Entity Framework DbContext Update Fails if No Change in Field Values - entity-framework

Question

When we pass our DbContext an object whose values have not changed, and try to perform an Update we get a 500 internal server error.
A user may open a dialog box to edit a record, change a value, change it back and then send the record to the database. Also we provide a Backup and Restore function and when the records are restored, some of them will not have changed since the backup was performed.
I was under the impression that a PUT would delete and re-create the record so I didn't feel there would be a problem.
For example, having checked that the Activity exists my ActivityController is as follows:
var activityEntityFromRepo = _activityRepository.GetActivity(id);
// Map(source object (Dto), destination object (Entity))
_mapper.Map(activityForUpdateDto, activityEntityFromRepo);
_activityRepository.UpdateActivity(activityEntityFromRepo);
// Save the updated Activity entity, added to the DbContext, to the SQL database.
if (await _activityRepository.SaveChangesAsync())
{
var activityFromRepo = _activityRepository.GetActivity(id);
if (activityFromRepo == null)
{
return NotFound("Updated Activity could not be found");
}
var activity = _mapper.Map<ActivityDto>(activityFromRepo);
return Ok(activity);
}
else
{
// The save failed.
var message = $"Could not update Activity {id} in the database.";
_logger.LogWarning(message);
throw new Exception(message);
};
My ActivityRepository is as follows:
public void UpdateActivity(Activity activity)
{
_context.Activities.Update(activity);
}
If any of the fields have changed then we don't get the error. Do I have to check every record for equality before the PUT? It seems unnecessary.
Perhaps I have missed something obvious. Any suggestions very welcome.

Answer 1

There is a lot of code missing here.
In your code you call your SaveChangesAsync (not the EF SaveChangesAsync).
Probably (but there is not the code to be sure) your SaveChangesAsync is something that returns false if there is an exception (and is not a good pattern because you "loose" the exception info) or if DbSet.SaveChangesAsync returns 0.
I think (but there is a lot of missing code) that this is your case. If you don't make any changes, SaveChangesAsync returns 0.
EDIT
The System.Exception is raised by your code (last line). EF never throws System.Exception.