I am experiencing a problem while doing research on responsive design.
Most of the responsive sites I am viewing show up the same on iphone and when the browser window is small.
But Paypal.com in a very small browser window (to simulate iphone) does not look the same as the website on the iphone, which seems to be responsive. (Screenshot links provided below).
Can anyone explain why they are viewing differently?
Screenshot on small browser window: http://i1068.photobucket.com/albums/u450/vs-works/paypal-on-iphone_zps0ad2f164.png
Screenshot on iphone: http://i1068.photobucket.com/albums/u450/vs-works/paypal-smallbrowserwindow_zps968aa79f.png
They could be doing two things.
1) sending different html depending on the user agent
or
2) redirecting to a mobile site
Either way they are detecting the client somehow ( likely by reading the user agent string ) and then serving the content accordingly.
What you are used to is responsive design using a liquid layout and css media queries.
It's definitely easier to develop and maintain a single code base. However you could serve browser/app/device specific content using the user agent string. Each method has it's merits.
For a company the size of Paypal there are other things to consider especially around regulations on what content has to be presented ( legally ) and how branding works. So it might be better for them to have different sites for different devices.
Related
We are going to redevelop one website we developed as an ASP.NET website to be a mobile one.
So, I'm wondering how does the development of a mobile website differ from a normal one?
Also, what is the best approach to do this taken in consideration that this mobile website will be browsed mainly from iPhone?
There are a number of differences between a mobile device and a standard computer.
The screens are much smaller (fewer pixels to display your page). You should put fewer elements on each page.
They are typically viewed in portrait mode (narrow display - narrow page). You should plan on using the full width of the screen instead of setting a fixed page width like most people do on standard web pages.
People use finger gestures to manipulate the page instead of a mouse (buttons/links should be larger)
They can include additional features such as geo-location, telephone, etc. that you can incorporate into your app to be easier to use. There are some libraries available to help you use these, such as jQuery Mobile.
Users are concerned about battery life plus the CPU tends to be slower. Make sure you keep animations and client side processing to a minimum.
Users are concerned about data usage. Keep ajax calls to a minimum (don't ask the server for data every few seconds!) and use graphics sparingly (it's better to use html/CSS to make the page attractive).
Flash isn't supported on iPhone and is not well supported on other devices. However, most mobile devices have decent support for HTML5, so you can typically use that instead.
Users on smartphones are used a different experience.
In addition to Brian's answer I'd add:
Screens are not resized but scrolled, however sides scrolling is not generally a good experience
Screens orientations can change, but the same scrolling rules apply
Consumers are used App like behaviour and as such less information with backwards and forwards between pages is common and between sites
Consumers generally have data concerns so data traffic needs to be minimised
Controls/buttons/selections/data entry need to optimised for hand gestures - for example think of what happens with the keyboard pops up to allow data entry, how much screen is available - can the see all their input easily if they need to?
I suggest that for developing a mobile website is to use the target smartphone for a few weeks to understand how the device is used in the real world.
I'm afraid you cannot use current asp-View to mobile especially for iPhone. There's special control set for iphone development - componentone.
If you web application is based on MVC or MVP patterns then moving will be not difficult.
Recently we have developed a site for iphone users, we are using asp.net/sql for normal site.
But when you look at mobile sites, mobile normally have small screens and some time optimization problem.
We use jqtouch for mobile development. A JQuery plugin for mobile web development on the iPhone,Android, iPod Touch, and other forward-thinking devices.
Learning Video
Getting started
Establish the context for the mobile site: is there subset of information that is more relevant to your mobile users? Maybe your regular site has apps that are irrelevant on mobile devices? Either way, you should create your mobile site separately in a mobile folder! You can then use a sub-domain to reach it: for example, http://m.mysite.com
You can use a combination of CSS Media Queries and 51degrees.Mobi to detect browser features and render the correct size layout depending on which type of device the user has.
http://html5boilerplate.com/
http://www.modernizr.com/ (this is included in HTM5 Boilerplate)
http://51degrees.codeplex.com/
Do not make the stupid mistake of following current fads like "Responsive Web Design" which attempts to squeeze a desktop version of a website into a mobile screen. Above links should get you started.
When i create web app for all mobile devices, what are all things need to follow,
Is it enough to create single html app for all device?
Or, create every single app for a device based on web browser?
Is there any Framework has overcome above mentioned issues?
Thanks in advance,
sri
No - different phone browser have different levels of HTML compliance. Compare iPhone/Android browser with, say, a 3 year old Nokia phone (that most corporate users probably have to use)
No - there are far too many browser/device/operator combinations for you to write individual web apps. This is known as the mobile web fragmentation problem.
Luckily yes - have a look at http://wurfl.sourceforge.net/ or http://deviceatlas.com/. These frameworks let you write one web app (within some limits). These frameworks will recognise the browser (through the User Agent) and output the most appropriate HTML for that device. They can also deal with issues like resizing images for lower end devices.
You need to be aware of the screen size as i think it's bad form to have to scroll left and right as well as up and down.
also, keep the page sizes small as your page may not be the only one open so you want to give users the ability to open more than a single page. also helps in speed and keeping the cost for the user down.
remember to have text size at a readable scale as mobiles are used not only stationary but also when in motion and being bumped around.
My wish is to know how I can program a mobile website, that fit to all mobile phones.
Are there any special approaches to recognize a device and render the code according to it?
Which tools and coding languages are required?
My first thought was to hold the website in XML, which would be parsed depending on the device.
You have to consider old phones, even devices with only wap support.
For example: The mobile website has to recognize Nokia N75 and render/send the code that looks optimal for this device. Same thing with an iPhone or a Motorola Razr.
There are all sorts of problems associated with developing mobile websites. Doing it well takes a lot of time and effort, as phones have such varying support of web standards. There are tools that do it for you, such as the Mobile Web Toolkit and Vodafone's PartnerMl. These tend to force you to write your pages using dedicated XML tags which describe a limited set of elements and styles that can be rendered on the page. The phone requests these xml pages, and the server side software intercepts the request, examines the type of phone (the User Agent), and serves back markup appropriate to that phone. The disadvantage of this system is that it is very inflexible; you are limited to the set of XML elements that the tool supplies, rather than the full flexibility of HTML.
If you want to do it yourself, essentially, you have to do the following.
Using server-side code, examine the User Agent in the Http Header. This tells you what kind of phone/browser made the request
Output appropriate markup and CSS for that user agent.
Useful tools are the User Agent Switcher add-in for Firefox. Using this, you can, for instance, visit the BBC's website, pretending to be various devices. You will see that the BBC outputs 3 or 4 versions of its markup, as well as 3 or 4 different versions of the CSS, depending on the user agent.
mobiForge contains useful information. WURFL and DeviceAtlas are databases that allow you to determine the capabilities of the device that has made the request.
You will quickly realise that you will have to keep your design simple, and it's best not to rely on Javascript, as only the most modern phones can handle it well.
XML is the way to go.
From there, you mosey on to parsing out and acting upon the Agent tags in the request.
From there you can choose (assuming the device supports it), having the device render it via XSLT, or you can apply the XSLT on your end and stream down the appropriate markup language for the device.
In the end, you end up with a specific "rendering" per device. Ideally, the more compatible the devices are with normal browsers, the close the final XSLT is to each other. But you'll still likely have a version for each device that you support.
The beauty of this is that you can add devices incrementally, as time and demand permits. And as devices converge, you gain value by being able to converge your renderings. Also, your back end stays the same no matter what.
Finally, it also works great for non-mobile as well.
Yea, it's a burden to support the different devices, but that's just a truth of the marketplace.
One way is to use strict html with very clear semantics and minimum of css tricking. Do only use relative measures (for example em and %). Trust the browsers default values, because they are in one way optimal for every device, more or less.
Nowadays there isn't exist good tools to do this.
A good practice is to respect the different W3C standards about the accessibility (like the WCAG, the XHTML, etc).
If you made your web site the most accessible as possible it'll be more adaptable. (independently from device, screen size, with or without screen touch...)
If you want more information you can read one of my article about the web accessibility here if you want: Guideline to move a website on a mobile device.
However you can use some meta tags to allow the web browser of the phone to adjust the content like this for the iPhone:
<meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width">
You might wanna check out WURFL
Is there a way for Mobile Safari to recognize a site meant for mobile phones and automatically zoom in? How does that work on other phones and browsers?
I'd like to avoid looking at user_agent and sending a different page for each mobile browser.
See the configuring the viewport part of the Apple web-app developer guide.
I just noticed that if you have your body or main wrapper div height set to 100%, this can mess with how far out it zooms/renders on a mobile browser. Confirmed this in mobile safari and android's chrome browser. Once I set the #siteWrapper height from 100% to auto, it then rendered at a much better scale.
(height 100% on a main wrapper is often used with sticky footers.)
Sites can recognize a mobile browser and produce output accordingly, that's usually the desired way.
Safari will detect the width and zoom-to-fit, but beyond that...
You can avoid having different pages based on User Agent by using conditional CSS. Apple actually has some very good documentation on creating web pages that can support Safari on the iPhone along with desktop browsers.
I would recommend starting with reading iPhone Human Interface Guidelines for Web Applications. This will give you a good start in using conditional CSS to customize pages on the basis of device characteristics (such as screen size) rather than User Agent.
I want to allow our main application to generate document files that can be easily read on the iphone, or other smart phones. The easiest way to do this, I think, is to create a simple HTML file and use javascript to show / hide different bits of it. For example, when the user clicks / touches "section 1", the section expands to show its full details; otherwise, it will remain collapsed to save space.
What guidelines should I follow when creating this file? I've done a little research and arrived at the following:
The iphone has a native resolution of 320x480, but only about 320x400 is visible for a web page.
Other smartphones have resolutions from 160x120 (probably not high enough to bother with) up to 320x240 and some even have 480x640.
These are useful for deciding how to style and arrange the HTML output, for example. Are there any other useful guidelines to work with? For example:
1) How big / small should I make things to let the user have a large enough 'target area'?
2) How can I get the file onto the iphone? Would the user have to drag and drop it via USB?
3) What size of fonts can I use before it gets too small to read?
etc etc. I don't actually have an iphone to test on, which makes this a little more problematic.
Thanks for your help!
I don't know about other smart phones, but the only way your file is going to get onto the iPhone is via the web browser, email, or a custom application that you write. There is no general mechanism for uploading files to the iPhone.
It's surprisingly easy to read even fairly small text on the iPhone, and the gesture-based zooming makes it very easy to zoom in and out.
If you're going to provide your documents through ASP.NET you might want to check this out:
http://mdbf.codeplex.com/.
It allows you to detect what kind of smartphone did the request, you can then check out the capabilities (screen-resolution, color-display, screen-pixels height... etc.)
Most mobile browsers render XHTML-MP (XHTML Mobile Profile). You can get away with rendering that.
iPhones (and other WebKit phones like Android) support the viewport meta tags which can make the experience more tailored to that phone screen size. You can learn about these in the iPhone web page creation docs from Apple.
If you are really interested in supporting a wide range of handsets, you should look at a "multi-serving" technology like WURFL, which will let you abstract a lot of the complexity away from supporting hundreds of handsets. It's sort of yesterday's technology though, since modern mobile browsers render most web pages just fine.
I'm not sure how current this is, but Yahoo says that one of the restrictions for an iPhone is that it won't cache files larger that 25k uncompressed. This doesn't affect your display necessarily, but it could affect your performance and so you may want to take it into consideration for your design.