Entity Framework: partially update record not working - entity-framework

I have the following set up:
All instances are injected, UnitOfWork and DataContext are singletons.
I want to do a partial update of a record.
In the generic repository, I have the following code in my update statement:
dbSet.Attach(entity);
if (updatedProperties != null)
{
foreach (var property in updatedProperties)
{
unitOfWork.DataContext.Entry<TEntity>(entity).Property(property).IsModified = true;
}
}
In my update method, I accept a List of string with the updated fields.
This method is called from the usermanager with the following code:
userRepo.Update(origUser, updatedProperties);
if(processToDB)
{
unitOfWork.SaveChanges();
}
The variable processToDB is set to true. I step into the code, I see in the changetracker that the entity is there, but the update never happens.
So, what fixes this for me, but I don't find this a good fix, is calling the SaveChanges method directly from the Update method in the generic repository:
dbSet.Attach(entity);
if (updatedProperties != null)
{
foreach (var property in updatedProperties)
{
unitOfWork.DataContext.Entry<TEntity>(entity).Property(property).IsModified = true;
}
unitOfWork.SaveChanges(); //added
}
Why doesn't it work when calling the savechanges on the user manager, it is after all the samen unitOfWork and DataContext (because they are singletons).

You don't need to set IsModified for each entity properties. Use AutoDetectChangesEnabled property and set as true while initialize your EF model as
DbContext.Configuration.AutoDetectChangesEnabled = true;
It will make EF to track changes on your entity object. You may check it by using
unitOfWork.DataContext(entity).State == EntityState.Modifed.
If the above condition get paced then update your entity.

Related

Update object using only DbSet

I'm trying to apply the unit of work pattern as described in this blog, but have bumped into the following problem: If I inject the associated DbSet into the repo only, e.g.
public ArticleRepository(DbSet<Article> articles)
{
this.articles = articles;
}
then how do I update records or set their status to modified?
Before I used
public void Update(Article article)
{
this.context.Entry(article).State = EntityState.Modified;
}
but with the new approach I don't have access to DbContext anymore. Neither DbSet.Add nor DbSet.Attach will work here, so how can I update the object in the context?
System.Data.Entity.Migrations.IDbSetExtensions contains the IDbSet extension AddOrUpdate<TEntity>. This will update the entity.
Some people like the advantage of not knowing whether they are adding a new entity or changing an existing one.
However, if you really want an error if you are updating an item that is not added yet, take a look at the Source Code of IDbSetExtensions.AddOrUpdate
Here you can see that the function first checks if the item exists and depending on the result adds or updates it as follows:
var existing = set.SingleOrDefault
(Expression.Lambda<Func <TEntity, bool>> (matchExpression, new[]
{parameter}));
if (existing != null)
{ // entity exists: update it
foreach (var keyProperty in keyProperties)
{
keyProperty.Single().SetValue
(entity, keyProperty.Single().GetValue (existing, null), null);
}
internalSet.InternalContext.Owner.Entry(existing)
.CurrentValues.SetValues (entity);
}
else
{ // not existing entity: Add it
internalSet.Add(entity);
}
If you don't want the AddOrUpdate, but really only an update, consider Creating your own Extension method for IDbSet. See Extension Methods (C# Programming Guide)

EF6 Change tracking

I was implementing audit in my EF 6 database by adding a ModifiedDate property in the entity base and tried to override SaveChanges() by adding the below code (Taken from https://stackoverflow.com/a/6282472/82152)
public class Session : ISession
{
public DbContext _context;
public Session(DbContext context)
{
_context = context;
}
.
.
.
public int SaveChanges()
{
var context = ((IObjectContextAdapter)_context).ObjectContext;
var objectStateEntries =
from e in context.ObjectStateManager.GetObjectStateEntries(EntityState.Modified)
where
e.IsRelationship == false &&
e.Entity != null &&
typeof(ModelBase).IsAssignableFrom(e.Entity.GetType())
select e;
foreach (var entry in objectStateEntries)
{
var modelBase = entry.Entity as ModelBase;
modelBase.LastModifiedDate = DateTime.Now;
}
return _context.SaveChanges();
}
After I changed one of the entity properties, and called SaveChanges - I could see that none of the objectStateEntries were marked as EntityState.Modified. It was all marked as EntityState.Unchanged.
Now after doing some reading, I changed my SaveChanges method to do context.DetectChanges(); after the first line - and it all worked. I tested a case where the entity property changed and another case where the entity property did not change, and it worked perfectly.
Now my concern is
Although my current solution works, would it take a performance hit ?
Why doesn't context.Configuration.AutoDetectChangesEnabled=true do the job of tracking the change automatically from property changes ?
You're not overriding SaveChanges(). You're creating a new wrapper class, and creating a SaveChanges method, and then trying to call SaveChanges() of your wrapped context. That's something totally different from overriding SaveChanges(). If you read the documentation for AutoDetectChangesEnabled You will find that it says this:
Gets or sets a value indicating whether the DetectChanges() method is called automatically by methods of DbContext and related classes. The default value is true.
So what it means is that DetectChanges() gets called when you call methods of the DbContext, which is something you are not doing. You ARE calling a method of the ObjectContext, which is not part of the DbContext (DbContext inherits from it), thus calling this method wouldn't trigger a DetectChanges() call.

EF 6 OriginalValues lost when using Attach method

I have the following Update generic method for my entities:
public void Update < T > (T entity) where T: class {
DbEntityEntry dbEntityEntry = DbContext.Entry(entity);
if (dbEntityEntry.State == System.Data.Entity.EntityState.Detached) {
DbContext.Set < T > ().Attach(entity);
}
dbEntityEntry.State = System.Data.Entity.EntityState.Modified;
}
After SaveChanges() the data is successfully updated in the DB.
Now I nee to implement and Audit Log before SaveChanges() but I noticed that CurrentValues are equal to OriginalValues:
// For updates, we only want to capture the columns that actually changed
if (!object.Equals(dbEntry.OriginalValues.GetValue<object>(propertyName), dbEntry.CurrentValues.GetValue<object>(propertyName))){
//here I add a new Audit Log entity
}
Any clue on how to solve this? Or is there a better way to do it in Entity Framework 6?
If you are using a disconnected entity, you can set originals values without affect entity instance values, adapt this method at you needs
public static void LoadOriginalValues(this WorkflowsContext db, DbEntityEntry entity)
{
var props = entity.GetDatabaseValues();
foreach (var p in props.PropertyNames)
{
if (entity.Property(p).IsModified)
{
entity.Property(p).OriginalValue = props[p];
}
}
}
The original values are recovered from the entity itself. If the entity is being tracked by a context, this information is available.
In your case, you're using a disconected entity, so there is no change tracking, and the entity doesn't have the original values.
SO, in this case, if you need the original values there is no other option than getting them from the DB, and compare them, one by one.
If you want to get an entity that behaves as if it had been tracked by the context you can use a context to read the entity from the DB, and use something like ValueInjecter to automatically set the property values from the disconected entity into the tracked entity.

DbContext AutoDetectChangesEnabled set to false detecting changes

I'm a bit stumped. From what I've read setting the DbContext.AutoDetectChangesEnabled to false should disable change tracking requiring one to call DbContext.DetectChanges in order to identify changes to be sent to the database.
However, it is clear from my logs below that the changes are being registered by dbContexts change tracker, even with the setting set to false.
Am I missing something?
Entity Framework Version: 5.0.0.0
DbContext class
public class ProjectContext : DbContext {
public DbSet<Project> Projects {get;set;}
}
Controller class
private ProjectContext db = new ProjectContext();
public method(){
Project p = new Project("uniqueName");
db.Configuration.AutoDetectChangesEnabled = false;
db.Projects.Add(p);
DebugChangeTracker();
db.SaveChanges();
db.Projects.First().ProjectName = "a differentName!";
DebugChangeTracker();
db.SaveChanges();
}
Logging method
private void DebugChangeTracker()
{
var path = "C:\\mypath\\";
path = path + Util.GetMsSinceEpoch().ToString() + "changeTracker.log";
using (StreamWriter sw = new StreamWriter(path))
{
var changeTracker = db.ChangeTracker;
var entries = changeTracker.Entries();
foreach (var x in entries)
{
var name = x.Entity.ToString();
var state = x.State;
sw.WriteLine("");
sw.WriteLine("***Entity Name: " + name +
"is in a state of " + state);
var currentValues = x.CurrentValues;
sw.WriteLine("***CurrentValues***");
PrintPropertyValues(currentValues,sw);
if (state != EntityState.Added)
{
sw.WriteLine("***Original Values***");
PrintPropertyValues(x.OriginalValues,sw);
}
}
}
}
First log
***Entity Name: Models.Projectis in a state of Added
***CurrentValues***
ProjectId:0
ProjectName:uniqueName
Second Log
***Entity Name: Models.Projectis in a state of Modified
***CurrentValues***
ProjectId:1
ProjectName:uniqueName
***Original Values***
ProjectId:1
ProjectName:a differentName!
Setting AutoDetectChangesEnabled to false doesn't disable change tracking. (That's what the AsNoTracking() extension method would do.) It just disables the automatic call of DetectChanges that would otherwise occur in many DbContext API methods.
But DetectChanges isn't the only method that participates in change tracking. However, if you don't call it manually at the right places where it is needed the tracked entity states are incomplete or wrong leading to incorrectly saved data.
In your case the state Added in the first part of your method is expected, even with AutoDetectChangesEnabled set to false because you only call db.Projects.Add(p). (The line is missing in your code btw, but I guess it's just a copy and paste error.) Calling a method from the DbContext API tracks changes correctly and the states in the tracker will be correct if the state was correct before the call to Add.
Or in other words: Calling an API method doesn't turn a correct state into a wrong state. But: If AutoDetectChangesEnabled is false it also won't turn a wrong state into a correct state which would be the case if AutoDetectChangesEnabled is true.
However, in the second part of your method you are just changing a POCO property value. After this point the change tracker state is wrong (Unchanged) and without a call to DetectChanges (manually or - if AutoDetectChangesEnabled is true - automatically in ChangeTracker.Entries or SaveChanges) it will never be adjusted. The effect is that the changed property value is not saved to the database.
In the last section mentioning the state Unchanged I'm refering to my own test (and also to what I would expect). I don't know and can't reproduce why you have state Modified.
Sorry, if this sounds all a bit confusing. Arthur Vickers can explain it better.
I find automatic change detection and the behaviour when disabling it rather difficult to understand and to master and I usually don't touch the default (AutoDetectChangesEnabled = true) for any tracked changes that are more complex than the simplest things (like bulk adding entities in a loop, etc.).
If someone looking for AutoDetectChangesEnabled in Entity Framework Core you can find it under ChangeTracker insted of Configuration
Usage like:
context.ChangeTracker.AutoDetectChangesEnabled = false;
//Do something here
context.PriceRecords.Add(newPriceRecord);
context.ChangeTracker.AutoDetectChangesEnabled = true;
according to Entity Framework Automatic Detect Changes's Article
they said:
you may get significant performance improvements by turning it off in some cases
look at this example from that article
using (var context = new BloggingContext())
{
try
{
context.Configuration.AutoDetectChangesEnabled = false;
// Make many calls in a loop
foreach (var blog in aLotOfBlogs)
{
context.Blogs.Add(blog);
}
}
finally
{
context.Configuration.AutoDetectChangesEnabled = true;
}
}
This code avoids unnecessary calls to DetectChanges that would have occurred while calling the DbSet.Add and SaveChanges methods.

Entity Framework - Auditing activity

My database has a 'LastModifiedUser' column on every table in which I intend to collect the logged in user from an application who makes a change. I am not talking about the database user so essentially this is just a string on each entity. I would like to find a way to default this for each entity so that other developers don't have to remember to assign it any time they instantiate the entity.
So something like this would occur:
using (EntityContext ctx = new EntityContext())
{
MyEntity foo = new MyEntity();
// Trying to avoid having the following line every time
// a new entity is created/added.
foo.LastModifiedUser = Lookupuser();
ctx.Foos.Addobject(foo);
ctx.SaveChanges();
}
There is a perfect way to accomplish this in EF 4.0 by leveraging ObjectStateManager
First, you need to create a partial class for your ObjectContext and subscribe to
ObjectContext.SavingChanges Event. The best place to subscribe to this event is inside the OnContextCreated Method. This method is called by the context object’s constructor and the constructor overloads which is a partial method with no implementation:
partial void OnContextCreated() {
this.SavingChanges += Context_SavingChanges;
}
Now the actual code that will do the job:
void Context_SavingChanges(object sender, EventArgs e) {
IEnumerable<ObjectStateEntry> objectStateEntries =
from ose
in this.ObjectStateManager.GetObjectStateEntries(EntityState.Added
| EntityState.Modified)
where ose.Entity != null
select ose;
foreach (ObjectStateEntry entry in objectStateEntries) {
ReadOnlyCollection<FieldMetadata> fieldsMetaData = entry.CurrentValues
.DataRecordInfo.FieldMetadata;
FieldMetadata modifiedField = fieldsMetaData
.Where(f => f.FieldType.Name == "LastModifiedUser").FirstOrDefault();
if (modifiedField.FieldType != null) {
string fieldTypeName = modifiedField.FieldType.TypeUsage.EdmType.Name;
if (fieldTypeName == PrimitiveTypeKind.String.ToString()) {
entry.CurrentValues.SetString(modifiedField.Ordinal, Lookupuser());
}
}
}
}
Code Explanation:
This code locates any Added or Modified entries that have a LastModifiedUser property and then updates that property with the value coming from your custom Lookupuser() method.
In the foreach block, the query basically drills into the CurrentValues of each entry. Then, using the Where method, it looks at the names of each FieldMetaData item for that entry, picking up only those whose Name is LastModifiedUser. Next, the if statement verifies that the LastModifiedUser property is a String field; then it updates the field's value.
Another way to hook up this method (instead of subscribing to SavingChanges event) is by overriding the ObjectContext.SaveChanges Method.
By the way, the above code belongs to Julie Lerman from her Programming Entity Framework book.
EDIT for Self Tracking POCO Implementation:
If you have self tracking POCOs then what I would do is that I first change the T4 template to call the OnContextCreated() method. If you look at your ObjectContext.tt file, there is an Initialize() method that is called by all constructors, therefore a good candidate to call our OnContextCreated() method, so all we need to do is to change ObjectContext.tt file like this:
private void Initialize()
{
// Creating proxies requires the use of the ProxyDataContractResolver and
// may allow lazy loading which can expand the loaded graph during serialization.
ContextOptions.ProxyCreationEnabled = false;
ObjectMaterialized += new ObjectMaterializedEventHandler(HandleObjectMaterialized);
// We call our custom method here:
OnContextCreated();
}
And this will cause our OnContextCreated() to be called upon creation of the Context.
Now if you put your POCOs behind the service boundary, then it means that the ModifiedUserName must come with the rest of data from your WCF service consumer. You can either expose this
LastModifiedUser property to them to update or if it stores in another property and you wish to update LastModifiedUser from that property, then you can modify the 2nd code as follows:
foreach (ObjectStateEntry entry in objectStateEntries) {
ReadOnlyCollection fieldsMetaData = entry.CurrentValues
.DataRecordInfo.FieldMetadata;
FieldMetadata sourceField = fieldsMetaData
.Where(f => f.FieldType.Name == "YourPropertyName").FirstOrDefault();
FieldMetadata modifiedField = fieldsMetaData
.Where(f => f.FieldType.Name == "LastModifiedUser").FirstOrDefault();
if (modifiedField.FieldType != null) {
string fieldTypeName = modifiedField.FieldType.TypeUsage.EdmType.Name;
if (fieldTypeName == PrimitiveTypeKind.String.ToString()) {
entry.CurrentValues.SetString(modifiedField.Ordinal,
entry.CurrentValues[sourceField.Ordinal].ToString());
}
}
}
Hope this helps.
There is a nuget package for this now : https://www.nuget.org/packages/TrackerEnabledDbContext
Github: https://github.com/bilal-fazlani/tracker-enabled-dbcontext