Swift lose precision in decimal formatting - swift

Question

I have an precision issue when dealing with currency input using Decimal type. The issue is with the formatter. This is the minimum reproducible code in playground:
let formatter = NumberFormatter()
formatter.numberStyle = .currency
formatter.isLenient = true
formatter.maximumFractionDigits = 2
formatter.generatesDecimalNumbers = true
let text = "89806.9"
let decimal = formatter.number(from: text)?.decimalValue ?? .zero
let string = "\(decimal)"
print(string)
It prints out 89806.89999999999 instead of 89806.9. However, most other numbers are fine (e.g. 8980.9). So I don't think this is a Double vs Decimal problem.
Edit:
The reason I need to use the formatter is that sometimes I need to deal with currency format input:
let text = "$89,806.9"
let decimal = formatter.number(from: text)?.decimalValue ?? .zero
print("\(decimal)") // prints 89806.89999999999
let text2 = "$89,806.9"
let decimal2 = Decimal(string: text2)
print("\(decimal2)") // prints nil

Answer 1

Using the new FormatStyle seems to generate the correct result
let format = Decimal.FormatStyle
.number
.precision(.fractionLength(0...2))
let text = "89806.9"
let value = try! format.parseStrategy.parse(text)
Below is an example parsing a currency using the currency code from the locale
let currencyFormat = Decimal.FormatStyle.Currency
.currency(code: Locale.current.currencyCode!)
.precision(.fractionLength(0...2))
let amount = try! currencyFormat.parseStrategy.parse(text)
Swedish example:
let text = "89806,9 kr"
print(amount)
89806.9
Another option is to use the new init for Decimal that takes a String and a FormatStyle.Currency (or a Number or Percent)
let amount = try Decimal(text, format: currencyFormat)
and to format this value we can use formatted(_:) on Decimal
print(amount.formatted(currencyFormat))
Output (still Swedish):
89 806,9 kr

Answer 2

I agree that this is a surprising bug, and I would open an Apple Feedback about it, but I would also highly recommend switching to Decimal(string:locale:) rather than a formatter, which will achieve your goal (except perhaps the isLenient part).
let x = Decimal(string: text)!
print("\(x)") // 89806.9
If you want to fix fraction digits, you can apply rounding pretty easily with * 100 / 100 conversions through Int. (I'll explain if it's not obvious how to do this; it works for Decimal, though not Double.)

Answer 3

Following Joakim Danielson Answer see this amazing documentation on the format style
Decimal(10.01).formatted(.number.precision(.fractionLength(1))) // 10.0 Decimal(10.01).formatted(.number.precision(.fractionLength(2))) // 10.01 Decimal(10.01).formatted(.number.precision(.fractionLength(3))) // 10.010
Amazingly detailed documentation

Answer 4

If this is strictly a rendering issue and you're just looking to translate a currency value from raw string to formatted string then just do that.
let formatter = NumberFormatter()
formatter.numberStyle = .currency
let raw = "89806.9"
if let double = Double(raw),
let currency = formatter.string(from: NSNumber(value: double)) {
print(currency) // $89,806.90
}
If there is math involved then before you get to the use of string formatters, I would point you to
Why not use Double or Float to represent currency? and
How to round a double to an int using Banker's Rounding in C as great starting points.

Answer 5

I get my response with double value and remove formatter.generatesDecimalNumbers line to get work.
let formatter = NumberFormatter()
formatter.numberStyle = .currency
formatter.isLenient = true
formatter.maximumFractionDigits = 2
//formatter.generatesDecimalNumbers = true // I removed this line
let text = "$89806.9"
let double = formatter.number(from: text)?.doubleValue ?? .zero // converting as double or float
let string = "\(double)"
print(string) // 89806.9
let anotherText = "$0.1"
let anotherDouble = formatter.number(from: anotherText)?.doubleValue ?? .zero // converting as double or float
let anotherString = "\(anotherDouble)"
print(anotherString) // 0.1