I have an independently written LSP-compliant language server for a custom language and an Xtext framework for that language, as Eclipse plugins. The two work fine independently; the LSP is connected in using LSP4E.
But when I try to connect the Language Server into a project in which Xtext is providing syntax coloring and some parsing checking, it appears that the language server is never started and certainly is not providing the error messages to the Eclipse UI that it does when used by itself. I'm not asking Xtext to create a language server itself.
The goal is to use (and not reimplement) the LS for parsing and type checking and language-aware code navigation, while using Xtext for syntax coloring.
Can anyone point me to a successful use of these two technologies together? or know that they cannot (yet?) be?
Edit: To the comment about checking whether the LS is working. As far as I can tell, the LS is not even started, though it started fine when used alone. Somehow putting Xtexxt into the mix has usurped the connection to the LS or changed it in a way that the launching and use no longer happens.
The LSP4J version installed is (only) Eclipse LSP4J org.eclipse.lsp4j 0.15.0.v20220805-0131 org.eclipse.lsp4j
Xtext's components vary, but basically Eclipse Xtext Xtext 2.28.0.v20220829-0438 org.eclipse.xtext
Related
Why do I have the same suggestions while typing expression?
Example:
I had exactly the same problem. After a week or so, it get really annoying.
basically, as the comments hint to, there are probably multiple linting or intelisense tools. In my case (for python) i had the pylance extension added.
When i disabled this, the problem went away, but features were missing. So i added it back...
For some reason (i dont know why), this fixed the problem !!!
I can only hypothesise that in some way the extension was corrupted. Nevertheless, it worked.
EDIT:
I can also confirm that unchecking this setting appears to work:
Jupyter: Pylance Handles Notebooks
My current system is Windows 11, with python 3.10.
Final edit (8 Dec 2022):
This is resolved here:
Please could you install VS Code 1.74 and the latest Jupyter, PyLance and Python extension and confirm this still exists.
Visual Studio Code provides an API so third-party extensions and built-in modules can contribute suggestions for auto-completion pop-ups. The system is currently designed so suggestions are merely appended—there's no duplicate detection or removal (perhaps because extensions can also take care of sorting suggestions and such algorithm would get on the way). That means that if you have more than one extension or module for a given language you can easily get duplicate entries.
Having several extensions for PHP is not necessarily a bad idea since they can address different needs (for instance, PHP DocBlocker just creates annotations, it doesn't provide auto-completion suggestions) but you have at least two extensions (PHP Intelephense and PHP Intellisense) that do exactly the same things. That's likely to hurt performance (all your workspace files will be scanned several times) and just adds noise.
I suggest you read the extension descriptions carefully to learn what they do exactly and then figure out which ones you need. Remember that extensions can be enabled/disabled in a per-workspace basis.
The following is just my own totally subjective opinion. Among the PHP extensions that provide code intelligence only two of them seem mature enough:
PHP Intelephense
PHP Intellisense
I've tried both. PHP Intelephense works best for me than PHP Intellisense so that's the one I've kept. I've also disabled php.suggest.basic following the installation instructions because basic suggestions didn't add any value to me (they were blind string matching):
Turn off the php.suggest.basic setting for best results.
... as well as taming builtin Emmet support, which was providing really dumb suggestions:
"emmet.showExpandedAbbreviation": "inMarkupAndStylesheetFilesOnly"
YMMV.
TLDR; Installing pre-release version of Jupyter solves (v2022.11...)
Ok, so after some more extensive experimentation I think I found what's causing this in my case. After looking at the processes I noticed that there were two Pylance processes running, and consistently this would only be a problem if I was working in a session with a jupyter notebook open or one that had been opened.
saun89 17740 37.3 0.3 1008004 199492 ? Sl 20:58 0:22 /home/saun89/.vscode-server-insiders/bin/fef85ea792f6627c83024d1df726ca729d8c9cb3/node /home/saun89/.vscode-server-insiders/extensions/ms-python.vscode-pylance-2022.11.32/dist/server.bundle.js --cancellationReceive=file:9178e897a2b78b36bfd167f79b36c3bdad2931d71b --node-ipc --clientProcessId=17651
saun89 18743 257 0.7 1304584 382288 ? Sl 20:59 0:20 /home/saun89/.vscode-server-insiders/bin/fef85ea792f6627c83024d1df726ca729d8c9cb3/node /home/saun89/.vscode-server-insiders/extensions/ms-python.vscode-pylance-2022.11.32/dist/server.bundle.js --cancellationReceive=file:8744a321767eed92821fd737be4dc7dcfb728284e5 --node-ipc --clientProcessId=17651
Pylance basically spins up a service for the workspace, and then spins up a separate service for the notebook.
Output from "Python Language Server" logs:
Disabling Jupyter removes the duplication, and after installing an earlier version of the extension (v2022.4) this appears to have fully resolved the issue. I'm going to go ahead and log the extension bug once I have something reproducible.
As of 11/30/22, Jupyter Extension Pre-Release version v2022.11.1003281132 is the latest version fixes this issue. Click the gear icon next to the extension and you should see "install another version..." Then you can select version v2022.11.1003281132.
I have already set up build and debug environment for Object Pascal inside Visual Studio Code via FPC and GDB, but I just made build process work for programs containing only 1 .pas file via
"command": "fpc",
"args": [ "-g", "-Px86_64", "helloWorld.pas" ],
Now, I need to build quite big Delphi project group (something like solution?) and it contains main project file .groupproj.
Is there a way to build the .groupproj via FPC somehow?
Or at least some workaround like conversion to .lpi and then build via FPC?
Or at least call Delphi compiler/builder from VS Code and build the whole project group via it? (but I don't like this option, because I prefer to not use Delphi)
To get some facts straight for other people that might stumble on this:
FPC supports Delphi source files (.lpr/.dpr, .pp/.pas and .inc). Not Delphi meta information (.dproj/.dof/.bpg/.cfg/.groupproj) which is Delphi version dependent anyway.
Lazarus conversion tool also converts .dfms. Basically it is a .dfm cleaner and Uses clause enhancer, just like some conversion tools between Delphi versions. It by default however also does substitutions that change Delphi code (that works in FPC's Delphi (-Sd) mode) into the objfpc dialect (-S2 mode) preferred by Lazarus . Always make a backup before trying, and check the configuration of the conversion tool thoroughly.
FPC and Delphi commandline parameters are different.
FPC does not support Lazarus metadata formats like .lpi. The Lazarus utility Lazbuild however does support building Lazarus projects from the commandline.
But luckily the basics are the same
a main program or library file files)
a set of unit (.pas files) and include directories (.inc files). FPC differentiates between the two, delphi doesn't.
autocreated forms must be added to the project.
any additional commandline switches like defines to set, range checking optimization options.
So in worst case, examine the Delphi projects (either in IDE or texteditor) for directories and switches and create either a manual buildscript or a lazarus (.lpi) project.
However it is vital to keep in mind that the default FPC mode is NOT Delphi mode, so always when executing FPC make sure you manually enable Delphi mode (-Sd)
Group project support within Lazarus is very new (as in months), and afaik not even in stable versions yet. Though if you create a bunch of .lpis, a batch file/shellscript with a sequence of lazbuild commands on .lpis might do it.
P.s. throw the VSCode under the bus and use Lazarus.
I'm having trouble with a PHP project using Yii framework.
My setup is the following: Win7 + Eclipse4.2 + PDT 3.1 + Yiiclipse PDT extension + WAMP Server with XDEBUG enabled.
Pretty much everything works ok. The debug session starts, it's going through project's index.php source, but when it has to jump to framework's files, it doesn't open them up. I edited source lookup and added framework's local path but it simply cannot find them.
Here is a screenshot: http://img607.imageshack.us/img607/3687/eclipsepdt.png
This isn't necessarily an answer - but your question isn't necessarily a question either, so I feel like this is fair game :D
I've had so many problems with Eclipse PDT + xdebug in the past with debugging, code completion, etc., that I gave up on it a while ago and switched to Netbeans for PHP Debugging. It's now the defacto standard on my development team for debugging PHP; even though we all still have our own favorite editors, when we need to debug we'll still use Netbeans.
Code completion, phpdoc 'tooltips' on completion, and debugging all work flawlessly for me regardless of what platform I'm developing on (Windows, OS X, Linux) and I cannot say the same about Eclipse PDT (code completion would often miss, I'd run into problems or crashes debugging,etc.) in my personal experience.
So, I apologize in advance if this is a non-answer to a non-question - but maybe try out Netbeans?
Are you sure, you can use Xdebug to debug Yii (or any other framework-based) applications at all? Since Yii introduces URL-rewriting based on MVC pattern, I think you can't.
I don't have much experience with Xdebug, but from what I have found I clearly see, that it (along with Eclipse PDT) strongly depends on URL shown in Eclipse's internal browser, when debugging.
So, taking for example an URL from your screenshot:
http://localhost/testdrive/index.php?r=dispozitive
As you mentioned, Eclipse has correctly opened index.php, which is normal, as it is directly referenced in URL and you problably pointed it out as start file in debug configuration window.
Buth going further. How would you like Eclipse to understand, that route dispozitive (where route itself is a completely Yii concept (or similar framework) and Eclipse / Xdebug / PHP knows nothing about it) or that ?r=dispozitive URL parts corresponds to executing protected/SiteController.php file in your file system and calling default actionIndex() from it? So it could know it should open it in IDE and possibly stop execution on there defined breakpoints.
This process and concept (routing) is 100% authored by Yii and done by it internally, so how would you like Eclipse or Xdebug to know anything about it?
As I wrote, I don't have much experience in debugging Yii applications, but from what I have found until know, I clearly see, that you can't debug PHP applications with Xdebug, if they are using any kind of URL-rewriting methods. This technique (debugging with Xdebug) works IMHO only in case of applications, where URL changes directly reflects files in filesystem in your application contents.
EDIT: Additionally, check which version (package) of Eclipse you have? It turns out, that Helios package has some bugs and doesn't stops on breakpoints. Which makes it pretty useless for debugging process. You should consider using Galileo Package Eclipse for PHP Developers instead.
I've got a Android AppEngine Connected Project I'm trying to build using GWT2.4 RequestFactory and Objectify on my Eclipse IDE.
Apparently I need to run the RequestFactory Validation Tool because I'm using ServiceName and ProxyForName annotations (these are required especially when working on the Android client side). My problem is the Eclipse can't validate it and the solution provided at http://code.google.com/p/google-web-toolkit/wiki/RequestFactoryInterfaceValidation#IDE_configuration is enough to make me rip my eyes out.
Since I'm working on a Windows machine, the shell script provided is not very useful. Trying to run Validation Tool from a cmd propt returns the error message:"This tool must be run with a JDK, not a JRE"
Can someone explain how this Tool is supposed to be run? Is there a way to use it as an External Tool in eclipse?
Normally if you follow carefully the instructions in the link you show, and run the GWT Development Mode from Eclipse, the Validation should be done automatically at the time you access the development URL with your browser.
For the record, I've actually had some problems with it, but launching the application several times maked it work.
Well, I ran into the same problem as well. When I tried annotation processing (under Java Compiler-> Annotation processing )was being disabled. So RequestFactoryDeobfuscatorBuilder was not being generated. Try enabling that and rebuilding your project.
I've just recovered from two days of hunting this bug down in a project that used to run validation properly but stopped.
In my case I had a new-ish generic BaseRequestContext and a specific sub-interface that extended it. My parent interface declared a method that didn't match the Locator's exactly (e.g. getThing(T) vs get(T)) and this wasn't reported as an error but did stop the validation tool from completing.
Apt is also removed in Java 8 : http://openjdk.java.net/jeps/117 . So beware.
Switching back to Java 7 will fix the issue if you are using Java 8.
I understood why the error happens sometimes in a project: the compiler was complaining it cannot find the directory .apt . But when I tried to create it manually it was not possible (under windows). I think the validation tool mutes the exception of not being able to create the directory: try renaming .apt in your validation tool calls (do a text search in your project)
Have been trying out Web2Py for a couple of days now and I decided it to be a keeper. But there is one thing that concerns me a lot and that might be a showstopper in the end. I need a nice development environment & setup I can trust and be productive with. Coming from the MS Visual Studio world I'm looking for something with good autocomplete / intellisense + functions for versioning and deployment.
I did some attempts to edit my code in Eclipse but it needs additional setup to run with autocomplete, and for debugging I dont know if it's possible. (Noticed there was a Django project template in Eclipse which is a bit tempting I must say.)
Wing Ide has a instruction on how to get web2py up and running and I am up to testing that one. Not free, but very cheap compared to much in the Windows world.
I also want a good versioning (hg) setup, and preferably a semi-automatic FTP-deployment-method.
What IDE do Web2Py developers use, and how do your setup look like?
A complete setup script for a project in a good IDE would be awesome! (Just like the installation is, one click to get it running 100%).
Pycharm looks good, perhaps that one can add web2py support http://youtrack.jetbrains.net/issue/PY-1648
Thanks a lot!
OS: Windows 7/Windows XP
IDE: NetBeans
Version control: TortoiseHg/NetBeans
Debugger: winpdb
Shell: IPython
Publish: WinSCP/PuTTY/TortoiseHg
Scripts
Once I create a new project in web2py I add a few scripts to my main app folder:
web2py\applications\myapp\DebugWinpdb.bat:
C:\Python25\Scripts\winpdb.bat ..\..\web2py.py -i 127.0.0.1 -p8000 -mypassword
web2py\applications\myapp\DebugShell.bat:
C:\Python25\Scripts\winpdb.bat ..\..\web2py.py -S myapp -M
web2py\applications\myapp\Shell.bat:
python ..\..\web2py.py -S myapp -M
IDE
As others have stated you need to do some extra stuff to get autocomplete/intellisense for web2py no matter what IDE you use.
For me NetBeans was a good compromise between does-everything-if-only-you-can-figure-out-how (Eclipse/PyDev) and does-the-basics-but-few-extras (PyScripter).
NetBeans Setup (Project Properties):
Python Category
Python Platform: Python 2.x (default is Jython)
Run Category
Main Module: web2py.py
Application Arguments: -i 127.0.0.1 -p 8000 -a mypassword
NetBeans Pros:
Tight Mercurial integration
Highlights which lines have been added, changed, or deleted in your source file as you edit it
Selective rollback of individual changes you've made since your last commit
One of the nicest visual diff viewers I have used
Python PEP8 style hints (fully customizable)
Name "foo" is not a valid class name according to your code style (CapitalizedWords)
Name "Bar" is not a valid function name according to your code style (lowercase_with_underscores)
Auto-format hotkey (corrects spacing around operators, etc)
Navigation within source file
semantically indexes current source file
organizes alphabetically by type (Class, method, attribute, etc)
makes even enormous style sheets manageable
NetBeans Cons:
Integrated Debugger doesn't work with web2py (that one really hurts)
Long startup time (but acceptably snappy for me once up and running)
Version Control
I use and highly recommend Mercurial for source control. As mentioned earlier, NetBeans has great support for Mercurial but there are some things I'd just rather do in TortoiseHg.
TortoiseHg Pros:
Shell overlay icons
Repository Explorer
view repos history with graphical display of branching/merging
one stop shop for Incoming, Outgoing, Push, Pull, Update, etc with button for Commit tool
Commit tool
Hunk Selection: cherry pick changes from within a file for more focused Commits
Add, Remove, Diff, Revert, Move, Remove, Forget
TortoiseHg Cons:
No easy way to drop directly into a command line
Bug that regularly prevents files from being removed during commit (waits indef for a lock to be released; running hg addremove from command line is a reliable workaround)
Publishing
I use a combination of WinSCP (for browsing), PuTTY (for terminal commands), and TortoiseHg (for push/pull of my repos) to work with my shared hosting account on Webfaction.
The first thing I do is set up public/private key encryption. If you are having trouble getting this set up between Windows and Linux, try these instructions from Andre Molnar. Short story is you need to generate your private key using ssh-keygen on Linux, copy it down to your Windows machine using WinSCP, then convert it for use with WinSCP and PuTTY.
Then add the following lines to your global mercurial.ini file:
[ui]
ssh = "C:\Program Files\TortoiseHg\TortoisePlink.exe" -ssh -2 -i "c:\path\to\your\privatekey.ppk"
Even if you have to connect to multiple servers, you need only copy your public key to each of the different servers. You'll also want to let WinSCP and PuTTY know where your private key is located, but those are fairly easy to figure out.
Try the new web2py admin interface in trunk. It has a web based mercurial interface and a google deploy interface.
In web2py you can edit applications/admin/models/0.py and set
TEXT_EDITOR = 'amy'
And you will get the web based Amy editor with autocompletion. It is not default because because it does not work with some browsers and because autocompletion is not as good as eclipse. It may work for you.
You can use web2py with Eclipse but you need a minor workaround to let Eclipse know about the web2py environment. It is explained here.
I know other users have used other IDEs with web2py, for example WinIDE and pyCharm. I suggest you ask on the web2py mailing list where people are very helpful.
I'm pretty sure that the 'one-click setup script' to do all that you are looking for does not exist (at the moment). But don't be put off - you can achieve a nice development environment to suit your needs and there are lots of choices.
Although I develop on Windows, I like the setup I have as it's more of a 'Unixy' way of thinking whereby I have a number of tools each doing a specific task. Once you get a workflow setup you can be very productive - although I realise it may look a bit confusing initially coming from a Visual Studio world.
Below I outline what I've settled on. I'm sure others will have their own recommendations. Pick the options you like best.
(There should be hyperlinks to useful software below but I don't have enough reputation to include more than 1 link...)
For developing on Windows I'm enjoying using Pyscripter. It's free, fast (compared to Aptana / Eclipse / Netbeans etc) and has some nice features (dark theme, integrated python console and code explorer to name a few).
To get code completion / intellisense to work for web2py you need to add some code to your model / controller files because of the way web2py works. There are some instructions in this discussion topic on the web2py group.
web2py has a great error ticketing system built in (see the web2py book chapter 3). For more comprehensive debugging, pydb seems to be the way to go. Just put the code below as a breakpoint:
import pydb
pydb.debugger()
and it'll take you to the debugger.
I use TortoiseHg for Mercurial integration and it works wonderfully. Combine that with winscp and you can deploy easily.
Caveats: I work in OS X, and do most of my coding in BBEdit.
That said, I've used both Wing and Komodo IDE for web2py debugging, and they've both worked quite well for me. I haven't tried NetBeans in a while now; when I did the Python support seemed a little rough around the edges. And I've never had the time or patience to come up to speed with Eclipse; it's filed in my mental file cabinet with Emacs, no doubt unjustly to Eclipse and/or Emacs.
(And I'll echo mdipierro's recommendation to try the web2py mailing list; it's really indispensable--one of web2py's strongest points.)
Have you considered using fewer tools? Both Python and web2py don't require a whole lot of code to get a lot accomplished. web2py only adds 10 or 15 new function calls (besides the HTML helpers and validators). You might find that Eclipse and other IDEs actually get in the way. Setting up new apps in web2py is simple through the admin system. Since the new app scaffolding copies the welcome app, you can customize new app setup by editing the welcome app. With Mercurial (or Git, Subversion or Bazaar) you can set up a server on your machine or with one of the public sites and either push or pull updates to your production server. Keep it simple, I say.
we are using web2py framework for all our web application needs and this is our setup :
OS - Ubuntu up-to-date
IDE - Aptana Studio 3.0 with pyDev
Version Control - git
Python 2.7
Browser for developing phase : Chrome
I've found the Wing IDE debugger to be very useful. It's a powerful debugger across the board, and also can be configured to do remote debugging, which is really important when you are running web2py on a no-GUI remote machine (e.g. at Amazon Web Services).