Generic Swift Protocol inside Generic Controller - swift

Question

Is it possible to have generic inside generic?
I have this protocol
public protocol ListViewModelProtocol {
typealias ViewModel
typealias Cell
func titleForHeaderInSection(section: Int) -> String?
func numberOfSections() -> Int
func numberOfRowsInSection(section: Int) -> Int
func viewModelAtIndexPath(indexPath: NSIndexPath) -> ViewModel
}
I also have base ListViewModel that implements this protocol
public class BaseListViewModel<T, U> : ListViewModelProtocol {
}
But already here it says that my ListViewModelProtocol is not implemented. How can I set T and U to be of specific class inside protocol? Because if I write this in protocol
typealias ViewModel: CustomClass
typealias Cell: CustomCell
Its still not working.
My goal is to subclass BaseListViewModel like
public class TestListViewModel : BaseListViewModel<TestCellViewModel, TestTableViewCell> {
}
Then I could just do this in my BaseViewController
public class BaseViewController<T: ListViewModelProtocol>: UITableViewController {
}
And in some subclass ViewController do this:
public class CustomViewController: BaseViewController<TestListViewModel> {
}
and that way CustomViewController would "get" TestCellViewModel and TestTableViewCell (actually its BaseViewController).
But of course this is not working as I expected. What am I missing? Or I have to define typealias for ListViewModelProtocol in every class that implements it or uses it as generic type? Which means I would have to define ViewModel and Cell of ListViewModelProtocol in both BaseListViewModel class and BaseViewController class, but thats not so generic since I just want to put base types of those in protocol and thats it.
Or maybe there is something wrong with my approach and I should implement this differently?
Any suggestions are useful. Thanks
EDIT
I have managed to fix this but I have another problem.
public class BaseViewController<T: ListViewModelProtocol>: UITableViewController {
var dataSource: T?
}
This datasource is used inside UITableViewDataSource methods by calling its own methods (see ListViewModelProtocol methods). Everything is working fine but when some custom controller:
Controller: BaseViewController<TestListViewModel>
is being deinitialized I get EXC_BAD_ACCESS error. If I put
deinit {
self.dataSource = nil
}
it works but I would like to know why I need to set it to nil.
Thanks.

Answer 1

typealias keyword has more than one meaning ...
// protocol can't be generic
protocol P {
// here typealias is just placeholder, alias
// for some unknown type
typealias A
func foo(a:A)->String
}
// C is generic
class C<T>:P {
// here typealias define the associated type
// in this example it is some generic type
typealias A = T
func foo(a: A) -> String {
return String(a)
}
}
let c1 = C<Int>()
print(c1.foo(1)) // 1
let c2 = C<Double>()
print(c2.foo(1)) // 1.0
// D is not generic!!!
class D: C<Double> {}
let d = D()
print(d.foo(1)) // 1.0
Update, to answer the question from discussion
class Dummy {}
protocol P {
// here typealias is just placeholder, alias
// for some inknown type
typealias A : Dummy
func foo(a:A)->String
}
// C is generic
class C<T where T:Dummy>:P {
// here typealias define the associated type
// in this example it is some generic type
typealias SomeType = T
func foo(a: SomeType) -> String {
return String(a)
}
}
class D:Dummy {}
let c = C<D>()
print(c.foo(D())) // D
and
// now next line doesn't compile
let c1 = C<Int>() // error: 'C' requires that 'Int' inherit from 'Dummy'

Answer 2

If you want to implement a protocol with associated types you have to set these associated types in the your generic implementation:
public class BaseListViewModel<T, U> : ListViewModelProtocol {
typealias ViewModel = T
typealias Cell = U
// implement the methods as well
}