error:
Symbol's function definition is void: every
Running emacs -q (and then running (add-to-list 'load-path "~/.emacs.d/elpa") like I have in my .emacs file) allows me to load ace-jump-mode and it functions without an issue. Assuming thus that the error exists in my .emacs, I commented out everything in my .emacs, and reopened emacs regularly, but still get the error.
From some searching around, I think the issue is the code in ace-jump-mode.el
(eval-when-compile
(require 'cl))
is not working correctly when I don't use emacs -q. When I M-x load-library cl, everything works fine.
I imagine that since I can't find any references to this online, its not a common bug, so it must be an issue with my config. I know I could just load cl in my .emacs, but I don't see the need to load the entire package just for one function.
Does anyone know how to fix this? Or, how to load only one function from cl?
Thanks.
Emacs is self documenting, C-h f every will show you that this
function is defined in cl-extra not cl, but loading cl autoloads it, so
it does become available.
Some things with how cl is loaded may have changed with Emacs 24, which
broke this library, I'm not certain. Like you found out, the easiest fix is
to just
(require 'cl)
in your init file. This isn't as a big deal as you make it out. A lot of
libraries you might use will do this anyway, so it's likely you're just
changing the order things get loaded.
The alternative is to just submit a patch to the author of ace-jump-mode
that avoids using every, which is more inconvenient.
Finally, if you ever got ace-jump-mode to work it was because you loaded the
uncompiled ".el" file instead of the compiled ".elc" file, which would have
run (require 'cl), meaning that both cl and cl-seq will have been loaded
somewhere along the way. So there is no magic that can make this work
without loading those files.
(eval-when-compile <foo>) means that <foo> is only executed when compiling the file (or when running it uncompiled). So if you compile your file, the resulting file won't load cl, which is a problem since every is only defined when cl is loaded. (eval-when-compile <foo>) is used to load macros (such as ignore-errors), since these are only needed during compilation, but every is not a macro, hence your problem.

Using Emacs as an IDE

Currently my workflow with Emacs when I am coding in C or C++ involves three windows. The largest on the right contains the file I am working with. The left is split into two, the bottom being a shell which I use to type in compile or make commands, and the top is often some sort of documentation or README file that I want to consult while I am working. Now I know there are some pretty expert Emacs users out there, and I am curious what other Emacs functionally is useful if the intention is to use it as a complete IDE. Specifically, most IDEs usually fulfill these functions is some form or another:
Source code editor
Compiler
Debugging
Documentation Lookup
Version Control
OO features like class lookup and object inspector
For a few of these, it's pretty obvious how Emacs can fit these functions, but what about the rest? Also, if a specific language must be focused on, I'd say it should be C++.
Edit: One user pointed out that I should have been more specific when I said 'what about the rest'. Mostly I was curious about efficient version control, as well as documentation lookup. For example, in SLIME it is fairly easy to do a quick hyperspec lookup on a Lisp function. Is there a quick way to look up something in C++ STL documentation (if I forgot the exact syntax of hash_map, for example)?
You'll have to be specific as to what you mean by "the rest". Except for the object inspector (that I"m aware of), emacs does all the above quite easily:
editor (obvious)
compiler - just run M-x compile and enter your compile command. From there on, you can just M-x compile and use the default. Emacs will capture C/C++ compiler errors (works best with GCC) and help you navigate to lines with warnings or errors.
Debugging - similarly, when you want to debug, type M-x gdb and it will create a gdb buffer with special bindings
Documentation Lookup - emacs has excellent CScope bindings for code navigation. For other documentation: Emacs also has a manpage reader, and for everything else, there's the web and books.
version control - there are lots of Emacs bindings for various VCS backends (CVS, SCCS, RCS, SVN, GIT all come to mind)
Edit: I realize my answer about documentation lookup really pertained to code navigation. Here's some more to-the-point info:
Looking up manpages, info manuals, and Elisp documentation from within emacs
Looking up Python documentation from within Emacs.
Google searching will no doubt reveal further examples.
As the second link shows, looking up functions (and whatever) in other documentation can be done, even if not supported out of the box.
I have to recommend Emacs Code Browser as a more "traditional" IDE style environment for emacs.
EDIT: I also now recommend Magit highly over the standard VCS interface in emacs.
Instead of running a make command in the shell window, have you tried M-x compile? It will run your make command, display errors, and in many cases make it very easy to jump to the line of code that caused the error if the output includes filenames and line numbers.
If you're a fan of IDEs, you might also want to look at emacs' speedbar package (M-x speedbar). And, if you haven't already, learn about how to use tags tables to navigate your code.
There are corners of emacs that once discovered make you more productive in ways you never thought of. As others have mentioned, using tags is a fantastic and fast way to zoom around your source code and using M-/ (dabbrev-expand) often does exactly what you expect when completing a variable name.
Using occur is useful to get a buffer with all occurences of a regular expression in a buffer. That's really handy when refactoring code and looking for fragments of code or uses of variables, or if you use TODO markers in your source files and you want to visit them all.
flush-lines, sort-numeric-fields, replace-regexp and rectangle functions can be really useful for taking a dump from some tool and converting it to useful data such as an elisp program or a comma delimited spreadsheet.
I wrote a page about IDE like things you can do with emacs
http://justinsboringpage.blogspot.com/2007/09/11-visual-studio-tricks-in-emacs.html
Learning elisp is a another great way to answer for yourself what else emacs can do beyond what a typical IDE can do.
For example I've blogged about writing Perforce helper functions like blame (writing your own means you can make it behave exactly as you want)...
http://justinsboringpage.blogspot.com/2009/01/who-changed-line-your-working-on-last.html
I've also written code that dynamically creates comments for a function at point, that matches the coding standards I'm working with.
None of my elisp code is particularly great, and most of it exists already in libraries, but it's really useful to be able to make emacs do custom stuff that just comes up during a working day.
You can find detailed description of emacs & version control integration on my site. I'm also working on article about using Emacs as Development Environment for many languages - C/C++, Java, Perl, Lisp/Scheme, Erlang, etc...
For version control, there are several things that you can use, depending on what version control system you use. But some of the functionality is common to all of them.
vc.el is the built-in way to handle version control at a file level. It has backends for most version control systems. For instance, the Subversion backend comes with Emacs, and there are git backends and others available from other sources.
The most useful command is C-x v v (vc-next-action) that does the appropriate next action for the file you are visiting. This might mean updating from the repository or commiting your changes, vc.el also rebinds C-x C-q to check in and out files if you are using a system that needs it (like RCS).
Other very useful commands are C-x v l and C-x v = that show you the log and current diff for the file you are using.
But for real productivity, you should avoid using the single-file vc.el commands other than for simple things. There are several packages that can give you an overview of the status of your whole tree, and give you more power, and not to mention the ability to create coherent commits spanning several files.
Most of these are heavily influenced or based on the original pcl-cvs/pcvs for CVS. There are even two of them that comes with subversion, psvn.el and dsvn.el. There are packages for git etc.
Okay, everyone here is giving perfect hints to make emacs a great IDE.
But anyone should keep in mind that, when you customize your emacs with a lot of extension (especially with the ones for type-checking on the fly, function definition lookups etc) your emacs will load very, very slow for an editor.
To workaround this, I would highly recommend to use emacs in server mode.
It is pretty simple to use, no need to customize your init file.
You just need to start emacs in daemon mode;
emacs --daemon
This will create an emacs server, then you can connect it either from terminal, or from gui. I'd also recommend to create some aliases to make it easy to call.
alias ec="emacsclient -t"
alias ecc="emacsclient -c &"
# some people also prefer this but no need to fight here;
alias vi="emacsclient -t"
This way, emacs will fire up even faster than gedit, promise.
The one possible problem here, if you are running emacs daemon from your casual user, you probably can't connect emacs server as root.
So, if you need to open a file that has root access; use tramp instead. Just run your emacs client with your normal user and open files like this;
C-x C-f
/sudo:root#localhost/some/file/that/has/root/access/permissions
# on some linux distro it might be `/su:root#...`
This made my life easier, I can open my heavy customized python IDE in miliseconds this way. You may also want to add emacs --daemon to your system startup, or create a desktop file for emacsclient. Thats up to you.
More on emacs daemon and emacs client can be found at wiki;
http://www.emacswiki.org/emacs/EmacsAsDaemon
http://www.emacswiki.org/emacs/EmacsClient
I agree that you should learn about M-x compile (bind that and M-x next-error to a short key sequence).
Learn about the bindings for version control (e.g. vc-diff, vc-next-action, etc.)
Look into registers. You not only can remember locations in buffers but whole window configurations (C-x r w -- window-configuration-to-register).
A starting point (which may be non-obvious) for exploring the VC features of Emacs is M-x vc-next-action.
It does the "next logical version control operation" on the current file, depending on the state of the file and the VC backend. So if the file is not under version control, it registers it, if the file has been changed, the changes are submitted etc.
It takes a little getting used to, but I find it very useful.
Default keybinding is C-x v v
I know this is a very old post. But this question is valid for emacs beginners.
IMO the best way to use emacs as an ide is to use a language server protocol with emacs. You can find all the information about language servers in the linked website.
For a quick setup, i would urge you to go to this page eglot . IMO eglot does it's job pretty well. It integrates well with auto completions packages like company. Provides find reference, and more.
Also for a debugger, you may need specific debuggers for specific languages. You can use gdb from within emacs. Just type M-x gdb .
For compiling your code, it's best to use shell-commands. I am working on this project eproj. It's gonna take a while to complete it. But all it does is maps shell command to project type. And builds you project via shell. It does the same to execute command. I may need help completing this project. It's not ready for use, but if you know a bit of elisp you can go through the code.
That aside, it's always best to use the emacs compile command.
For version control, I haven't yet seen any other package which can match the power of magit. It's specific to git. Also for git there is another package git-timemachine, which i find very useful.
Object lookup and class lookup is provided by language server protocol.
A project tree can be used for ide like interface with treemacs.
There is also a project Interaction Library called projectile.
For auto completion, I find company-mode very useful.
Truly emacs can be made to do anything.
There's a TFS.el for emacs integration into Microsoft TFS. It works with any TFS, including the TFS that runs Codeplex.com.
Basic steps to setup:
Place tfs.el in your load-path.
In your .emacs file:
(require 'tfs)
(setq tfs/tf-exe "c:\\vs2008\\common7\\ide\\tf.exe")
(setq tfs/login "/login:domain\\userid,password")
-or-
(setq tfs/login (getenv "TFSLOGIN")) ;; if you have this set
also in your .emacs file, set local or global key bindings for tfs commands. like so:
(global-set-key "\C-xvo" 'tfs/checkout)
(global-set-key "\C-xvi" 'tfs/checkin)
(global-set-key "\C-xvp" 'tfs/properties)
(global-set-key "\C-xvr" 'tfs/rename)
(global-set-key "\C-xvg" 'tfs/get)
(global-set-key "\C-xvh" 'tfs/history)
(global-set-key "\C-xvu" 'tfs/undo)
(global-set-key "\C-xvd" 'tfs/diff)
(global-set-key "\C-xv-" 'tfs/delete)
(global-set-key "\C-xv+" 'tfs/add)
(global-set-key "\C-xvs" 'tfs/status)
(global-set-key "\C-xva" 'tfs/annotate)
(global-set-key "\C-xvw" 'tfs/workitem)
compile, next-error, and previous-error are all pretty important commands for C++ development in Emacs (works great on grep output too). Etags, visit-tags-table, and find-tag are important as well. completion.el is one of the great unsung hacks of the 20th century, and can speed up your C++ hacking by an order of magnitude. Oh and let's not forget ediff.
I've yet to learn how to use version control without visiting a shell, but now that I'm running commits so much more frequently (with git) I will probably have to.
You might also find tabbar useful. It emulates the only behavior I missed when moving from Eclipse to Emacs. Bound to "," and "." for moving to the previous and next tab bar, it relives you from switching the buffer by Ctrl-x b all the time.
Unfortunately, the mentioned web page does not provide the correct version to download. Most Ubuntu versions, however, deliver it in their emacs-goodies packages.
I use emacs on Windows. the compile module is nice, but I wanted compile to be smarter about the compile command line it suggests. It's possible to use "File Variables" to specify compile-command, but I wanted something a little smarter than that. So I wrote a little function to help out. It guesses the compile command to use, to prompt the user with, when running compile.
The guess function looks for a vbproj or csproj or sln file, and if found, it suggests msbuild. Then it looks at the buffer file name, and depending on that, suggests different things. A .wxs file means it's a WIX project, and you likely want to build an MSI, so the guess logic suggests an nmake command for the MSI. If it's a Javascript module, then the suggestion is to run jslint-for-wsh.js to lint the .js file. As a fallback, it suggests nmake.
The code I use looks like this:
(defun cheeso-guess-compile-command ()
"set `compile-command' intelligently depending on the
current buffer, or the contents of the current directory."
(interactive)
(set (make-local-variable 'compile-command)
(cond
((or (file-expand-wildcards "*.csproj" t)
(file-expand-wildcards "*.vcproj" t)
(file-expand-wildcards "*.vbproj" t)
(file-expand-wildcards "*.shfbproj" t)
(file-expand-wildcards "*.sln" t))
"msbuild ")
;; sometimes, not sure why, the buffer-file-name is
;; not set. Can use it only if set.
(buffer-file-name
(let ((filename (file-name-nondirectory buffer-file-name)))
(cond
;; editing a .wxs (WIX Soluition) file
((string-equal (substring buffer-file-name -4) ".wxs")
(concat "nmake "
;; (substring buffer-file-name 0 -4) ;; includes full path
(file-name-sans-extension filename)
".msi" ))
;; a javascript file - run jslint
((string-equal (substring buffer-file-name -3) ".js")
(concat (getenv "windir")
"\\system32\\cscript.exe c:\\users\\cheeso\\bin\\jslint-for-wsh.js "
filename))
;; something else - do a typical .exe build
(t
(concat "nmake "
(file-name-sans-extension filename)
".exe")))))
(t
"nmake "))))
(defun cheeso-invoke-compile-interactively ()
"fn to wrap the `compile' function. This simply
checks to see if `compile-command' has been previously set, and
if not, invokes `cheeso-guess-compile-command' to set the value.
Then it invokes the `compile' function, interactively."
(interactive)
(cond
((not (boundp 'cheeso-local-compile-command-has-been-set))
(cheeso-guess-compile-command)
(set (make-local-variable 'cheeso-local-compile-command-has-been-set) t)))
;; local compile command has now been set
(call-interactively 'compile))
;; in lieu of binding to `compile', bind to my monkeypatched function
(global-set-key "\C-x\C-e" 'cheeso-invoke-compile-interactively)
I tried doing this as "before advice" for the compile function but couldn't get it to work satisfactorily. So I defined a new function and bound it to the same keystroke combination I have been using for compile.
EDIT there is now "smarter-compile.el" which takes this idea one step further.
In the recent years, Clang became an important part of the Emacs C++ support. Atila Neves had a talk on CppCon 2015:
"Emacs as a C++ IDE"
It is a 16 minute talk, where he shows solutions for the following topics:
Jump to definition
Auto-completion
On-the-fly syntax highlighting
Find file in project
Slides can be found here.
On documentation lookup: that depends on your programming language(s).
C libraries and system calls are typically documented in man pages. For that you can use M-x man. Some things may be documented better in info pages; use M-x info.
For elisp itself, use C-h f. For python, use >>> help(<function, class, module>) in the interpreter.
I find that most other languages offer documentation in html form. For that, try an embedded browser (I use w3m). Set your BROWSER environment variable to a wrapper script around emacsclient -e "(w3m-goto-url-new-session \"$#\")" (on *nix), in case something might open a browser and you want it opened inside emacs.
Try lsp-mode. Now you can use other IDE functionality inside emacs connecting to server. Look for more info: lsp-mode
In the Unix or X windows style, I don't know that there is an integrated IDE that works for everything.
For interacting with debuggers, just one component of an IDE, consider realgud. The other thing it has that I find useful are parsers for location messages, so that if you have a call stack trace and want to edit at a particular place in the callstack, this front-end interface will can do that.
By far this program could use improvement. But then it could also use people working on it to improve it.
Disclaimer: I work on realgud