Unable to remove item from hash table - powershell

Question

In Powershell, I have a hash table that contains data similar to this -
Name Value
---- -----
1-update.bat 1
2-update.bat 2
3-update.bat 3
3.1-update.bat 3.1
4-update.bat 4
I also have an variable that contians a number, for example 3
What I would like to do is loop through the array and remove any entry where the value is less than or equal to 3
I'm thinking that this will be easy, especially as the docs say that has tables contain a .remove method. However, the code I have below fails, yeilding this error -
Exception calling "Remove" with "1" argument(s): "Collection was of a
fixed size."
Here is the code that I used -
$versions = #{}
$updateFiles | ForEach-Object {
$versions.Add($_.name, [decimal]($_.name -split '-')[0])
}
[decimal]$lastUpdate = Get-Content $directory\$updatesFile
$versions | ForEach-Object {
if ( $_.Value -le $lastUpdate ) {
$versions.Remove($version.Name)
}
}
I first tried to loop $versions in a different manner, trying both the foreach and for approaches, but both failed in the same manner.
I also tried to create a temporary array to hold the name of the versions to remove, and then looping that array to remove them, but that also failed.
Next I hit Google, and while I can find several similar questions, none that answer my specific question. Mostly they suggest using a list (New-Object System.Collections.Generic.List[System.Object]), whcih from what I can tell is of no help to me here.
Is anyone able to suggest a fix?

Answer 1

Here you go, you can use .Remove(), you just need a clone of the hashtable so that it will let you remove items as you enumerate.
[hashtable]$ht = #{ '1-update.bat'=1;'2-update.bat'=2;'3-update.bat'=3;'3.1-update.bat'=3.1; '4-update.bat'=4 }
#Clone so that we can remove items as we're enumerating
$ht2 = $ht.Clone()
foreach($k in $ht.GetEnumerator()){
if([decimal]$k.Value -le 3){
#notice, deleting from clone, then return clone at the end
$ht2.Remove($k.Key)
}
}
$ht2
Notice I've cast the original variable too so that it's explicitly a hash table, may not be required, but I like to do it to at least keep things clear.

Answer 2

It looks like you just confused ForEach-Object with foreach but only halfway (maybe it was foreach before and you converted it).
You can't send a [hashtable] directly to ForEach-Object; the $_ in that case will just refer to the single [hashtable] you sent in. You can do:
foreach ($version in $versions.GetEnumerator()) {
$version.Name
$version.Value
}
or you can do something like this:
$versions.Keys | ForEach-Object {
$_ # the name/key
$versions[$_] # the value
$versions.$_ # also the value
}

Answer 3

$ht.Keys # list all keys
$ht[$_] # take an element of hastable
$ht.Remove($_) # remove an element of hastable by his key
what you want:
$ht.Keys | ? { $ht[$_] -le 3 } | %{$ht.Remove($_) }

Answer 4

You need to create a temporary array to hold the name/key of the versions to remove, and then looping that array to remove them from hash table:
$versionKeysToRemove = $versions.Keys | Where-Object { $versions[$_] -le $lastUpdate }
$versionKeysToRemove | ForEach-Object { $versions.Remove($_) }
Or shorter:
($versions.Keys | ? { $versions[$_] -le $lastUpdate }) | % { $versions.Remove($_) }
Please note the parentheses.