I am new to spring-batch, got few questions:-
I have got a question about the restart. As per documentation, the restart feature is enabled by default. What I am not clear is do I need to do any extra code for a restart? If so, I am thinking of adding a scheduled job that looks at failed processes and restarts them?
I understand spring-batch-admin is deprecated. However, we cannot use spring-cloud-data-flow right now. Is there any other alternative to monitor and restart jobs on demand?
The restart that you mention only means if a job is restartable or not .It doesn't mean Spring Batch will help you to restart the failed job automatically.
Instead, it provides the following building blocks for developers for achieving this task on their own :
JobExplorer to find out the id of the job execution that you want to restart
JobOperator to restart a job execution given a job execution id
Also , a restartable job can only be restarted if its status is FAILED. So if you want to restart a running job that was stop running because of the server breakdown , you have to first find out this running job and update its job execution status and all of its task execution status to FAILED first in order to restart it. (See this for more information). One of the solution is to implement a SmartLifecycle which use the above building blocks to achieve this goal.
Related
I have a job that uses the Kafka Connector Stage in order to read a Kafka queue and then load into the database. That job runs in Continuous Mode, which it has no time to conclude, since it keeps monitoring the Kafka queue in real time.
For unexpected reasons (say, server issues, job issues etc) that job may terminate with failure. In general, that happens after 300 running hours of that job. So, in order to keep the job alive I have to manually look to the job status and then to do a Reset and Run, in order to keep the job running.
The problem is that between the job termination and my manual Reset and Run can pass several hours, which is critical. So I'm looking for a way to eliminate the manual interaction and to reduce that gap by automating the job invocation.
I tried to use Control-M to daily run the job, but with no success: The first day the Control-M called the job, it ran it fine. But in the next day, when the Control-M did an attempt to instantiate the job again it failed (since it was already running). Besides, the Datastage will never tell back Control-M that a job was successfully concluded, since the job's nature won't allow that.
Said that, I would like to hear ideas from you that can light me up.
The first thing that came in mind is to create a intermediate Sequence and then schedule it in Control-M. Then, this new Sequence would call the continuous job asynchronously by using command line stage.
For the case where just this one job terminates unexpectedly and you want it to be restarted as soon as possible, have you considered calling this job from a sequence? The sequence could be setup to loop running this job.
Thus sequence starts job and waits for it to finish. When job finishes, the sequence will then loop and start the job again. You could have added conditions on job exit (for example, if the job aborted, then based on that job end status, you could reset the job before re-running it.
This would not handle the condition where the DataStage engine itself was shut down (such as for maintenance or possibly an error) in which case all jobs end including your new sequence. The same also applies for a server reboot or other situations where someone may have inadvertently stopped your sequence. For those cases (such as DataStage engine stop) your team would need to have process in place for jobs/sequences that need to be started up following a DataStage or System outage.
For the outage scenario, you could create a monitor script (regardless of whether running the job solo or from sequence) that sleeps/loops on 5-10 minute intervals and then checks the status of your job using dsjob command, and if not running can start that job/sequence (also via dsjob command). You can decide whether that script startup would occur at DataSTage startup, machine startup, or run it from Control M or other scheduler.
When spring batch DB failure happens or server is shut down, a spring batch job which was running at that time will be in a unknown started state.
In spring batch admin, we will not see an option to restart the job. Hence we are not able to resume the job.
How to restart the job from last successful commit?
The old discussions suggest that it had to be dealt manually by updating tables. I was manually able to update end time, status in batch step execution and batch job execution tables. Is it really the best option? It may not be practical to do that manually in a prod region.
As mentioned in the Aborting a Job section of the reference documentation, when a server failure happens, the job repository has no way to know that the process running the job died. Hence a manual intervention is required.
How to restart the job from last successful commit?
Change the status of the job to FAILED and restart the job instance, it should continue from where it left off.
I have a batch process, written in PHP and embedded in a Docker container. Basically, it loads data from several webservices, do some computation on data (during ~1h), and post computed data to an other webservice, then the container exit (with a return code of 0 if OK, 1 if failure somewhere on the process). During the process, some logs are written on STDOUT or STDERR. The batch must be triggered once a day.
I was wondering what is the best AWS service to use to schedule, execute, and monitor my batch process :
at the very begining, I used a EC2 machine with a crontab : no high-availibilty function here, so I decided to switch to a more PaaS approach.
then, I was using Elastic Beanstalk for Docker, with a non-functional Webserver (only to reply to the Healthcheck), and a Crontab inside the container to wake-up my batch command once a day. With autoscalling rule min=1 max=1, I have HA (if the container crash or if the VM crash, it is restarted by AWS)
but now, to be more efficient, I decided to move to some ECS service, and have an approach where I do not need to have EC2 instances awake 23/24 for nothing. So I tried Fargate.
with Fargate I defined my task (Fargate type, not the EC2 type), and configure everything on it.
I create a Cluster to run my task : I can run "by hand, one time" my task, so I know every settings are corrects.
Now, going deeper in Fargate, I want to have my task executed once a day.
It seems to work fine when I used the Scheduled Task feature of ECS : the container start on time, the process run, then the container stop. But CloudWatch is missing some metrics : CPUReservation and CPUUtilization are not reported. Also, there is no way to know if the batch quit with exit code 0 or 1 (all execution stopped with status "STOPPED"). So i Cant send a CloudWatch alarm if the container execution failed.
I use the "Services" feature of Fargate, but it cant handle a batch process, because the container is started every time it stops. This is normal, because the container do not have any daemon. There is no way to schedule a service. I want my container to be active only when it needs to work (once a day during at max 1h). But the missing metrics are correctly reported in CloudWatch.
Here are my questions : what are the best suitable AWS managed services to trigger a container once a day, let it run to do its task, and have reporting facility to track execution (CPU usage, batch duration), including alarm (SNS) when task failed ?
We had the same issue with identifying failed jobs. I propose you take a look into AWS Batch where logs for FAILED jobs are available in CloudWatch Logs; Take a look here.
One more thing you should consider is total cost of ownership of whatever solution you choose eventually. Fargate, in this regard, is quite expensive.
may be too late for your projects but still I thought it could benefit others.
Have you had a look at AWS Step Functions? It is possible to define a workflow and start tasks on ECS/Fargate (or jobs on EKS for that matter), wait for the results and raise alarms/send emails...
I'm looking for a way to deploy a pod on kubernetes to run for a few hours each day. Essentially I want it to run every morning at 8AM and continue running until about 5:30 PM.
I've been researching a lot and haven't found a way to deploy the pod with a specific timeframe in mind. I've found cron jobs, but that seems to be to be for pods that terminate themselves, whereas mine should be running constantly.
Is there any way to deploy my pod on kubernetes this way? Or should I just set up the pod itself to run its intended application based on its internal clock?
According to the Kubernetes architecture, a Job creates one or more pods and ensures that a specified number of them successfully terminate. As pods successfully complete, the job tracks the successful completions. When a specified number of successful completions is reached, the job itself is complete.
In simple words, Jobs run until completion or failure. That's why there is no option to schedule a Cron Job termination in Kubernetes.
In your case, you can start a Cron Job regularly and terminate it using one of the following options:
A better way is to terminate a container by itself, so you can add such functionality to your application or use Cron. More information about how to add Cron to the Docker container, you can find here.
You can use another Cron Job to terminate your Cron Job. You need to run a command inside a Pod to find and delete a Pod related to your Job. For more information, you can look through this link. But it is not a good way, because your Cron Job will always have failed status.
In both cases, you need to check with what status your Cron Job was finished and use the correct RestartPolicy accordingly.
It seems you can implement using a cronjob object,
[ https://kubernetes.io/docs/tasks/job/automated-tasks-with-cron-jobs/#creating-a-cron-job ]
I created a simple process by Applicaiton Lab interface in Bluemix Workload Scheduler. I ran my process, but the step didn't proceed and remained in queued status.
How can I proceed the step?
I executed the process by "Run now". The process doesn't have triggers
The step remains "Queued status".
The Process information
There is only one step. The step is "ping www.ibm.com"
Process doesn't have trigger. It is an on-demand process.
There might be a problem with the agent as I can successfully run a simple workload process without any issues. If you are using the Workload Automation Agent that is created for you then you will need to open a support ticket to have the Workload team look at that agent.
reviewing your question I think that a process submitted to the Workload Scheduler service should be a process which will complete: a ping command like the one you are trying to submit, will never complete if not 'killed' using CTRL+C (or called with [-c count] option)